Mini 2011: Partition Mafia (Game Over)

[Wisdom]

consider the possibility im town and hes scum
he cant swap me because me AND cakez flipping town is bad for him

[dramonic]

Yeah but he's gonna be living scum, not dead scum. <_<

[SirCakez]

hey im not dead yet
If both Riku/Pine do flip town for some god forsaken reason don't be afraid to look at Wisdom. Muffin v Wisdom may very well be TvS.

[zMuffinMan]

Yeah but he's gonna be living scum, not dead scum. <_<

tbh, if it were me 2 years ago, i'd have swapped wisdom without a second thought probably. ever since i started playing again, i feel like i'm playing a lot safer than i ever did before because i'm afraid of being wrong. it sucks, but it is what it is - i think i need to get my feet wet again

btw, you don't seriously believe i'm scum with wisdom, do you?

[dramonic]

I'm not entirely convinced.
You might just be playing cowardly.

[zMuffinMan]

if wisdom is scum, i'm sorry

[implosion]

VOTE COUNT 1.13 (FINAL)

1	2	3
DeasVail	BuJaber	dramonic
Eddie Cane	Kokichi Oma	Pine
havingfitz	REALMEN ONLY JUNGLE	riku
northsidegal	Wisdom	SirCakez
	zMuffinMan

Group 1

(0):

Group 2

(0):

Group 3

(7): BuJaber, DeasVail, REALMEN ONLY JUNGLE, riku, Wisdom, havingfitz, Kokichi Oma
Not voting: 6 (dramonic, Eddie Cane, northsidegal, Pine, SirCakez, zMuffinMan)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

[implosion]

Group 3 has been lynched on day one. It contained:

dramonic,

Vanilla Townie

.
Pine,

Vanilla Townie

.
riku,

Vanilla Townie

.
SirCakez,

Town 1-shot Free Walker

.

Spoiler: SirCakez's role PM

Hello, and welcome to Partition Mafia, SirCakez!
You are a

Town 1-shot Free Walker

.
Once, during the day, you may bold in thread: "

Join Group X

" where X is either 1, 2 or 3, and is not the group that you are currently in. If you do so, you will leave your current group and join that group. You may not use this ability if you are the only member of your group. When you use your ability, the votecount will reset, and the deadline will be extended to 48 hours from the next vote count if it is less than that.
You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member is alive, or nothing can prevent the same.
Confirm by sending me a PM stating your role and alignment.

It is now Night One. Deadline will be 11:00 AM PST on Sunday, in (expired on 2018-05-20 14:00:00).

[implosion]

DeasVail has been killed on Night One. He was a

Town 1-shot Protector

.

Spoiler: DeasVail's role PM

Hello, and welcome to Partition Mafia, DeasVail!
You are a

Town 1-shot Protector

.
Once, during the day, you may bold in thread: "

Protect PLAYER

" where PLAYER is the name of a player other than yourself. If you do so, that player will leave their current group. They will not be a member of any group for the rest of the day, and will not die no matter which group is chosen. You may not use this ability on a player who is the only member of their group. When you use your ability, the votecount will reset, and the deadline will be extended to 48 hours from the next vote count if it is less than that.
You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member is alive, or nothing can prevent the same.
Confirm by sending me a PM stating your role and alignment.

[implosion]

Day two dawns!

VOTE COUNT 2.1

1	2	3
northsidegal	Eddie Cane	BuJaber
Wisdom	Kokichi Oma	havingfitz
	zMuffinMan	REALMEN ONLY JUNGLE

Group 1

(0):

Group 2

(0):

Group 3

(0):
Not voting: 8 (BuJaber, Eddie Cane, havingfitz, Kokichi Oma, northsidegal, REALMEN ONLY JUNGLE, Wisdom, zMuffinMan)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
Deadline is in (expired on 2018-05-28 15:00:00).

