Mini Theme 2022: Trapped! [Gameover]

[Myloninja13]

Yeah okay I'm cool now. Let's do this challenge!

[Myloninja13]

!guess #6

[Myloninja13]

Just in case this takes a while, here's another Qu-Qu-Question!

If you were scum last night, would YOU have killed GuiltyLion or me? And Why?

[mutantdevle]

!guess #6

Lower.

2

guesses remain.

[Feysal]

First up, yes, Enigma did scumread Koki and then get killed. Which at first glance is bad for Koki but at the same point this comes back to head VS gut because you know he was doing that means it's a super easy suspicion NK. Besides, as scum!you, I don't see what's all too crazy about killing Enigma here? At that point everyone seemed to be townreading you and Enigma, despite GL's suspicion, was not a very viable mislynch. And I'm pretty sure GL in particular was townreading you just as strongly anyway?

I thought I'd already gone over this. One more time then.

GuiltyLion was unlynchable due to his interaction with Pine. That alone would have been reason enough to kill him. Add the fact that he had suspected Enigma, and I could have used that to attack Enigma further. It would have been easy for me, since I had also voiced my suspicion which I could build on. As for how viable the Enigma mislynch was, I think you're just plain wrong. Enigma and Ofrhz were being town read for largely the same reason, yet Enigma had some remaining suspicion against him despite that. He should have been easier to mislynch than Ofrhz, who of course was lynched.

Now, consider what I would have to gain from killing Enigma over GuiltyLion. Instead of having Enigma as potential mislynch, I would be left with GuiltyLion, who would remain unlynchable. Instead of being able to build on my own case against Enigma, I would make myself look foolish for having been wrong about him. The only benefit I would gain would be using Enigma's suspicion of Kokichi against him. Except, I did not. I never said a word about it, and did not even make the connection until you asked about it.

Since Enigma did not suspect me, I would not need to kill him for my own survival either. That leaves me with no reason I can think of to target him.

As for what I said about Chickadee, I was just wrong. I don't think my reasoning was flawed, although I realized later that pretending to post private communication would be just as bad as doing it for real. I never imagined she had actually written her last will from a town perspective. In hindsight, she must have feigned her concern over sharing her last will to make it more credible, and I fell for it.

[Feysal]

If you were scum last night, would YOU have killed GuiltyLion or me? And Why?

I don't know. I might have killed GuiltyLion due to his strong early play, but I might just as well have picked randomly.

Is there even any point to doing this challenge? There are no unfortunates left, and even if there were, this is the last day. The rules say you can skip a challenge, so why not do it?

VOTE: forfeit

[mutantdevle]

- A little note here, forfeits only need a majority to go through. (1/2 so far).

[Kokichi Oma]

Just in case this takes a while, here's another Qu-Qu-Question!

If you were scum last night, would YOU have killed GuiltyLion or me? And Why?

I think I answered this. But, likely you. Only because guilty lion has townread me since the beginning of the game.

[Myloninja13]

If you were scum last night, would YOU have killed GuiltyLion or me? And Why?

I don't know. I might have killed GuiltyLion due to his strong early play, but I might just as well have picked randomly.

Is there even any point to doing this challenge? There are no unfortunates left, and even if there were, this is the last day. The rules say you can skip a challenge, so why not do it?

VOTE: forfeit

Oh yeah, true lol.

VOTE: Forfeit

[Myloninja13]

Hopefully we have this.... I think I know who scum is.

[Myloninja13]

I asked a friend today and they backed up my answer so woo?

[Kokichi Oma]

As long as you don't vote me we win. Not too hard.

[mutantdevle]

Oof you failed the challenge, who could have guessed. No fortunate role will be awarded.

It's voting time bois, you know the drill!

[mutantdevle]

The voting phase has begun. You have (expired on 2018-10-25 15:00:00) to answer both of the following questions:

You must now vote for who you think is a saboteur and why?

How would you feel about being trapped?

[mutantdevle]

The people have voted.



This is what feysal said:

"VOTE: Kokichi Oma

I'm town, so he is not. Can't get simpler than this."

This is what kokichi said:

"Voting feysal.

Hes scum!"

And finally, this is what myloninja said:

"Okay, so after many long days and many challenges we finally come to the last decision. Somehow, I'M the one who must choose who I believe is the final scum, which is a bit WOAH and kinda really terrifying.

Ultimately though, I can not in good conscience betray myself and as such I will be voting for Feysal to go. Feysal if you are town I am really, genuinely sorry but I just can't see Koki as anything but town here. You have BOTH played well here no matter who is town or scum so please remember that! I'd be happy to play any more games with you guys once I finish my mafia break (Or until I get requested to join one lol).

But yes, I do vote for Feysal to go home here. Koki, if you are scum well played but I can not reasonably see you getting a red role PM this game."

So the final votecount is this:
Feysal (2) - Kokichi Oma, Myloninja13 - LYNCHED.
Kokichi Oma (1) - Feysal.


Now at this point, the only person who doesn't know the results is myloninja13. So before I reveal to him whether he fucked up or not, let's see Feysal's final words:

"Very disappointed. Your gut is meant for digestion, but not of ideas."

Feysal's role is this:

Spoiler: Role

Myloninja13 fucked up. (aka, Feysal was a fortunate)

[mutantdevle]

Spoiler: Winners!

Congratulations to Kokichi Oma, Pine & Chickadee on their mafia win!

despite how scummy they all were on day 1

Myloninja13 got endgamed, RIP.

I will post some other stuff including the PTs later because I'm only here posting this stuff because it's long overdue.

[Enigma]

:/

[Myloninja13]

:/

[Myloninja13]

Sorry guys, sometimes the head is much better than the gut clearly.

AHhhhhh, like the entire time at the end I knew Koki was more suspicious technically, I just felt like it was too easy, and Koki's actions seemed towny to me. Both of y'all played very well btw, great game haha.

Honestly, it might've been better if one of Ofrhz/Feysal was a fortunate as I'm pretty sure both of them wouldn't have lynched me over Koki haha.

[Kokichi Oma]

yaaaay

[teacher]

What in the actual?!

[ofrhz]

gg! Kokichi played up the wifom very well

[Feysal]

...

[Irrelephant11]

Sadddddd
Well played town, still proud of how we caught chick/pine and used the voting mechanics to our advantage
Well played scum, kokichi with the game-winning bus against Pine is probably the mvp

[Kokichi Oma]

Thanks everyone.