Mini Theme 2008: Role Design Committee [Game Over]

[Ankamius]

Well

Day 2 is proving to be a huge waste of time to read through.

[Ankamius]

Momrangal is obvtown
the worst is obvtown

Kokichi Oma is just under obvtown

Espeonage is lightly town
Not Known 15 is lightly town

-> moderate town

SnarkySnowman is null
NicoRobin is null

-> lightly town

Alonzo is lightly scum

-> moderate scum

TheGoldenParadox is strongly scum
StefanB is strongly scum
Chickadee is strongly scum

That's really all that's changed.

Chickadee/StefanB/TheGoldenParadox are my picks for scum. All three slots are significantly scummier than everybody else in the game. I can see all three of them having a scum agenda behind their play, none have given me any townvibes, and their overall approach just... doesn't feel like trying to gamesolve.

If I'm wrong on any one slot, it's Alonzo instead. The only real difference between this slot and the above is that it's harder to get a read on.

Other than those slots, I'm townreading every other slot except for Snarky, who I've yet to see any reason to read either direction.

the worst/Momrangal are both slots I will have a very hard time seeing as scum this game, likely permanently. Neither are locked yet, but it would take a huge scumfucking to turn my reads on either slot around. I can go into some detail on this, but I don't think I have to since I don't think it should be hard to figure out why for both slots.
Kokichi reads like wrongtown. I don't agree with their posts, but I don't see an agenda behind them or get the impression that they're fake.
Not Known 15... just doesn't seem like scum, albeit mostly because I can't see a survivalistic mindset behind it. It's not a slam dunk by any means, but it's enough to give me pause in wagoning this.
Espeonage had a few posts that resonated with me a bit, but otherwise I haven't been too impressed with their posting.
Nico looks like a distraction. The amount of suspicion on that slot is lightly reading town, but that's... really all that's readable from her.

[Kokichi Oma]

Momrangal is obvtown
the worst is obvtown

Kokichi Oma is just under obvtown

Espeonage is lightly town
Not Known 15 is lightly town

SnarkySnowman is null
NicoRobin is null

Alonzo is lightly scum

TheGoldenParadox is strongly scum
StefanB is strongly scum
Chickadee is strongly scum

Hahaha WHAT?????

[the worst]

D1 reads

[Kokichi Oma]

Too many people are scummy this game, I dont have time to find who is just bad town right now. So I'll get back to this later

[the worst]

Let's talk Anka first?

[Kokichi Oma]

Sure say what you need to about her, and I'll reply tomorrow

[the worst]

I'm a little bit mad about her, you go first

[Ankamius]

[StefanB]

Claim: 1 shoot bulletproof-lightning rod.
Every action did target me last night.
This is the first time I am sad not to be dead.
It was Chickadees role claim in her very first post and my Role made it clear that it was her second role.
The proven BP was not claimed by her.

Now I am Vanilla btw.

ahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

Your point?

[StefanB]

Ankamius:

Momrangal is obvtown

Not Known 15 is lightly town -> moderate town

NicoRobin is null -> lightly town

TheGoldenParadox is strongly scum

Those are the reads I want to hear more about.

[Ankamius]

Momrangal is hard to explain because it's mostly... she's just town. A lot of her thoughts rang true and her entire approach feels like gamesolving town.

TheGoldenParadox is the opposite; I honestly could just post their entire ISO and have that serve as a case because their approach just feels fake, posturey, and scum-motivated. They're actually close to lockscum to me.

NK15's only thing not indicating town is that really bad TIAM vote. Other than that, their analysis has actually been pretty good and they've read as skeptical town.

Nico... I'm not entirely sure? I didn't write down anything related to them, but it's probably related to how they went about their JK claim if I had to take a stab at the slight read change.

[the worst]

Agree strongly with Nico read fwiw
And she doesn't give much away as a player in general

[Ankamius]

Are you referring to me or nico?

[StefanB]

Nico is a difficult slot for me, too.
As is the slot you just inherited, Ankamius.
Will look at TGP, is one of the players who is very in the backround.

I have to say that Espeonage having a similar avatar than The Worst is somethink that I find makes the game a bit harder.

[Espeonage]

Git gud

[the worst]

Are you referring to me or nico?

Incidentally both of your SLOTS but 1062 was directed at Nico as a player

It's definitely not a criticism--she has beat me as scum so it'd be cheap to criticise --just true for her playstyle.

On the contrary Anka you are a bleeding heart.

[the worst]

I have to say that Espeonage having a similar avatar than The Worst is somethink that I find makes the game a bit harder.

If you're struggling just remember:
Mine faces towards the post
Espe's faces away from the post
ofrhz' is upside down

Easy!

[Alonzo]

Anka seems alot more genuine than Mafman

VOTE: TGP

[StefanB]

I looked at TGP and I do like a few post (his stand on the dayvig for example) but it would suprese me if he flipped scum.

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

[Alonzo]

It would or wouldn't?

@stefan

[StefanB]

wouldn't argh. Deleted it after I wrote to much into the brackets and looked not enough.

[mutantdevle]

- SnarkySnowman has requested replacement.

[TheGoldenParadox]

...
ok then.
I'm really sorry for being away so long and not declaring V/LA. My life is in such a huge mess right now, and I haven't even thought about Mafia. I apologize.

Anyways, @anikamus what the actual hell. You're scumreading me for "posturing" and say you could post my entire iso as a case. Yeah.. right. TBH I'm caught between just town failing to catch up or deliberate scum that's trying hard for a mislynch and still get towncred.

[Ankamius]

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox