Mini Normal 2030: Day 8

[Nauci]

Vote Count 4.1

Mister Rogers

(doughboy)

(2) -

Not_Mafia

(The Worst, RockyHorror)

3837

,

Mister Rogers

(doughboy)

3873

No Lynch (1) -

Akarin

(Naomi-Tan)

3863

UNVOTE/Not Voting (3) -

profii 3836

,

Light Ethos 3836

,

Creature

(ManateeDude)

3836

Full vote count is in the OP.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2018-10-20 15:00:00).

With 6 players remaining, it takes 4 votes to achieve a lynch.

[Creature]

Yeh, thinking we should nolynch

[Mister Rogers]

Ya just got off work. Gotta be throwing DOWN here relatively shortly.

[profii]

Rogers why are you self voting

[Mister Rogers]

OK I have my PoE down to the following:

Scum MUST reside in:

[AK,Pofii,LE,NM,Creature]

Sheep me!

PEDIT: Oh sorry, I thought we were policy lynching me on the advice of Fatboy

Vote:Unvote

[Mister Rogers]

Thjis SO pisses me off. Everyone that remains is a townread of mine. Well this is why I have to dig really deep on this. All the scum are playing an excellent game.

[Light Ethos]

I don't have faith that we'll get the right person today.

[profii]

PEDIT: Oh sorry, I thought we were policy lynching me on the advice of Fatboy

wrong answer.

Obviously with 2 votes on yourself, 2x scum could make it 4 and likely win the game with the night kill.

I was hoping you would say with 2 votes on you that you were suggesting N_M is scum therefore the cross vote meant scum couldn't rush and we should vote N_M

Or you were going to say you were watching the thread ready to unvote if anyone made a move - but I would have queried how you did that for such an extended period.

But that's just waffle and you're probably scum...I still think No lynch is the way to go today, but then I think N_M has to check Creature or Akarin tonight to make tomorrow as hard as possible for scum

[Mister Rogers]

I incorrectly added Crimson to the Neighborhood that Krazy and Doughboy were talking about because I misunderstood Crimson's interaction with them. I care about being factually correct, so if Crimson and I were in any kind of PT together, I definitely would have asked about that interaction before posting in this thread.

LE, can you please point out where this occurred and provide any additional explanation that might help me understand it?

[Mister Rogers]

@LE: What is your read on Naomi Tan?

[Mister Rogers]

Not only have the living scum played well but they will of necessity bussed themselves in this thread.

[profii]

Not only have the living scum played well but they will of necessity bussed themselves in this thread.

Crimson97

(7) - Naomi-Tan , Creature,

Almost50

,

Performer

,

Flavor Leaf

, Not_Mafia,

Light Ethos

Naomi-Tan (1) -

Crimson97

Performer

(2) -

Gamma Emerald

, Mister Rogers

Mister Rogers (1) -

profii

profii

(1) -

Krazy

UNVOTE/Not Voting (1) -

Sashaddin

It's tricky because I know N_M was truthful about A) being blocked and B) his result on me.

as per my point on Rogers, carelessly leaving the door open for Scum to lynch him makes me think he has TMI and knows he wont be rushed.

So yes I think he was bussing but I have no idea who of those 3 it can be - logically if Rogers is scum, then N_M and LE are unlikely to both be scum, that means N_Ms results are probably legit, but it could be that he is a scum gunsmith, or it could be that LE is a scum doc.
or it could be creature or akarin

I want to hear what everyone thinks about my theory on Rogers before we go too much further- speculating over N_M/LE/Akarin/Creature only gives scum a roadmap on who to kill tonight so we should perhaps do that after deciding about this rogers development...

[Light Ethos]

Krazy did you ever explain why you asked Dougboy if he was a PR.

@Rogers: it was a long time ago, but if I recall correctly, this post made me think he was in the neighborhood too. I read it as him asking if Krazy had publicly posted something that already was privately posted. Obviously I was wrong, but that's what I thought it was.

[Light Ethos]

@LE: What is your read on Naomi Tan?

I think Naomi-Tan was town. I don't see her vote on Crimson as a distancing vote. There was a lot that I didn't like in our back and forth, but she went through a lot of effort to get Crimson to be the Day 1.

