Silent Star 4: Yin and Yang

[clidd]

i mean, flea has basically had a tone of debauchery since faer slot was set as universal PoE and i don't see any solving coming from fae regarding ydrasse/chara/me

most posts are performative fillers that reflect like outed scum

you probably also haven't forgotten the mechanical theory that served as an excuse for faer to avoid scumhunting/townhunting for most of the game

pedit: meh, so go ahead then

because flea has to be town for chara to be scum

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

why is chara town

besides the fact that flea is obvscum (unless you buy that the way flea has been playing so far comes from town) chara vs ydrasse's interactions felt like tvs

yea i doubt the scum team decided to bet it all on obvscum flea somehow wifoming me into townreading fae

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

fae is the first person to get elimmed if the team is naka/infy/ydra/fae

[clidd]

after reading the last two pages of flea's iso i don't see anything related to town-solving or anything i like

chara's iso is meh, but looks better than flea and its interactions with ydrasse don't seem s/s (unless you think they did ss theater)

[clidd]

i wouldn't say i think chara is towny, but due to ydrasse's flip it ended up having a town spew more than not (especially compared to flea)

[clidd]

but, again, my reads this game are being meh so i'm open to hear more

[clidd]

so... any thoughts?

@pooky @amy

also

@chara

who's more likely scum/town to you? me or flea? (and why)

[Amy Dunne]

I miss Akarin.

Let's try to win now.

+1

I hope she’s okay, I’ve left her a few unread messages.

[Amy Dunne]

there are a lot of things I want to say, but for now the only consideration relevant to the game is that chara is town given the information that ydrasse is scum.

so we do chara today and me tomorrow - win

Uh no, plans have changed, I wasn’t counting on a Ydra red flip. I guess if I ever have the slightest diubt, she’s scum. \_0_/

[Amy Dunne]

I could actually get behind Chara today...

clidd ignoring me is amazing ngl, and I'm sure that's cause he knows I'll break him >:)

Why do you autoassume that makes him scum?

[Amy Dunne]

nobody vote plz

also i dont trust chara at all

+1

[Flea The Magician]

I mean I've no intention of voting at all, honestly.
I don't know who to vote for my wincon, and nobody trusts me enough to vote me.

[Flea The Magician]

i mean, flea has basically had a tone of debauchery since faer slot was set as universal PoE and i don't see any solving coming from fae regarding ydrasse/chara/me

most posts are performative fillers that reflect like outed scum

you probably also haven't forgotten the mechanical theory that served as an excuse for faer to avoid scumhunting/townhunting for most of the game

pedit: meh, so go ahead then

because flea has to be town for chara to be scum

Pot Kettle. That's all I'm saying.

[Amy Dunne]

im like 95% of the way to locking in chara as last scum

Pooky convinced me Ydra was Yin, sorry Flea.

[Flea The Magician]

I could actually get behind Chara today...

clidd ignoring me is amazing ngl, and I'm sure that's cause he knows I'll break him >:)

Why do you autoassume that makes him scum?

I dont, I assume nothing at this stage.
Clidd never ignores me though, he knows I'll happily 1vs1 him, we've tunnelled each other before.

[Amy Dunne]

why is chara town

besides the fact that flea is obvscum (unless you buy that the way flea has been playing so far comes from town) chara vs ydrasse's interactions felt like tvs

im like 95% of the way to locking in chara as last scum

no idea how you are seeing this, but if you can explain it would help

i have gigantic difficulty seeing town!flea here but, well, after ydrasse's flip I'm open to hearing theories that diverge from mine

We both think it’s Chara but we’re not locking it in yet.

[Flea The Magician]

im like 95% of the way to locking in chara as last scum

Pooky convinced me Ydra was Yin, sorry Flea.

not sure what you're sorry for, but eh. It's a game.

[Amy Dunne]

my certainty level on chara being scum is even higher than my sr on ydra.

Ydra misplayed this unless Flea is her buddy and rn, I’m leaning no. Because my never yeeting Flea stance was totally predicated on either a Ydra townflip or no flip, because I just didn’t buy a Chara/Clidd team but her red flip forced us to reacess.

[Amy Dunne]

i mean, flea has basically had a tone of debauchery since faer slot was set as universal PoE and i don't see any solving coming from fae regarding ydrasse/chara/me

most posts are performative fillers that reflect like outed scum

you probably also haven't forgotten the mechanical theory that served as an excuse for faer to avoid scumhunting/townhunting for most of the game

pedit: meh, so go ahead then

because flea has to be town for chara to be scum

I think Clidd is probably town and Ydra pocket.

But if we yeet the wrong pkayer, we lose. We now need to get two right, not just one.

I didn’t really like Chara’s you’ve given up post, because that isn’t how I read it at all.

[Amy Dunne]

so... any thoughts?

@pooky @amy

also

@chara

who's more likely scum/town to you? me or flea? (and why)

Rn, I feel best about you, then Flea and Chara last.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

after reading the last two pages of flea's iso i don't see anything related to town-solving or anything i like

chara's iso is meh, but looks better than flea and its interactions with ydrasse don't seem s/s (unless you think they did ss theater)

how does ydra red flip clear chara?

[Amy Dunne]

I mean I've no intention of voting at all, honestly.
I don't know who to vote for my wincon, and nobody trusts me enough to vote me.

Pooky and me both think it’s Chara but I Clidd seemed so certain she’d flip town and Ydra being Yin, makes it less likely to be you. I think they distanced. Ydra knew she’d flip before Chara and did that whole image reverse thing to convince us it was Chara.

Plus remember why 4/5 criminals are scum wifom theory? Recall Ydra insisting how “dumb” my theory was? If my theory was actually correct, it just means I had the wrong one obviously since Tanner flipped town.

If it is Chara, then scum misplayed this because Flea would probably look the worst from a Chara red flip but Chara looks the worst from a Ydra red flip.

[Amy Dunne]

im like 95% of the way to locking in chara as last scum

Pooky convinced me Ydra was Yin, sorry Flea.

not sure what you're sorry for, but eh. It's a game.

I was sure you had to be Yin and that’s why Ydra scumflip forced me to reacess.

[clidd]

after reading the last two pages of flea's iso i don't see anything related to town-solving or anything i like

chara's iso is meh, but looks better than flea and its interactions with ydrasse don't seem s/s (unless you think they did ss theater)

how does ydra red flip clear chara?

chara isn't clear, but the way she and chara were arguing made me lean town!chara after a ydrasse scumflip and flea's play in general has been more compatible with scum

but as I said, I'm not imposing my read, you two are the ones who will decide not me

[Amy Dunne]

my god i'm half-convinced that the wincon of some faction this game is to flip tanner

This kind of exasperation over Flea Tanner sr doesn’t look SvS to me.