Mini Normal 1938 [Game Over]

[iDanyboy]

Votecount 1.19

• Tchill13 (6/7):
  Hopkirk, pisskop, Backhand, CloudKicker, Fykus, BlueBloodedToffee
  
  pisskop(3/7):
  lovelife, Havo, Virtuoso
  
  Fykus (1/7):
  Tchill13
  
  BlueBloodedToffee (1/7):
  Game Replacement
  
  
  Not Voting (2):
  Robbnva, IgnitionUSMC

Mod Notes

• With
  13
  alive, it takes
  7
  to lynch.
  
• Deadline: (expired on 2017-08-21 21:13:58).
  
• Virtuoso
  is V/LA on weekends.
  
• If you spot any errors in the vote count please let me know.

[IgnitionUSMC]

Bbt is pushing for a hammer way to much.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Is that comment supposed to serve a purpose?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Well you are in the town leans and not the town read, you are also the last name of the list. I just remember that game where you were vig and you played quite similarily so i think you prob town

I wish I had read this game properly earlier.

This game is going to be super easy to win.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Lol, I fail at multi-tabbing. Always forget that they cross over.

[pisskop]

different browsers

i use firefox and then chrome if im doing multiple games

[Backhand]

People who are probably town:
Necro
Lovelife
Tchill

Talk about how you are town reading TChill at this point of the game please?

At the time, I liked the way he engaged with robb and havo about cloudkicker.

Also, yes please let him claim.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

What did you like about the way he engaged? What made it more likely to be town engagement over scum engagement?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Can you also quote the posts you're talking about please.

[Backhand]

Can you also quote the posts you're talking about please.

So what are the odds cloudkicker is scum based on the fact these 2 posts came back to back?

I felt good about this post at the time. I was mixing up my moments in the game though on my last post, he wasn't talking to robb and havo directly.

To be clear, that mild townread has long since been lost.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

OK, so if he wasn't talking to Rob and Havo at that time, can you give me a better explanation for your town read on him?

What did you like about 199?

[Backhand]

No, I can't. It gave me a good gut feel at the time, nothing deeper than that.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

That's a really bad explanation.

What did you like about 199?

[Backhand]

That's a really bad explanation.

What did you like about 199?

It is all the explanation I have, it was a page 8 mild townread. Scumread me over it if you will.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It was page 8 and you felt comfortable enough to push out 3 town reads. He was one of them.

Can you explain what you liked about 199 now?

[IgnitionUSMC]

Even despite my interaction/voting with PK, i do agree with PK's beetlejuice layout on tchill.

Right now i have a feeling that hop, rob, and love are leaning town based on them actually trying to analyze and scum read people based more than just a "gutfeel". I think the fykus/tchill back and forth could actually be m/m instead of a t/m or m/t argument. So even if tchill flips this doesnt confirm fykus either way. Not ready to vote for tchill because im not sold he is mafia even with my suspicions. His ISO doesnt tell much by itself, more than what we have already looked at.

With this still being day 1, we've had a couple of wagons go around. Does someone have a list of the vote history already done so we can analyze? Or do we have to matrix this out?

[Backhand]

It was page 8 and you felt comfortable enough to push out 3 town reads. He was one of them.

Can you explain what you liked about 199 now?

I said what I have to say--you going to reach a conclusion here?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

We have to end D1 to avoid the game stalling and a random flash wagon happening at the last minute which is more likely than not going to land on town.

We have 42 pages of information and we've had numerous wagons. End the day and hammer TChill please.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I said what I have to say--you going to reach a conclusion here?

Are you refusing to answer my question about 199?

You already know the conclusion I have reached. Dodging questions doesn't help you either.

[Havo]

We have to end D1 to avoid the game stalling and a random flash wagon happening at the last minute which is more likely than not going to land on town.

We have 42 pages of information and we've had numerous wagons. End the day and hammer TChill please.

What is your problem with letting people claim?

WTF wouldn't you let him claim???

What is he's a town PR??

You're playing reckless as hell.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Reckless or trying to get shit done.

You decide.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Havo, why am I town?

[Backhand]

I said what I have to say--you going to reach a conclusion here?

Are you refusing to answer my question about 199?

You already know the conclusion I have reached. Dodging questions doesn't help you either.

I'm refusing to give a different answer than the true one you're not happy with--I read the post, it felt town. Until you brought it up, I'd forgotten I even included him on my initial list.

Also we have five days. We can let him claim.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I didn't realise your 'gut-feel' was reasoning for both your town read and that post. I guess you could roll them into one.

Although

, that seems an awfully flimsy reason to give to throw out a town read on page 8. Especially when you gave a false reason for justifying it first time around.

[Backhand]

I didn't realise your 'gut-feel' was reasoning for both your town read and that post. I guess you could roll them into one.

Although

, that seems an awfully flimsy reason to give to throw out a town read on page 8. Especially when you gave a false reason for justifying it first time around.

It was extremely flimsy! At the time I was voting for you for equally weak reasons, you gotta start somewhere. As for the "false" reason, when I looked back to check and saw him quoting robb and talking about cloudkicker I thought he had agreed with me on them, but that happened later.