Scummies 2012 Nominations (Deadline For Noms)

[MagnaofIllusion]

This is another unnecessary but well deserved

Nth

for the 'Gang of Three' instrumental in recovering so much of the site lost to the malicious Tiger attack.

[MagnaofIllusion]

3rd

for Haylen for Most Cunning Manipulation -

I didn't get to really read the game before my replacement because of Tiger Attack complications but after reviewing the Mafia QT and the game I could see she did an excellent job in planning both the dual scum Cop fake-claim and made absolutely solid judgements about Nightkill choices that left Pine or myself the only logical decision the last day.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Add my

2nd

to

Kunkstar for Cyclical Experiment 2

in the category of

Best Mutation / Mechanic

[MagnaofIllusion]

Second

Nuwen

for

Paragon

. She quite effectively latched onto LLD immediately into Day 1, never let go, and quite accurately derived Spyrex and Chesskid Day 1 from their play regarding LLD.

Nominate jasonT1981

for

Most Cunning Manipulation

for his play in Team Mafia 2012 – Closed Normal. He established himself as an almost universal Town read Day 1 with Dayplay and never looked back. He never drew any significant suspicion and at endgame was the one Town read everyone had in their back pocket when they were trying to find the last two scum. Had Captain Leela been lynched a 5-player LYLO odds he was lynched were pretty much zero as scum had every logical reason to take out the claimed Town Powerrole (Tracker) over the universal Town read. A fantastic performance.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Nominate

Fate

for

Paragon of Mafia Hunters

for Chrono Trigger Resurrection Mafia.

The post I have linked to was the culmination of day-hunting by Fate and his Town / Scum lists each were almost 100% accurate (each only having one error). In a game of that size and complexity that was a pretty strong accomplishment. Had the remaining Town Doc saved Fate I think the game would have wrapped up earlier than it did. An excellent example of day-driven scum-hunting.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Nominate GreyIce for Best Replacement for Kunkstar's Switchboard Mafia

Grey replaced in Night 2 after Town (for a number of reasons not germaine to the nomination) had mislynched two Days running and was poised to do so again. Grey resurrected a completely dead slot and focused Town on actual scummy play. Scum 1 was lynched Day 3, he caught the second with his Tracker role Night 3, and coordinated with DeltaWave to lynch the last scum on Day 5. He quickly and effectively turned the game around for Town.