XnadrojX's Mini Normal Review

[borkjerfkin]

totally stylistic, but maybe remove the neighborizer enabler? I think the game is less gimmicky and more interesting without it

[XnadrojX]

When both serial killer and traitor is alive serial killer wins

[XnadrojX]

And the neighbouriser enabler was something put there to prevent the neighbouriser from essentially neighbouriser half the game so can I make it like a 2/3 shot neighbouriser instead?

[Firebringer]

When both serial killer and traitor is alive serial killer wins

If traitor is last mafia alive he is auto endgamed.

[Firebringer]

Mafia Encryption
Mafia Ascetic
Traitor Encryption Enabler

Ascetic Enabler
3-shot Cop
Neighbouriser
Neighbouriser Enabler
Jailkeeper
VT x4

1-shot BP SK

This looks alot better.
I don't know about giving the cop 3 shots though.
2 seems alright.

Everything else seems fine.
I kind of agree theirs a bit too much enablers but I don't think they particularity hurt the game although roles become easier to sort out based on enabler flips.

I think this setup works fine as this

[Firebringer]

And the neighbouriser enabler was something put there to prevent the neighbouriser from essentially neighbouriser half the game so can I make it like a 2/3 shot neighbouriser instead?

This isn't a huge concern most games a full neighborizer gets at most 2 people in their neighborhood.
Average is probably around ~2.4 or something.
With about 4 neighbors or more being exceedingly rare.

Its also not very powerful role, but it can add talk to the game.

[XnadrojX]

And the neighbouriser enabler was something put there to prevent the neighbouriser from essentially neighbouriser half the game so can I make it like a 2/3 shot neighbouriser instead?

This isn't a huge concern most games a full neighborizer gets at most 2 people in their neighborhood.
Average is probably around ~2.4 or something.
With about 4 neighbors or more being exceedingly rare.

Its also not very powerful role, but it can add talk to the game.

I see. I'll change that

[XnadrojX]

Mafia Encrypter
Mafia Ascetic
Traitor Encryption Enabler

Ascetic Enabler
2-shot Cop
3-Shot Neighbouriser
Jailkeeper
VT x5

1-shot BP SK

I think this looks good like this

[XnadrojX]

Since I don't want more than 4 alive people in a PT at the same time, juts in case, im 3-shotting the Neighboursiser

[borkjerfkin]

Yeah i am ok with this. Ascetic is a huge boon here and easily offsets the town power.

[Firebringer]

Mafia Encrypter
Mafia Ascetic
Traitor Encryption Enabler

Ascetic Enabler
2-shot Cop
3-Shot Neighbouriser
Jailkeeper
VT x5

1-shot BP SK

This looks fine if the game didn't have SK...
Unsure of it with SK to be honest.

Anyone have any more thoughts?
Radja? Bork?

[borkjerfkin]

SK adds swing; I'm not sure that it really makes town more disadvantaged

[Firebringer]

Bump I am not the only reviewer here.
Bork think this is fine as is?
Radja?

[borkjerfkin]

At a certain point with an SK, I do kinda go: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

My goalposts for balance with a third party are pretty wide, because it really does come down to: if 2+ crosskills happen, town will probably win. if 0 happen, town will probably lose.

That being said, I think this is within the realms of runnable and don't have an issue approving.

[Radja]

I looked at it again and I'm still not sure.

It should be a fun game so I'm just going to approve this.

[XnadrojX]

So 2/3 reviewers approved? FireBringer do you approve the setup?

[Firebringer]

ehhhhhhhhh.............
I would kind of like it announced the alignment numbers. Though that isn't really normally required.
I just know as a player, I don't like going into a game where suddenly theres an SK.

[borkjerfkin]

I dont think that is an issue we should tackle in the microcosm of this review.

[Firebringer]

If I am the only one who has issue I won't be the one to hold this game off from entering sign ups.

I approve

[Nexus]

Going into signups now.