Break time. Gonna watch some House. It's on the episode with the psychopath patient.
Not my favorite, but it's a solid episode.
PEdit: I'm not molding my play to appease your bias.
I think I posted a question in your GTKAS that never got answered about Piers Anthony stuff
Not according to your ISO in that thread.
Please direct any further commentary about my GTKAS to the relevant thread to avoid any OGI issues.
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 2:48 pm
by Dragon of the West
Okay so I just finished reading through everything...I'm coming to the conclusion that D1s really frustrate me. Quick reads:
A50 - null; not enough content to read. Anyone familiar with A50's town vs scum play? I only played one game with them where they were scum and just seemed disengaged most of the time, similar to here so far.
Andre - townlean; not much content but what was there, I liked for town. reminds me of 233
CSF - mostly null; tone has seemed fine
DGB - townlean; I'm a little confused about how the whole hood thing played out but the way DGB came clean about the 'gambit' and explained the hood interactions in detail struck me as town-ish. Although, I disagree that claimed masons get targeted by scum for NK. the games I've seen so far the claimed masons/neighbors/mason-lites just get kept alive as weak PRs that people get paranoid about
Gamma - null to townlean; this seems like inquisitive town!Gamma for the most part. Seems to be a little more in the driver's seat here from other games I've played with them, but idk if that's AI
House - not sure what to make of this slot. maybe scumlean? some posts seem like they're acting from an informed position or agenda-y, but other ones also strike me as engaged and hunting. not sure if that's just busy-work, though
Kerset - null, no content
MathBlade - scumlean; I think if one of DGB or MathBlade is scum, it's this slot. Paranoia about getting investigated, "botching" the crumb/claim and then using that to cast suspicion on DGB seemed off and kinda scummy. I think they backtracked their DGB read when they realized it might get them killed either before DGB or right after
Nero - honestly, Nero is a mystery to me. Every game he seems to have a tinfoil paranoia hat on that makes no sense to me and sounds like he's just slinging conspiracy theories around and I get paranoid he's scum and then he ends up being town and his theories end up being right. I don't think I'll be on board for a D1 Nero lim
Kyo - null to townlean; thought process and questions seem like town!Kyo
Titus - townlean; much more engaged and aggressive early compared to what I saw in 233 where they were scum. They said they play very different game to game so again not sure if AI but tone strikes me as town
Wake - null, no content
VOTE: MathBlade
Hopefully I'll have more time to be around for discussion tomorrow
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 3:01 pm
by House
Spoiler:
In post 655, Dragon of the West wrote:Okay so I just finished reading through everything...I'm coming to the conclusion that D1s really frustrate me. Quick reads:
A50 - null; not enough content to read. Anyone familiar with A50's town vs scum play? I only played one game with them where they were scum and just seemed disengaged most of the time, similar to here so far.
Andre - townlean; not much content but what was there, I liked for town. reminds me of 233
CSF - mostly null; tone has seemed fine
DGB - townlean; I'm a little confused about how the whole hood thing played out but the way DGB came clean about the 'gambit' and explained the hood interactions in detail struck me as town-ish. Although, I disagree that claimed masons get targeted by scum for NK. the games I've seen so far the claimed masons/neighbors/mason-lites just get kept alive as weak PRs that people get paranoid about
Gamma - null to townlean; this seems like inquisitive town!Gamma for the most part. Seems to be a little more in the driver's seat here from other games I've played with them, but idk if that's AI
House - not sure what to make of this slot. maybe scumlean? some posts seem like they're acting from an informed position or agenda-y, but other ones also strike me as engaged and hunting. not sure if that's just busy-work, though
Kerset - null, no content
MathBlade - scumlean; I think if one of DGB or MathBlade is scum, it's this slot. Paranoia about getting investigated, "botching" the crumb/claim and then using that to cast suspicion on DGB seemed off and kinda scummy. I think they backtracked their DGB read when they realized it might get them killed either before DGB or right after
Nero - honestly, Nero is a mystery to me. Every game he seems to have a tinfoil paranoia hat on that makes no sense to me and sounds like he's just slinging conspiracy theories around and I get paranoid he's scum and then he ends up being town and his theories end up being right. I don't think I'll be on board for a D1 Nero lim
Kyo - null to townlean; thought process and questions seem like town!Kyo
Titus - townlean; much more engaged and aggressive early compared to what I saw in 233 where they were scum. They said they play very different game to game so again not sure if AI but tone strikes me as town
Wake - null, no content
VOTE: MathBlade
Hopefully I'll have more time to be around for discussion tomorrow
So the only slot we're in any major disagreement on is MathBlade, but I'm scum?
okay that’s a start
how do you plan to read House+Nero?
Game will slow down eventually
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:13 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Game slowing down won’t decrease the length of their ISOs
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:15 pm
by House
Good luck if you're betting that my post rate will decrease over time.
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:16 pm
by House
Not a fan of Kerset's lackadaisical attitude towards sorting the most active players in the game.
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:18 pm
by Gamma Emerald
I don’t wanna project my meta onto Kerset in this regard but I have used ISOs as a way to subvert my aversion to reading through longer games as scum
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:24 pm
by Dwlee99
Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2021 5:26 pm
by Kerset
In post 606, Cat Scratch Fever wrote:I just looked at his past games, and I don't think they've played together.
He did do something similar in Team Mafia 2020, which is why it pinged me.
In post 585, DrippingGoofball wrote:Yes I was suspicious, I liked the idea that the scum would waste a kill on us thinking we're masons, or be cornered that scum!MB is claiming mason and now they can't kill him, and if they kill me the jig is up.
I still think the gambit was outed too early to get any value out of it but whatever. I think this is more interesting.
In post 540, Nero Cain wrote:Also, while I don't think the gambit was great or anything Math at least tried to keep it up and WIFOM. DGB hard claiming neighbors in 257 and ending any possibility that they get shot is pretty scummy I feel.
TBF, I am the one that said they're not Masons, which was based on the amount of waffling and DGB shading that Math was doing
I know but you were just some rando outsider, it wasn't until DBG shut down the idea that they could be masons that their gambit was nullified.
In post 596, House wrote:TIL Nero doesn't honestly scumread Math
In post 568, Nero Cain wrote:
You have like the worst case of conf biasness ever.
Scum doesn't confbias in singleball because they KNOW who's town and who's not.
good post!
except
In post 533, Nero Cain wrote:While possible, I still feel like it's very likely that one of DGB/Math is scum and
here's House and Gamma attacking me over voting the wrong hoodie and I think that's a thing scum do. "Like oh you aren't voting my buddy, you are so scummy." So I'm leaning DGB is the scum in the hood.
You could say that you missed these posts but to me it just looks like cherry picking and egging Math on.