Mini 1790: Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag Mafia [GAME OVER]

[heuristically_alone]

Oh wow, was not expecting to have already won. We rock!

[heuristically_alone]

I'm AMAZED you thought full Cop and Doc AND VIG in the same game was a good idea. Three words: Follow The Cop.

Only one player was going to show up as a guilty result after Night 1. So I don't know how the cop was going to be extremely useful.
2/11 chances for first night (assuming that both mafia live)
Town didn't know they had a cop or doctor either.
The captain was also supposed to make players nervous and possibly roleblock the cop/doctor but it was never used at all (which saddened me)

But still, the setup had little to do with the general outcome of the game.

Sorry I saddened you with my captain role, but I decided that it would be best to just not use my ability and give cop/doctor any free reign with their roles.

[Golden Robster]

Should of just kept my guilty on java

[Golden Robster]

Also, thank you for not shooting me!

(I appreciate it)

[Golden Robster]

Thanks for modding that Fire!

[Cabd]

One other unmentioned flaw is that you've given town "false info" if a specific situation were to have happened.


Day One: Town lynches godfather
Night One: Cop gets innocent on second scum

There's zero chance cop goes "well gee, guess there's probably two godfathers in this game"

[Firebringer]

There's zero chance cop goes "well gee, guess there's probably two godfathers in this game"

Setup speccing is bad.
Don't do it.

[Frozen Angel]

One other unmentioned flaw is that you've given town "false info" if a specific situation were to have happened.


Day One: Town lynches godfather
Night One: Cop gets innocent on second scum

There's zero chance cop goes "well gee, guess there's probably two godfathers in this game"

well thats what town should think about godfather in first place. thats not giving anyone false info.

Games must be challenging in day , not based on guilties over night. info must just be treated as information not confirmation

[Cabd]

...Did I miss a meta shift while I was gone?

[Frozen Angel]

I hate meta.

I love changing it

and I will do that in my setups. I promise everyone!

[Cabd]

This game is not bastard or role madness

???

[Brian Skies]

One other unmentioned flaw is that you've given town "false info" if a specific situation were to have happened.


Day One: Town lynches godfather
Night One: Cop gets innocent on second scum

There's zero chance cop goes "well gee, guess there's probably two godfathers in this game"

Java having his role card flipped would have revealed the scumteam composition to the town, especially the part about another scum being promoted to Godfather should the Godfather die first.

[Frozen Angel]

This game is not bastard or role madness

???

Its not basterd nor role madness

[Frozen Angel]

Its not normal but having a backup godfather won't make it basterd

[Firebringer]

Java having his role card flipped would have revealed the scumteam composition to the town, especially the part about another scum being promoted to Godfather should the Godfather die first.

In hindsight I should have just put down a partial role card on flip.

[Garmr]

I only town read one scum that's pretty good.

[Garmr]

Also I figured out heur AND maestro were town yahhh. I honestly think second scum (sircake) was nabbed by chance through. Sir cake seemed like a last minute lynch with no real case given. Even through set up spec was wrong. Rangers and bee boy just seemed like they were random lynching because there cases on heur,maestro and I were horrible and had no thought going into them the only thing I could agree with bee boy was cabd was slightly suspicious. I also figured you would throw in two investigation immune roles but I thought it would be a traitor not a back up godfather.

I forgot to cop through because I forgot I was sleeping the night at a friends place with no net. After the second flip you could pretty much figure out the game from poe. Sircake proves that beeboy and ranger were town while my innocent on nosf was obvious. frozen would of been obvious and cabd If i did my night action would of cleared him. From my eyes brians jump onto heur is another clear and maestro was obvious town. Through when maestro suggested lynching me tomorrow I felt my heart sink.


All that left was golden and java and frozen vigging one of them would of been easy to see.

[Frozen Angel]

I love you too

I'm not hurting town! when did I do that ? I never played against my wincon. please forgive me if I was mean to you or manipulative but remember I was just following my scum agenda then.

[Garmr]

I was just bitter about the extreme emotional outbreak you did when I nailed the entire scum team. I had a feeling you were scum but I feel so bad I jumped on the secondary last scum read I could of won that game for town and had bragging rights.

It should of been obvious I was town through being the second vote on brian skies and two derp players range and beeboy were pushing I was scum. If they stop and thought about it for a second and not been derping they would of realized I was telling the truth. I also didn't like the fact that beeboy was soft claiming a role to counter claim me with out laying it down.

[Frozen Angel]

I still think your giving yourself so much credit for than lynch.

[Suzune]

I do not want to be snarky or mean to you garmr but, I sort of think the Skies lynch was my doing. you did play a good game though.

[beeboy]

I still think your giving yourself so much credit for than lynch.

[Garmr]

I do not want to be snarky or mean to you garmr but, I sort of think the Skies lynch was my doing. you did play a good game though.

I would say 50 yours 40 mine 10 others.

[Garmr]

I still think your giving yourself so much credit for than lynch.

Atleast I can actually say I wasn't just random lynching people beeboy and trying to lynch obvious town heur,maestro and me.

[beeboy]

You wouldn't have needed a cop claim to save you if you where obv town.
I also wasn't trying to lynch Maestro, I thought he was town.

Sorry for being rude it is just you weren't exactly kind this game yourself and I wanted to get that off my chest.