Mini Theme 2008: Role Design Committee [Game Over]

[Chickadee]

Chick you dont scumread tgp?

I'll have to go back through and look at TGP. I want to try and see if I can see what other people are seeing. I'll do it a bit later today when I'm at work.

[TheGoldenParadox]

Is it just me or had tgp had a really terribly mood change in reaction to the wagon.

Like I joined because I was townreading most of the wagon, but this makes me feel good about it.

wutt
alt slip?
also
i didn't have a mood change in reaction to the wagon
i had a mood change in general

[TheGoldenParadox]

Chick you dont scumread tgp?

of course she doesn't because i'm not scum

also tw why do you join a wagon solely for the reason that you're townreading most of the people on the wagon
anikamius is scum. He replaced into a scum slot.
chick can you please vote ani with me? I feel like you're distancing yourself by trying to lynch Ani without a vote on him, and i'll have none of it. I don't see how you're going to get anyone to pursue an espe lynch and I really don't see espe scum. Please either vote or just flat-out shoot ani. Thanks.

[TheGoldenParadox]

Is it just me or had tgp had a really terribly mood change in reaction to the wagon.

Like I joined because I was townreading most of the wagon, but this makes me feel good about it.

wutt
alt slip?

oh wait nevermind HAHHAHHAHAHA stop trying to confuse me thanks

[Chickadee]

Chick you dont scumread tgp?

of course she doesn't because i'm not scum

also tw why do you join a wagon solely for the reason that you're townreading most of the people on the wagon
anikamius is scum. He replaced into a scum slot.
chick can you please vote ani with me? I feel like you're distancing yourself by trying to lynch Ani without a vote on him, and i'll have none of it. I don't see how you're going to get anyone to pursue an espe lynch and I really don't see espe scum. Please either vote or just flat-out shoot ani. Thanks.

I can't shoot Ani today. I already tried to shoot Nico. But sure, I can vote Ani with you.

VOTE: Ankamius

[Ankamius]

Please do

I live for wagons on myself

[Kokichi Oma]

VOTE: ani

[Kokichi Oma]

VOTE: ank *

[the worst]

who suggested that snarky wagon a while ago?

[Momrangal]

Taking Zombies into consideration?
I think the fact that the mod confirmed Chick action is not a secret. If you saw more, than talk to the mod.

Necromancer game

Also all I know is devel confirmed it, but I no longer see the confirmation

[Momrangal]

Also I did! Interested in pines catch up.

Do not like this ank wagon

[Momrangal]

Why are there so many duckd

[Chickadee]

Do you not like who is not he wagon, or wagoning Anka?

[StefanB]

Taking Zombies into consideration?
I think the fact that the mod confirmed Chick action is not a secret. If you saw more, than talk to the mod.

Necromancer game

Also all I know is devel confirmed it, but I no longer see the confirmation

He posted that the action was recieved. You are right the rest was not post in tread.

[Alonzo]

@ nico

are you MY JK? do you see what needs to happen?

[Not Known 15]

VOTE: Chickadee
Ankamius called her out for her suboptimal contributions.
Especially the daykill attempt out of nowhere and their general looseness with the daykill.
Until now I treated her as town because of her role.

That was stupid, and here is why:
It is one shot of a kill.
Normally this would be strange on Mafia because it gives Mafia a free kill and town one less lynch.
However...
On night 1, due to Stefan and their role(1-shot BP LR), Mafia actually did NOT have a kill!
This role makes perfect sense as mafia.

[Chickadee]

VOTE: Chickadee
Ankamius called her out for her suboptimal contributions.
Especially the daykill attempt out of nowhere and their general looseness with the daykill.
Until now I treated her as town because of her role.

That was stupid, and here is why:
It is one shot of a kill.
Normally this would be strange on Mafia because it gives Mafia a free kill and town one less lynch.
However...
On night 1, due to Stefan and their role(1-shot BP LR), Mafia actually did NOT have a kill!
This role makes perfect sense as mafia.

I actively encouraged Stefan to use his role that night. Your logic is flawed.

[NicoRobin]

@ nico

are you MY JK? do you see what needs to happen?

I am not sure who designed my role, as it was never specified.

[Alonzo]

@ nico

are you MY JK? do you see what needs to happen?

I am not sure who designed my role, as it was never specified.

is your role pm 10 words long with ok as the first word?

confirm with the tenth word.

[Alonzo]

Did anybody else submit jailkeeper?

speak now!

[NicoRobin]

@ nico

are you MY JK? do you see what needs to happen?

I am not sure who designed my role, as it was never specified.

is your role pm 10 words long with ok as the first word?

confirm with the tenth word.

ability

[the worst]

role PMs probs aren't like verbatim what you sent in

[StefanB]

Holly chainsaws.

Interesting, one of the mainreasons that there is a waggon on TGP is Ankamius (note I am sorry for mystyping that name, because I probably will someday).

Chick votes the attacker (Ankamus), then Not Known15 votes Chick.

What makes that complicated for me is that I have a townread one one player, and a townlean on another, and they are on different sides of that.

Intresting, to note.

About Nktheory: Yes that one is flawed, exspecially considering that Chick did get her rolePM and then submitted the on-shot BP lightningrod, thus creating the situation (I know that because my role made it clear that it was the second role).
Also the kill was stopped through the JK, another factor that worked.
We have some safty messures that make killing people harder that is true.

I can confirm that Chick knew my role and we were openly discusing me using it, look back at day 1 and it should be obvious that she knew.

[Not Known 15]

exspecially considering that Chick did get her rolePM and then submitted

no. She got her alignment PM. The role PM came later.

(I know that because my role made it clear that it was the second role).

What makes you sure that your role means that she is town? You stop one kill, not two.
You also make every other action redirect to you, including things like the The Worst curse, removing one day for actions to target others...
It is not that powerful in reality that it couldn't be abused as a "clear" for Mafia who submitted it.
The Mafia had factional communication during the second stage of the role submission, it would have been easy to coordinate submissions.

[StefanB]

Sorry meant alligment role.

Now that question is if you are mafia, do you use that roles to clear yourself and create a potential very townsideszenario or use the roles to make it better for scum, I know I would probably do the second.
Do you think there is much inition to send the role Chick did send for scum besides towncredit?

Thinks from your points that I don't attack:
1. A vigshoot exspecially a one-shot can be scum.