[Light Ethos]

PEDIT: Oh sorry, I thought we were policy lynching me on the advice of Fatboy

wrong answer.

Obviously with 2 votes on yourself, 2x scum could make it 4 and likely win the game with the night kill.

I was hoping you would say with 2 votes on you that you were suggesting N_M is scum therefore the cross vote meant scum couldn't rush and we should vote N_M

Or you were going to say you were watching the thread ready to unvote if anyone made a move - but I would have queried how you did that for such an extended period.

But that's just waffle and you're probably scum...I still think No lynch is the way to go today, but then I think N_M has to check Creature or Akarin tonight to make tomorrow as hard as possible for scum

This logic makes sense to me. There was a wide window where the scum team could snatch the win here. I also don't think scum!profii takes this approach here unless he's with scum!NM.

We already know that Akarin/Creature isn't the team. (Or at least I don't think that it is.)

[Akarin]

VOTE: No Lynch

Does this mean we're in danger of someone hammering it now?

[profii]

Negative

[Mister Rogers]

Ending the day right now is not smart. I have found obvscum and I think its important to discuss it before the end of the day as well as possible partners. THAT will make it harder on the scum.

[profii]

Yo Rogers

It’s noted that you have totally not addressed my point that you negligently opened the door for scum to lynch you for 16 hours

Also you are not even pushing that N_M would be the scum in this scenario which would negate my assertion

[profii]

Like you should either be going for N_M or trying to push me trying to manufacture a mislynch on that reason

[Light Ethos]

Ending the day right now is not smart.

I have found obvscum

and I think its important to discuss it before the end of the day as well as possible partners. THAT will make it harder on the scum.

??? If it's obvious, you probably wouldn't have needed to continually promise to post a genuine PoE. You also probably would have said who it is.

[Mister Rogers]

Yo Rogers

It’s noted that you have totally not addressed my point that you negligently opened the door for scum to lynch you for 16 hours

Also you are not even pushing that N_M would be the scum in this scenario which would negate my assertion

Yes I have ignored your point. I simply know that I am town and I knew that nobody would hammer. Its not complicated and its not important either.

Regarding obvscum, I simply need to put together all the evidence as it comes from multiple places and relates to multiple separate events. There are plenty of days left here.

[Nauci]

Vote Count 4.2

Mister Rogers

(doughboy)

(1) -

Not_Mafia

(The Worst, RockyHorror)

3837

No Lynch (1) -

Akarin

(Naomi-Tan)

3890

UNVOTE/Not Voting (4) -

profii 3836

,

Light Ethos 3836

,

Creature

(ManateeDude)

3836

,

Mister Rogers

(doughboy)

3879

Full vote records in the OP.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2018-10-20 15:00:00).

With 6 players remaining, it takes 4 votes to achieve a lynch (or 3 votes to achieve a No Lynch).

[profii]

Yo Rogers

It’s noted that you have totally not addressed my point that you negligently opened the door for scum to lynch you for 16 hours

Also you are not even pushing that N_M would be the scum in this scenario which would negate my assertion

Yes I have ignored your point. I simply know that I am town and I knew that nobody would hammer. Its not complicated and its not important either.

Regarding obvscum, I simply need to put together all the evidence as it comes from multiple places and relates to multiple separate events. There are plenty of days left here.

Erm no. 2 votes placed on you and it just takes the other 2 scum to coordinate

to win the game before you could unvote

The

only

way you can know that won’t happen is if you

know

one of the current voters on your wagon is scum, negating that effect and you aren’t pushing N_M here so you can only know that you wouldn’t get hammered because you have a scum Pm

[Light Ethos]

So the game has stalled.

@Mister Rogers: I do agree with profii's logic here. The window to hammer you was a pretty wide one. Sure, there have been many lapses of inactivity this game, but casting the second vote on yourself and leaving it there for hours isn't something a town player should do in this situation. You would need to fully believe that Not_Mafia is scum to comfortably trust doing that as town. Even worse, you had to be prompted to take your vote off of yourself. That shows that this line of reasoning wasn't even on your mind.

If you've found obvscum, state your case. If not, we're pushing this to Day 5.