[Kokichi Oma]

This is lylo I believe. No one vote. I think wisdom is town so buj is likely the scum out of day 1 group 2. If anyone has anything relevant to claim, now is likely the time

[Kokichi Oma]

Also why kill DV? Did he soft?

[Wisdom]

sorry guys i did fuck up after all.
fwiw I think kokichi is more likely scum than bu

[Wisdom]

Also still think there should be scum in the group prs, so with cakez town muffin and/or eddie are scum

consider my vote on group 2

[Kokichi Oma]

Why am I more likely scum? Why would I do that claim when not being pressured as scum

[Wisdom]

Because you wanted g2 lynched
Gets 4 town lynched and saves your buddies

[northsidegal]

unless the team is exactly {eddie, kokichi, muffin} (which i doubt), i think i'm leaning towards group 3 today.

disagreeing with wisdom here - i haven't reread to fully solidify this yet, but i still townread kokichi and looking back i think people were too quick to townread bujaber.

[Wisdom]

i still think bu is different than his scumself

[zMuffinMan]

my initial thought going into night was wisdom-REAL MAN-someone from G1 (fitz was my first guess)

protector flip is interesting since it might mean a 6th manipulation role exists (self-mirror). at least if symmetry was a key theme for those roles (i think it might be)

i want eddie to full-claim his role as well as verifying whether he can self-target (i doubt it but if he can that blows my symmetry theory away)

anyway, heading to work so ill probably do some reading when i get home tonight

[Kokichi Oma]

i still think bu is different than his scumself

What's his scum self? I townread him when he was scum in the clown game, so cant say I would know the difference

[Wisdom]

he feels fake as scum
I knew he was scum in clown after i read a few posts

[BuJaber]

I'm not scum and I still trust wisdom to be town here, so I'm guessing 1/1/1 split again. Or 1/2/0.

My vote is on group 2.

They used up their kill so we will never lose if we hit at least 1 scum every day because they can't put less than 1 in each group.

So basically if we lynch group 2 we're down 3. Assuming it's 1:2 we'll have 3 townies and 2 scum left.

They have two ways to win tomorrow which is they put 2 town together without scum or 1 scum with 1 town.

So 2/2/1 is their best bet. If they do 3/1/1 we lynch the scummiest solo group.
They can try to put 2town with 1 scum but then you have 2 groups with only 1 person in them you'd know who's scum.

Besides it's still between wisdom and koki. One of them at least is scum. The fact that they didn't put them together means we will have a confirmed scum tomorrow if koki isn't the scum.

Even if you guys don't believe that I'm town it'll still be between me and wisdom tomorrow so you'll be able to know how to avoid losing.

Basically the fact that you can't have a group with 0 is why this game is balanced and scum can't hurt town too much as long as we know there is guaranteed scum within 2 or 3 players. Which is why I had so many issues with dramon and muffin's logic. They were way too scared of lylo. This game lylo is less dangerous than normal mafia bekieve it or not because there is so much info to gain from the partitioning.


VOTE: Group 2

Koki it's actually a brilliant claim by you. At first I townread the hell out of it because I couldn't explain why you'd risk exposing yourself but you knew you were either killing 4 town or we will vote another group which means you remain a mystery.

[BuJaber]

Also as far as it sucks that we argued so much I think muffin is town if koki is scum. Why would koki claim so early if he knew that a switching PR exists which makes it likely that town had one if scum had one. So koki would have known about muffin's switch.

Muffin I don't tell people how to play the game but when you're town consider keeping the sarcasm limited. You came off as scum that is gloating knowing you are being suspected but can't be killed.

[zMuffinMan]

who else do you think is scum buj?

also,

They used up their kill so we will never lose if we hit at least 1 scum every day because they can't put less than 1 in each group.

either you're very confused about the setup or i am

[zMuffinMan]

oh wait you mean they cant put less than 1 person in each group. right nm

the problem with your logic, of course, is that if wisdom happens to be town and eddie happens to be town, then town loses today

so yeah, theoretically if one scum gets lynched everyday then town can't lose

otoh that actually needs to happen...