@Xaldin
I basically disagree that Larxene's tone in response to being challenged on the claim is null - I think there's some pretty clear scum motivation in attacking people who don't just accept the claim at face value; you could argue that it's just personality indicative or part of the roleplay that Larxene seems to be doing or whatever and I don't think it's a strong point for that reason but I don't think you can just discard it out of hand. Think you've also basically just dismissed the other points without engaging with them on an intellectual level at all; the crux of it is that Larxene's reads are badly formed and badly held and none of it feels very town - you can disagree with the way that's expressed but I don't think it's very reasonable to just say "those points are bad there's nothing wrong with Larxene" and not engage with the read beyond that. What is your read on Larxene?
Part two of this is... what are you doing with your vote? What are any of your reads besides Xigbar? Why is Xigbar even a scumread? Don't think you've explained anything at all and I'm starting to wonder which of my scumreads might be wrong if you're scum here because
182 is frankly pretty awful from you - I'm presuming you're scumreading Luxord here? Literally zero nuance in your stances here that might help me see that you've put thought into your reads or the gamestate overall at this point.
@Larxene
why does my Saïx read alone make you want to call me town? Not sure that makes a lot of sense to me since it was the one read I explained the *least* comparative to how strongly I feel about it. Not sure what you mean by "not enough" with regard to the scumreads on you; if there's something you think we're missing in your read on you then I think you should probably address that and talk to us about it rather than just saying what feels like essentially "can't touch this". I assure you my scumread on your slot is very real and I think the reasoning for it is pretty decent right now; don't at all like the implication that it's going to take a big case and a big push to take you down.
Basically dislike your lack of critical engagement with any of your reads; your reaction to Luxord's post in particular is basically a big nothing, you say you want more than a catchup but you haven't engaged with him on anything in a way that might encourage that; you've not basically anything to encourage content from any slot except arguably voting Roxas - a vote that comes from you with basically no progression; you went from being basically sure that Roxas was town for no reasoning at all to now scumreading them and wagoning them without going into why beyond calling up pretty shallow reasoning that you'd ignored up until that time. Really really struggling to see your slot as town right now in any universe.
@Luxord
if you're unhappy with people calling you out for waffling then... maybe do a little less waffling? Would really like a response to
181 and just some clarity on what your stances / reads actually are at this stage in the game and how you arrived at them; the "stream of consciousness" stuff really doesn't work when we actually just can't follow your thoughts at all. You really need to take some hard stances and explain things in a cogent way if you're town here because what you're doing right now isn't working at all.
@Xemnas
talk to me about your Roxas read please? Don't think that townreading the slot because scum wouldn't want to hard stances early is particularly good reasoning; think it's probably ultimately just playstyle; this is my weakest scumread but it's definitely the one that I'm most worried about endgaming if it's scum so I'm pretty concerned with not letting any lazy reasoning by on townreads there; if you think there's something lacking in the reasoning I expressed in
157 then I'd definitely like to hear why you think that; somewhat struggle to see the kind of aggressive hard defending that's come out of that slot coming from town at the moment.
Definitely disagree that outing the invest-immune is something to townread even a little bit; I think that if Larxene is the type of player to out that kind of thing then she's the type of player to do it as either alignment and don't think there's strong reasoning to argue otherwise.
What's your read on Xaldin?
@Lexaeus
you're really going to have to provide good reasoning for townreading Axel here because at this point it feels like they're not even playing the same game as anyone else; all their content is completely irrelevant, there's literally not a shred of town in any of their posts and I am absolutely baffled as to how you can't see that. Please show me how you are not scumreading that slot because that just makes zero sense to me. Saying they're conf!biased does nothing for me; your reasoning for all your reads has been categorically vacant and I think you need to do a lot more to show the work behind them than what you've been doing because it's getting a little bit ridiciulous by now.
@Xigbar
is
195/
196 addressed to me? Don't understand what you mean by picking someone who you're scumreading to declare obvtown there.
--
Okay half my altguesses just went out the window with Demyx's entry and now I'm confused on that front lmao. Had something else to say but now it's gone.
You said half your alt guesses got thrown out.
)
