Mafiascum.net

Primary reviewer: mastina
Secondary reviewer: Ircher

It's a bit risky, I'll give you that. Quirky and unusual. A 13-player game with only two scum in it and town masons is something which is a little on the townsided spectrum, but literally any change I could propose would throw the whole setup out of whack--additionally, while I would call this game a little townsided, I wouldn't call it horrendously townsided. It's certainly unusual so it's hard to get an exact metric, but I'd say in the range of ~57% townsided.

...The cutoff point being 60%, though. Means you should be good.

So,
.

Have fun!

I thought it was both simple and elegant.

I really don’t have anything to add atm other than I agree it’s unusual but think it is fine as-is.

Can I advertise as "No Greylist or Modified Role" when it goes to signups?

There is no graylist. As for modified roles, that's above my paygrade; it's an implosion question.

Yeah I think public declarations of aspects of the setup are in general fine.

It could affect balance considerations, in theory, but as long as the reviewers have no issue (which it sounds like they don't) it's fine.

Can my scum have daychat. For balance.

In post 8, Espeonage wrote:Can my scum have daychat. For balance.

I believe the answer is yes, but I'm not positive.

It is allowed, but I believe the masons should also have daychat.
You could also change goon to encryptor if you want, since that's equivalent to giving daytalk to scum but not masons except that they'll flip encryptor.

Encryptor could be better. Balance some of the lean. Ya I'll do that.

Doesn't make a significant balance impact, and what effect it does have gives scum some little extra (when they are the faction at a slight disadvantage). So, should be fine, yes; the goon->Encryptor has my approval.

Commandeering this thread as my mod PT.

Playerlist:

Tchill13
Gustavo
Sergtacos
Lalendra
Enderphoenix
Mumble
Oath
Fredrick A Campbell
GuerillaWoo
ofrhz
the worst
osuka
Tommy Egan

Setup

Mafia Rolecop
Mafia Encryptor

Town Mason
Town Mason
9x VT

Scum gets day talk, masons do not virtue of Encryptor.

VT PM:

You are a Vanilla Townie. You win when all the non town are dead.

Mason PM:

You are a Mason with XXXX. You win when all the non town are dead.
PT Link: link

Rolecop PM

You are a Mafia Rolecop. You win when all the non mafia are dead.
Your partner is XXXX.
PT Link:

Encryptor PM

You are a Mafia Encryptor. You win when all the non mafia are dead.
Your partner is XXXX.
PT Link:

------------

Just for reference bc standardised PMs are not a thing yet afaik????

Tchill13
Gustavo
Sergtacos
Lalendra
Enderphoenix
Mumble
Oath
Fredrick A Campbell
GuerillaWoo
ofrhz
the worst
osuka
Tommy Egan

Dice in order of sign up list given by Implo.

Shit didn't do role order.

I'll reroll.

~High Number
Mafia Rolecop
Mafia Encryptor
Mason
Mason
VTs
~Low Number

Lets do this again. Same rules as before.

Tchill13 - 138
Gustavo - 147
Sergtacos - 67
Lalendra - 138
Enderphoenix - 129
Mumble - 195
Oath - 44
Fredrick A Campbell - 119
GuerillaWoo - 7
ofrhz - 118
the worst - 150
osuka - 57
Tommy Egan - 117

Mumble - 195
the worst - 150
Gustavo - 147
Tchill13/Lalendra - 138

Tiebreaker dice roll.

Tchill first number

Tchill13 - VT
Gustavo - Mason
Sergtacos - VT
Lalendra - Mason
Enderphoenix - VT
Mumble - Mafia Rolecop
Oath - VT
Fredrick A Campbell - VT
GuerillaWoo - VT
ofrhz - VT
the worst - Mafia Encryptor
osuka - VT
Tommy Egan - VT

Scum win.

I am pretty ready for a freak out at 7p lyle that isn't lylo

worst caught on quickly it's not multi ball bc of normal guidelines.

scum aren't happy. Masons have not said anything yet. I'd bet on scum here.

As an aside. How exactly does someone become a Normal Reviewer In Training?

PM me if you'd like to apply.

sick cheers

Mumble role cops Lalendra
Boris kills Gustavo