Large Normal 211: Scientific Mafia

[Gamma Emerald]

happy scumday

[TwoInAMillion]

I am more confirmed town than Pine is confirmed vig. So Inferno needs to stop whining. If I am wrong I'll be the first to admit it but I am pretty sure we can't have 3 town neighbors, a hider, a cop, and a vig, all in the same game.

[Archwing]

Happy cake day mulch

[Pine]

WE ARE ALLOWED TO TWILIGHT TALK

Someone please say happy cake day to me

You didn't wish me a happy birthday, so no.

Oh fine.

Happy scumday!

[Pine]

We're allowed to twilight talk, but the wait is spinning us into conspiracy theories and personal attacks.

There's a very solid chance the game is over.

[Inferno390]

I am more confirmed town than Pine is confirmed vig. So Inferno needs to stop whining. If I am wrong I'll be the first to admit it but I am pretty sure we can't have 3 town neighbors, a hider, a cop, and a vig, all in the same game.

That is blatant nonsense. Not only did I admit the possibility of Pine!SK, we've already shown that you are NOT confrimed anything. I'm not whining, I want you to shut up, because you are obviously being an idiot.

[Mulch]

Thank you all

[Archwing]

I have something important to share tomorrow if we are still alive

[Pine]

I have something important to share tomorrow if we are still alive

...k

[Inferno390]

We?

[Assemblerotws]

Vote Count 3.02

texcat [8]: Pine, northsidegal, TwoInAMillion, RedFlavor, Firebringer, Ausuka, Nictis, Archwing [LYNCH]

Not Voting [6]:

texcat, Mulch, Archwing, Theta Alpine, Gamma Emerald, Inferno390

With

14

alive, it takes

8

to lynch.

Day ends in (expired on 2018-05-06 11:30:00) on

May 6, 2018

.

[Assemblerotws]

texcat was lynched!

Spoiler: She was a:

Mafia Nonconsecutive Roleblocker

RedFlavor has surrendered!

Spoiler: He was a:

Mafia Traitor

The Mafia are eliminated, but Town and SK remain. Night 3 begins now and ends in (expired on 2018-04-26 14:00:00) on April 26.

[Assemblerotws]

Firebringer has died!

Spoiler: He was a:

Town Loyal Cop

Ausuka has died!

Spoiler: She was a:

Serial Killer Ascetic JOAT (Cop, Rolecop, Commuter, Rolestopper

[Assemblerotws]

The Town has won!

[Assemblerotws]

I was particularly impressed by how Pine had Ausuka as his top SK pic as soon as he knew there was one, which led to the game-winning shot.

[Firebringer]

Ausuka you realize the play to make was no kill so Pine looks like confirmed SK, right?

[northsidegal]

lol, i'm getting carried this game

thanks for the super cool role by the way assemble, even though town won so fast i never got to use it.

[Firebringer]

Not saying you would win but Pine would be easy mislynch for you then you kill the confirm towns

[Firebringer]

You didn’t even need to kill me since I wouldn’t be confirmed lol

[Pine]

This is the PM I sent to Assemble, wherein I gamesolve in real time.

Are you FUCKING kidding me? There's actually a serial killer?

I am so mega-boned.

Okay. All previous reads are out the window, except probably Fire, who claimed Cop. He doesn't claim unprovoked like that, especially not before mafia is eliminated. That puts neighborhood back in play. In fact, a T/T/M/SK neighborhood makes sense.

So because we've seen no kills which can be conclusively labeled SK, my guess is that N1, their kill was stopped, blocked, overlapped, or something.

Then I claimed D2, and they likely no-killed, setting me up as a fall guy.

So whomever it is, they're likely a pro. That rules out Inferno and (probably) TIAM, leaving GEmerald as the last neighbor. He's a good candidate. Same logic probably eliminates Nictis, Archwing, and Theta Alpine.

Mulch and Ausuka come to mind. I don't know if Mulch has the self-discipline to hold his fire, but Ausuka does. I don't think Mulch would have been quite as aggressive going after scum if he were SK. At the beginning, sure, but he practically declared holy war on the mafia team.

Firebringer self-eliminates. Depending on how his results are worded (Innocent/guilty, mafia/not mafia etc) that may hard clear Flubber and NSG. I'll have to check with Fire about that, because you're not likely to tell me (even though you've really kind of screwed me here.)

Alternatively, I'm wondering if a kill was stopped because Mafia shot a BP SK. That opens up the TIAM-Inferno-Nictis-Archwing-Theta pool. I'll have to go back and look at ancillary claims like who blocked whom (come to think of it Theta's blocker claim probably hard rules him out.) A mafia shot on the SK, though, may have used up a 1-shot BP. I'll have to go back through mafia statements as well, especially Red's twilight WIFOM, to see if I can guess their intended kill N2.

Barring a revelation from that, my primary suspect pool is Ausuka and Gamma Emerald.

Subject to changing my mind:

Shoot Ausuka

. Her insistence that there was an SK and desire to pin it on me is hella suspicious.

Edit: Oh, Theta claimed Tracker, not blocker. That's vaaaaaguely plausible for SK, but unlikely. His results corroborate Fire's claims, and reduced chance of a blocked kill.

[Pine]

Ohhhh, the Loyal modifier is what made the Cop not overpowered. They don't get results on scum, SK, or any of the various Ascetic roles.

[Theta Alpine]

wow

good job pine
i personally thought mulch was the sk
though obviously i was wrong about that

p-edit
yeah
i was really wondering why town had at least two investigative roles combined with everything else
also i think this game was partially balanced around the sk actually killing instead of hiding

[Pine]

Well, let's see the full setup before we discuss balance. I suspect there's a lot of things out there that counter lots of other things.

[Firebringer]

Full setup is in the mod thread.

Don’t think this was balanced

[Firebringer]

Ohhhh, the Loyal modifier is what made the Cop not overpowered. They don't get results on scum, SK, or any of the various Ascetic roles.

Yeah I was overselling my role a tad
I could only get hard innos

Which is why I picked people in mid town range