Mini 1868 - Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Prism]

If this were to be run again I would suggest:

- give full details on roles at beginning of game, e.g. the gunsmith being 1X and having the gun to give away
- dayvig shot shouldn't end phase. It should be an extra kill, so if there's a cop guilty, it can just be shot, but town still gets a lynch that day too.

Also make night kills not require a vote. Just take the most recent submitted PT kill.

That near-no kill night one likely would have resulted in an abandon. It's also pretty silly that we weren't allowed to change the kill before the deadline if we wanted to change our minds. The lack of clarity on this point was pretty scary.

[Persivul]

Also make night kills not require a vote. Just take the most recent submitted PT kill.

That near-no kill night one likely would have resulted in an abandon. It's also pretty silly that we weren't allowed to change the kill before the deadline if we wanted to change our minds. The lack of clarity on this point was pretty scary.

Agreed. For town wondering what this is about, we had to vote on the NK just as we vote on lynches. A majority was needed to get a kill. IIRC N1 empking wasn't around, and gamma came in pretty late to hammer it. Also, once a hammer was reached, we couldn't change our minds.

There's nothing wrong with this method per se, it just needs to be spelled out clearly because it's unusual for this site. A big bold paragraph in the first post of the scum thread would do.

[Cabd]

Yeah, that's nonstandard and should have been laid out in the rules.

I require something very similar in my games, but it's changeable with agreement.

"25. All factional decisions must be agreed upon by all living members of that faction."

[pieguyn]

I was half-assed following this for the first few days of D1 and I had Nacho, Empking and GE immediately. what could have been

[BBmolla]

Not much I can say. I keep getting worse.

[-Grey-]

Not much I can say. I keep getting worse.

Nah, not your fault I made bad assumptions.

[Prism]

This game also resulted in some really interesting interactions for me.

I was playing both this one and camn's revenge with Fate and Nacho. This game I was telling Nacho basically everything I do as scum, and what differences I have in tone that are legitimate/illegitimate. My start here purposely imitating my meta from "Trial of the Evoker" is one such example. I had to behave in camn's revenge differently from this one in order to get Nacho to townread me, but simultaneously being too different was claiming scum to Fate in one of the games. It was a really fun balancing act, and I made a lot of attempts to standardize my gameplay between the two games early on. Eventually, things happened in camn's revenge that resulted in that being unsustainable, and the result was me basically claiming scum to Fate here as the consequence for being obviously town in the other. Obviously, none of this could ever be explicit as you can't reference ongoing games.

I basically gave up on getting him to townread me in this game. It was really just a funny balancing act, and fascinating to play out as I've never had to manage multiple, cross-contextual interactions like that before.

[Fate]

Well put, and yes that was definitely going on

BUt


Tbf I scumread the fuck out of nacho this game and never let go of that

[Fate]

I asked you specifically to have Nacho comment on my alignment and your hydras vote on me, Reflektor.

This is top priority, especially now with Tammy down I'm short on players I can trust if they're town

I think you're town, Prism doesn't. I'm perfectly comfortable with Prism feeling around and doing his own thing for now.

This post alone is punishable by death.

Thr LUV pushes were shit as well.

If town hadnt voted me over Empking your true colors wouldve shown through there as well

[Nachomamma8]

PERSIVUL IS A GOLDEN GOD

[Nachomamma8]

A shiny, golden god; I missed every single PR tell (my only contribution was telling Persivul his PR tell was wrong), we would have been sunk and burned and ruined by Day 2.

[Nachomamma8]

Tbf I scumread the fuck out of nacho this game and never let go of that

You scumread me and I trolled you and still I lived. Beautiful.

[Tammy]

Sorry for replacing out!

Good game scum. Maybe one day Nacho will draw town with me again

Thanks for running it kbw.

And lol at mind melding with pieguyn

[Realeo]

I think it's an excellent setup once you stop "Omg! Town is going to die" and actually play it.

Although I think roleblocker is a better choice than doctor.

[Fate]

Tammy we really needed you to get scumcho lynched

I had no pull this game D1

[Randomnamechange]

Oh yeah, just read that random got a guilty N1. I thought he might be a PR because he wasn't concerned with being wagoned, as if he had a claim in his back pocket if needed.

That could have been a pretty quick town win...

yeah, looking back I'm annoyed at myself for that.
wp though, that was grerat play from you

[Tammy]

Tammy we really needed you to get scumcho lynched

I had no pull this game D1

Awe!

I'm sorry I was silly and replaced out. You were one of the reasons I was looking forward to this game, and yes it would have been nice to have solid backing on that read.

[-Grey-]

22) Don't be a prick.

Realeo, all your hairsplitting doesn't mean shit because you can't escape the fact you broke the shit out of this rule.

Stay the fuck away from me kthx.

[Gamma Emerald]

Wtf
I somehow won lol
Also thanks for not locking this listmod.