Skygazer's mini normal review, September 2018

[schadd_]

think this is probably a bit on the townsided end and i would maybe make tracker oddnight or 2-shot

icy babysitter is a pretty strong role and gives the person license to play as lurky or scummy as they want to avoid nk which some people r good at. also no reason not to protect a claimed investigative i think - you mention follow the cop which isnt much of a thought in normals (investigative wouldn't ever claim outright, no reason to believe there is or isnt a non-jailing protective) but if an investigative does claim, they will probably be protected (baby death isn't a concern if they would die regardless of being protected) and probably shot as well

you're right that neep only gets 5 clears but the not VT results are valuable as well. scum neighbor it's a non-issue bc neighbor claim is confirmable. goon has to fakeclaim which is big yikes if the tracker is still alive. vanilla cop will have to fakeclaim, claim their real investigates (yikes!) or other known things (flips, neighbors) which can also b problematic with tracker

also town vanilla cop + town neep is uncommon

1-shot vig is still good bc its confirmable - 2 roles that can choose when they confirm themselves is v good if they both survive for a while

[schadd_]

role pm nitpicks:

tracker should say "which player(s) they targeted" since multitasking exists

i like to clarify what gives vanilla cop the vanilla result, i.e. vt and goon. could potentially be an issue in some sorta way especially in light of there being neep

"or when your faction controls half the vote" is getting to be in vogue for mafia wincon - imagine icy baby + vt + goon in lylo and vt gets lynched; that should probably be a scum win but there's no way to make that happen

[schadd_]

i'd /pass that as well

cede to rc on balance which we might wanna talk abt more

[schadd_]

i pass the latest revision! : )