Boonskiies' Large Normal Review

[Empking]

Where does 'Bunyip' come from? And please post the full set up.

[Empking]

Also, I'd probably need to add in rules or somewhere, that if it comes down to 1-1 scum, and both scum would be killed during the night, then it is a joint mafia win, and in the sense of a 1-1-1 kingmaker situation, also a joint mafia win. Ascetic RB/Non Consec Commuter can get around that, so I had to add the both scum would be killed part. I think this is why the Ascetic Rb needs to also be Non-Consecutive.

Why do you want those situations (particularly 1-1-1) to end with a scum win?

[Empking]

To the 1-1-1 thing, I don't necessarily want a scum win there; what is the normal situation for that?

It playing out.

[Empking]

I don't have a problem with the strongmen.

However, a passive role being non-consecutive - turning it into an active role - or being linked to the taking of another action does not seem quite normal to me.

[Empking]

I feel that it is balanced. Can you post everything again?

[Empking]

All the role PMS, and if you made any rule changes, those too.

[Empking]

Your main scum PMs don't seem to suggest that they have a traitor (while the traitor's PMs suggest they know)

[Empking]

/approve