Mini 1887 - Oddrole Mafia (Game over)

[Socrates]

SOCRATES

I MISS UYPU


ALSOC MENNO

<3

[Socrates]

So my main takeaway here is that scum actually can replace out when they're doing perfectly well but are mad about town shitposting. Haven't ever seen that before.

@eager thanks for modding; I don't 100% agree with all mod decisions made but thanks for the experience

It should never be the responsibility of the scum team to keep a game alive. i was literally contemplating replacing out myself when Prana did so, which him doing so was really the main reason I chose to stick it out. It felt like it would have been too hard on the Mod.

[Socrates]

Also I hammered a stated townread and would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for that pesky serial killer and his forensics kit.

This game was a slog at the start, but I really started enjoying it by day 3.

[eagerSnake]

I'm thinking I should have made oddrole a night start game.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I just think it's funny I successfully blocked a kill with my role with my lazy ass claim

[eagerSnake]

I just don't like night start because I feel bad for the people who die N0.

[bangthemafia]

Haha, Oddrole was amusing. My first oddrole game and I was literally struggling to imagine what all roles can be possible!

[bangthemafia]

Socrates, I so hard townread you. And even after you guys so quickly power lynched me day 2, I was reading the game and Viridian:s analysis was amazing.

@Mod, there were so many complex things going on in night and even day, can you please post detailed night actions? Maybe on page 1 itself?

[aronagrundy]

Also I hammered a stated townread and would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for that pesky serial killer and his forensics kit.

This game was a slog at the start, but I really started enjoying it by day 3.

I didn't choose the forensics life, the forensics life chose me

[Viridian]

What was Dwlee's original role btw?

[Viridian]

This was fun! I just killed whoever spoke first that day. The plan was to make everyone afraid of posting and force a mass prod but momo being immortal kind of spoiled that. In addition to the whole role swap lol

That's hilariously diabolical. I just thought whoever it was found N_M's first post super scummy in light of the previous day.

[Socrates]

I just think it's funny I successfully blocked a kill with my role with my lazy ass claim

I don't know if the mod plans the share the scum PT, but I think you would get a kick out of how you ended up getting shot. It's not for the reasons you think.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I just think it's funny I successfully blocked a kill with my role with my lazy ass claim

I don't know if the mod plans the share the scum PT, but I think you would get a kick out of how you ended up getting shot. It's not for the reasons you think.

Oh now my feathers have been ruffled. Ugh I'm dying now

[Socrates]

I just don't like night start because I feel bad for the people who die N0.

This is a fairly common sentiment. a No-kill night 0 is a possible solution, but I would suggest you give the mafia something else to do night 0 just so it feels fair. Like make sure they have a rolecop or something along those lines.

[Titus]

Hey Socrates, you were an awesome scumbuddy. Our posting was the most enjoyable scum theatre.

[Socrates]

Oh yes. Having someone to bounce off of like that was quite fun. The key to enjoying playing as mafia, I have found, is to not take it so seriously or obsess over winning. It's why I can't really get mad at Not_Mafia's antics, as poorly as it went over with the town. The way he kept up the schtick in the PT made me laugh. The comedic timing on him getting shot was also perfect.

[eagerSnake]

Yeah this game had some good dramatic irony

For example nm saying he could finally talk and then getting immediately day killed for being the first one to talk that day

Then the daykiller getting killed by his own ability at the end too

[eagerSnake]

Dwlee99's original role was Jedi

[McMenno]

overall I had fun, but I have some critisiscms:

if someone asks a question pertaining public information, answer it in thread. if it's about their role, say something along the lines of "I will only answer questions regarding public information". can every player answer the question and receive the same answer? then answer it.

make a dead thread, and when someone dies, pm them a link. this way they know they're dead and have someplace to discuss/vent about how the game went down/is going down.

also send everyone a pm when the game is over. and make sure to release the setup and the night actions each night (maybe even the mod thread if you have that) (this is something you can still do)

[Viridian]

Yeah uh, I felt slighted that I got literally no response to the one mechanics question I had that was about a role my slot used to have .

[bangthemafia]

@Eager, dude, update the 1st page, before people lose interest. It still shows 4 players alive.

Tell us in detail what did everyone start as? What they did each day or night? And what were the results of their actions???

[eagerSnake]

1.

Malachite

aronagrundy*

Spoiler:

You are a

Daykiller (sk)

.

