@Kast
"In terms of mechanics balance,
with what's been claimed
, I doubt town has to deal with 2 scum teams."
Here's what your claim list misses out on
- Kunk claimed 2 shot Hider+Commuter
- SpyreX is a protective role from flavor
Also, if I was a SK in this game, would have just kept quiet about my BP, given the meta on BP claims equaling SK automatically.
@Iece
- Regarding tinkerbell, at the start of the game I made a list of all possible roles in the game depending on whether the fairy tale character was sexy enough or not (Pics and stuff). After reading the first game, I tried reasoning what powers RC would give to scum and the corresponding fakeclaims. This was what I thought the fakeclaims were at that time:
Little red riding hood - Cop
Rapunzel - JK
Tinker Bell - Commuter
- Reason I'm not pushing your lynch now is that if you're scum
a) You're lying about your ability. In which case, you would have made up for result for today and got caught.
b) If you're an actual rolecop kinda of scum role - you would have welcome the chance to semi-confirm yourself with N1 results. At worst, you could have made up flavor on N1 about people who had claimed before you instead of going "tinkerbell" which if you're scum - you know will put the spotlight on you.
The 10% also ties in with your ability not working properly on one GF scum. (So one false positive amongst 12 targets = wrong 8.3% of the time = Right 91.66% of the time). So yeah, much better choices for the lynch today.
- Yes, I wanted to claim last because of my mass roleblock.
More thoughts on why ABR claimed scum in thread
a) Because of me
- Clearly tinkerbell is not there in the setup since no pro-town player has claimed the role
- Also Snow white not being there is also weird. Given that
-- I said "I expected tinkerbell to the commuter fakeclaim"
-- I was pushing for a massclaim
Scum thought I was a role who had inside info on their fakeclaims. So decided to hedge bets; One person claims the best fakeclaim given to them, ABR takes a risk with claiming actual villain name cause of "Why would scum do that" WIFOM and make up another name. (Giselle is the claim which sounds out there).
b) Because by claiming scum in thread and getting lynched - give the impression that scum don't have fakeclaims - because one of their partners has a kickass fakeclaim.
c) He's a role like Bomb - so should probably have second most scummiest candidate hammer him just in case.
d) One of the scum have a governor ability - seems broken in a mini but you never know.
768 is an opportunistic scum attempt to get BP lynched or yet another attempt to get himself lynched. I am definitely voting ABR today ..
