Oh dear, I meant to push DrDonothing a bit more, but I've already ran out of time. This seems like an oversight on my part, I should have really been here yesterday, oh well. There are a few things that stood out to me as I skimmed up to around 74, mainly the fact that DrDolittle and Dannflor seem to be defending each other for some reason. Or maybe I'm just seeing things, please correct me if I'm wrong Dannflor, here's what I mean:
In post 48, DrDolittle wrote: In post 37, Yumeko Jabami wrote:Tell me, DrDonothing, do you always hesitate to place a vote during the early game? Do you not think that Dann's Point of view is odd enough to place a vote down at this stage of the game?
TBH this is the first time where I don't place a vote during the early game.
Yumeko Jabami wrote:However, post 33 by Dannflor looks like scum grilling awkward town to me... or at least it's what I'd expect to be happening. Dannflor would certainly be the logical place to place a vote right now.
I think this is just Dannflor looking like a Dannflor. Most likely not AI
In post 59, Dannflor wrote:
Yuck. Don't like this entrance. Comes in and calls one random post towny with no explanation and then hops on an already built wagon while adding nothing to it.
VOTE: Lovebird
Lovebird, if you're lacking town reads, why don't you try questioning people to change that? Or, at the very least add something of value to the DDL wagon by interrogating him or building a different case. Your entrance just jumps on the easiest wagon without adding anything else.
In post 159, Dannflor wrote:I'd like to wait for DDL to do virtually anything before I form an opinion on that slot
I'm wary because iirc he gets scum read a lot for not doing much early game regardless of alignment
DoDonothing, you say in post 48 that this is the first time you don't place a vote in the early game. Setting aside the why for now, what do you think of Dannflor saying you get scum read for not doing much early game regardless of alignment? The statements aren't quite contradictions to each other, but I thought it was close enough to one that it was curious. What kind of experience do the two of you share, anyway? It seems you've played together, would you guys say you're friends? Friendly acquaintances? Or are you just nobodies to each other? DrDonothing in particular seemed to indicate familiarity in post 48, while Dannflor seemed more distant when talking about DDN in post 159. Ah, so cold Dannflor! It's not nice to treat your friends that way you know?
In post 59, Dannflor wrote: In post 36, Yumeko Jabami wrote:However, post 33 by Dannflor looks like scum grilling awkward town to me... or at least it's what I'd expect to be happening. Dannflor would certainly be the logical place to place a vote right now.
I like to grill awkward town first to make sure they're awkward town and not awkward scum.
Furthermore, would you say DDN's playstyle holds a special exemption to what you said here, or do you think this isn't an applicable situation?
---------
In post 38, TemporalLich wrote:I definitely feel DrDolittle is trying to hide something. At least the random voters are honest and true.
ssbm_Kyouko is probably town btw
Don't you think it's a bit early to be calling people town? Or does ssbm just wear their heart on their sleave?
I'm working on the presumption that you didn't dig into my post too deeply, but instead scanned it. Which is ok - well not really, I work hard on those - it doesn't really say much about your alignment. The point I'm trying to make is that putting in effort doesn't make somebody town - you seem like a fish out of water, latching onto other people's scumread. This is one of your first times playing mafia, right? I get the feeling you're nervous, not because you're mafia, but because you're a new player trying to fit. That's not to say that you
can't
be mafia - I'm trying to figure out your flighty attitude. Full disclosure, I read a bit ahead in the thread before posting this stuff, so I'm partially judging you based on stuff past this post as well.
Your post surprised me, because it seemed like you somehow missed the first post and only saw the second. That or you're just a little too naive.
In post 101, Emperor flippyNips wrote: In post 97, Gamma Emerald wrote: In post 69, Emperor flippyNips wrote:Anyways I was just being lazy and didn’t feel like looking at everyone’s name to see who I wanted to RVS.
And yet you voted someone who hadn't posted. Do you see a problem there? Because I do.
VOTE: Emperor FlippyNips
Can think of 2 explanations, one possibly scum indicative and one definitely scum indicative.
No I really don’t. What I said was to why i didn’t vote straight away. So that’s out of context. You can look at my ISO if you want to get it straight. I really don’t see the problem with voting someone who hasn’t posted yet it’s literally what happens in the beginning of games.
Coming at me for using my
RVS
seems like a lost cause & we should move on to find actually scum
Ahahaha, you're being silly. What's the point of Rvs if you don't want other people to judge you off of it? Did you think people just voted each other for giggles? While that certainly sounds like fun, Don't you think it's a little hypocritical of you to say that coming after you for, in your opinion paraphrased: 'essentially nothing' while you've placed a vote on lovebird for 'actually nothing' and hadn't moved on yourself?
This isn't a dig at you, people aren't coming after you because you voted lovebird, they're coming after you because you showed hesitation - yes, a moment of weakness and they jumped on it. Well, that's the kind of game we're playing though.
In post 109, Mary Saotome wrote: In post 36, Yumeko Jabami wrote:I understand that it is site meta to claim miller in your first post when you are one, so I'll acknowledge it, yes, you've caught me, I'm a miller!
Mary Saotome, it's good to see you again. Let's work hard to undermine any opposing factions together.
Ugh, it's you. Well at least you won't survive long with a claim like that Yumeko-chan.
I'm afraid I don't understand, is my life at risk? Everybody has been so very accepting of my claim so far, are you saying that their is some unspoken suspicion floating about, or perhaps that there will be if i survive for a few nights? Or perhaps you're the one who doesn't trust me? If that's the case, I'll just have to work a little bit harder, won't I?
In post 116, Mary Saotome wrote:Your tone comes off more so as accusing then it does sorting and asking questions. That could be my mistake! Hard to read tone.
My my Saotome, have you ever heard the phrase 'practice what you preach'? I've always thought it was silly, I mean, preaching isn't always about positive things, so the whole phrase ends up being a little bit assuming, don't you think?
In any case, I never took you for a clumsy girl, you should take more care in the future.
Dann certainly is interesting, I'm all fired up over here. Can you tell? In any case, there's this one other player, they're just so very boring. Honestly, it's a drag. Good chance they're scum too. Hey, we should team up, let's get all the boring out of here. What do you say?
VOTE: Radiantcowbells