You can kill another player of your choice each day at any time by messaging the moderator. Actions: (day)kill

You win the game when you are in the final two and there are no other killers.

2. Not_Mafia*

Spoiler:

You are a

Ken Kesey (mafia)

.

You can fake your own death at night. You die and then return to life. Your role and alignment won't be revealed. Actions: suicide

PranaDevil and Socrates are also in the mafia and you can converse with them during pre-game and night phases in the Mafia PT.

You win when you have majority and there are no other killers.

3. Jaack*

Spoiler:

You are a

Doctor (town)

.

You can protect other players from kills. Each protection stops one kill, and lasts for one night. Actions: protect

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

4. Börk Börk*

Spoiler:

You are a

Grey Goo (town)

.

You can infect a player to assimilate them, turning them into your role. Their team doesn't change. Actions: infect

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

5.

PranaDevil*

Titus

Spoiler:

You are a

Shuffler (mafia)

.

You may shuffle the setup, exchanging two random players' roles. You don't know whose roles were exchanged. Actions: shuffle

Not_Mafia and Socrates are also in the mafia and you can converse with them during pre-game and night phases in the Mafia PT.

You win when you have majority and there are no other killers.

6.

All Alone* PimHel

Viridian

Spoiler:

You are a

One-Shot Forensics Expert (town)

.

You may perform an autopsy on a dead player, possibly giving you information about that player's killer. Your ability can only be used once. Actions: (day)autopsy (1 use)

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

7.

TheRealGin-N-Tonic*

momo

Spoiler:

You are an

Immortal (town)

.

You are immortal, and All Alone is the source of your power. You cannot be killed, and if you are lynched you will return to life. However, if All Alone should die, you will immediately die as well.

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

8. alban*

Spoiler:

You are a

Skunk Farmer (town)

.

Anyone who tries to target you with an action will be disabled by your smell until the next night.

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

9. bangthemafia

Spoiler:

You are a

Sleeper Vigilante (town)

.

Right now, you don't have any powers, but if Dwlee99 dies you will become a Vigilante.

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

10. randomidget*

Spoiler:

You are a

Mystery Role (town)

.

You have a night ability, but you don't know what it does. Actions: mystery

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

*randomidget was a Mystery Motivator (gives a player an extra vote for the next day with his ability)

11. Dwlee99*

Spoiler:

You are a

Jedi (town)

.

You can disable someone's role. That player will temporarily lose all abilities/characteristics until the next night. Each night you learn the role PM of a random role in the setup, but not who has it. Actions: disable

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

12. McMenno*

Spoiler:

You are a

Bruce Wayne (town)

.

Right now, you don't have any powers, but if Not_Mafia dies you will become a Batman.

You win when all the bad guys are gone.

13. Socrates*

Spoiler:

You are a

Cheerleader (mafia)

.

You can block another player's action each night. You are immune to roleblocks. You will automatically use your action on a random player each night. Actions: (auto)roleblock

Not_Mafia and PranaDevil are also in the mafia and you can converse with them during pre-game and night phases in the Mafia PT.

You win when you have majority and there are no other killers.

[eagerSnake]

D1

Aronagrundy

(day)kill

Jaack

Lynched

alban

N1

Socrates

(auto)block

Dwlee99

Dwlee99

(auto)cheat

Bork Bork

[blocked]

Dwlee99

disable

Socrates

[blocked]

randomidget

mystery(motivate)

Dwlee99

Not_Mafia

mafiakill

momo

Not_Mafia

suicide

Bork Bork

infect

Dwlee99

Titus

none

D2

aronagrundy

(day)kill

Not_Mafia

Lynched

bangthemafia

N2

randomidget

mystery(motivate)

Dwlee99

McMenno

kill

Dwlee99

Socrates

mafiakill

Dwlee99

Titus

shuffle (

aronagrundy

and

PimHel/Viridian

)

Bork Bork

infect

Titus

Dwlee99

none

D3

arondagrundy

(day)autopsy

Dwlee99

Viridian

(day)kill

Bork Bork

Lynched

Socrates

N3

randomidget

mystery(motivate)

Titus

McMenno

kill

Titus

Titus

infect

momo

Titus

mafiakill

McMenno

D4

Viridian

(day)kill

aronagrundy

[eagerSnake]

I think that about does it.

Dwlee99 was a natural magnet, look at all those night actions on him

Targeted 7 times this game.

Mafia PT: viewtopic.php?f=90&t=70744

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

scum PT