Mafiascum.net

In post 235, shellyc wrote:My own solve is Taylor / Mena / teacher

Is this a teamsolve or just three top individual scumreads?

Wait Shelly are you an alt?

Okay so like I think I’m roughly at

Teacher - townlean
IV
Shelly
Bob

Ydrasse - nulltown

Kerset - null
Andres
NDmath


Saudade - scumlean
Osuka

Plusjoy - scum
T-swizzle

I feel like this is gonna be a game where I end up having to scumhunt more than townhunt and PoE my way through tho

Teacher you said last night that you got saudade’s logic for the kerset push but I’m looking at the ISO there and it reads very null to me so far

mena your vibes feel off....... are you scum?

So like, can you try to talk me through that?

you didn’t pass the vibe check

In post 404, Ydrasse wrote:mena your vibes feel off....... are you scum?

Ugh idk how I feel about you this game ydrasse

mutual!

walk me through your two top scumreads?

In post 222, Tayl0r Swift wrote:

In post 199, shellyc wrote:my gut reads null of saudade

you’re posting a ton

let me tell you how much i dont have anything to say, but in a way that sounds like i have contributed

In post 286, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i like how everyone thinks they have super well-reasoned reads. like i guess its page 12 but the game is what? 3 hours old? has everyone even posted yet? chill out people. also a lot of people are giving reads but i havent seen a whole lot of vote-moving since initial rvs votes. interesting

I like, intensely dislike the first post here as just being like too self-aware and jokey about not doing anything, and it’s compounded by the complaining about people having reads? Like I feel like the town response to people giving reads is “good there’s something to work with” not “slow down, chill out”. I think high energy gamestate a are overwhelmingly likely to benefit town and think being a little salty about that speaks more to approaching the game from a scum mindset

Plus they’ve like been around at different points but none of their content really engages with the gamestate at the time imo

In post 404, Ydrasse wrote:mena your vibes feel off....... are you scum?

i feel this kinda

Plusjoy I feel like I don’t understand where his thoughts are coming from at all, and that’s compounded with things I think are contradictory (thinking my reads were weird when I said similar things to his first impressions), I dislike the push on IV who I think is p towny so far and I dislike the confidence level being manifested there (also in conjunction with someone saying that in a past game as town he was happier to leave people as idk which speaks I think to an ability as town to be nuanced or acknowledge that his read strength may be variable as town), and then stuff that I just don’t get at all (like the thing of arguing that ND’s opening claim was as obviously a joke as kerset’s was)

Just like enough things seem off in small ways that despite him playing I don’t feel he’s town

Would prob prefer t-swizzle at this point tho

VOTE: t-swizzle

ehh I don’t know how to feel about mena slot

it feels postury but I can’t really explain why thsi doesn’t come from town

I think I need someone brilliant to help me out here

Is talking to me gonna help or nah?

maybe, i don’t really know what to ask though atm, you’ve given your stances and explained most of them

hmm maybe we can start with your saudade read

you were gut town on them earlier what changed

also does your read scale imply teacher is less townie than osuka, plus, Taylor are scummy?

I don't like the mena slot. They also subtly moved their NDMath position from scummy to null after our convo about it, which he instead SR's me for. Not a problem in itself, but why would you seemingly agree with NDMath being null instead of scummy and also SR me for that?

In post 412, Menalque wrote:

Plusjoy I feel like I don’t understand where his thoughts are coming from at all, and that’s compounded with things I think are contradictory

(thinking my reads were weird when I said similar things to his first impressions), I dislike the push on IV who I think is p towny so far and I dislike the confidence level being manifested there (also in conjunction with someone saying that in a past game as town he was happier to leave people as idk which speaks I think to an ability as town to be nuanced or acknowledge that his read strength may be variable as town), and then stuff that I just don’t get at all (like the thing of arguing that ND’s opening claim was as obviously a joke as kerset’s was)

Just like enough things seem off in small ways that despite him playing I don’t feel he’s town

Would prob prefer t-swizzle at this point tho

VOTE: t-swizzle

I feel the same about you, I don't get your reads/tells

I will say not understand someone else’s thoughts/finding them contradictory is not necessarily a scumtell, I do implore people to keep that in mind, scum are more careful about this than town are in general

In post 417, innocentvillager wrote:hmm maybe we can start with your saudade read

you were gut town on them earlier what changed

I was, not exaggerating, super fucked up last night as I was playing after I got back from a get together

I really don’t remember saying saudade was town at all, I just remember memeing with him

In post 195, Menalque wrote:And my gut says saudade townie?

gotcha but yeah this

I'm still leaning towards IV being scum the most but if only me, shelly, and lurkerman think so and the rest think IV is town there's not much I can do since the read is pretty gut based. I'm willing to join on a taylor wagon though since they seem second scummiest.