sheepsaysmeep's mini normal review, December 2018

[Performer]

1 Town Rolecop
1 Town Vigilante
1

Town Doctor

Town Non-consecutive Doctor
1 Town Mason Novice Roleblocker
1 Town Mason

8 Town Vanilla

1 Mafia Watcher
1 Mafia 1-shot Strongman
1 Mafia Goon
------------

I think the above proposal is improved over the original one, in terms of balance.

Idea:
For the doctor if you don't want them to consecutively target the same person, you could apply non-consecutive as the modifier for the doctor then.
BUT if the doctor protects on n1, then is roleblocked n2, then decides to protect on n3 and is not blocked - they still can't protect .

[Performer]

A doctor cannot protect against strongman, neither can a roleblocker.

I believe the resolution goes like this....
strongman>roleblocker>doctor
------

Also when you get the chance, can you provide the updated role descriptions along with result messages for rolecop and watcher (in case they're blocked ).

[Performer]

what about cutting the strongman and the novice roleblocker

1 Town Rolecop
1 Town Vig
1 Town Non-Consec Doctor
2 Town Mason
5 VT
1 Mafia Watcher
2 Mafia Goon

i feel like that's loltown enough for it to be acceptably town's fault? and it balances with rolecop having 2 guilties of the 3 mafia instead of 1 of 3?

if thats really a problem that needs to be resolved thoguh im defo cool with those changes

Yeah I'm content with this version as well , after removing strongman and rb.

[Performer]

1 Town Rolecop
1 Town Vig
1 Town 2-shot Jailkeeper
2 Town Mason
5 VT
1 Mafia Watcher
2 Mafia Goon

I think the non-consecutive Doctor has more positive utility than a 2-shot Jailkeeper...the latter can be positive or negative based on who is targeted.

If a Mason claims on d1 and the Jk ends up jailing him 2 nights in a row, that could mean 2 soft confirmed town.

The 2 roles will have different effects as the Doc is simply restricted but positive usage, the Jk can be positive in protection or stopping scum OR negative to town prs.

I would say either is fine , a non-consecutive Doc or a 2-shot Jk....it depends on what your intents of the setup are.

Rc , thoughts?

[Performer]

lmk if you need anything else

Nothing else from me about this setup!