Mini 2052: Downtown Train Mafia - Game Over!

[Amor]

I'm still here. I'm not really feeling the TGP wagon -- he seems to be making an effort, and his votes are largely in line with my suspicions. Waiting to see what Munch has to say, because I did not have a good feeling about that slot when Tony was in it.

[Robert2424]

I'm still here, just mainly stumped.

[Bambi Jay]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

[Lady Angel]

Votecount:

Robert2424: 1 (Allomancer)

TheGoldenParadox: 3 (Bambi Jay, Brassherald, Northsidegal)

TonyMontana: 2 (Robert2424, TheGoldenParadox)
Bambi Jay: 2 (Amor, Darth Vader)

Not Voting: RCEnigma, Munchmellow

Leading Wagons are in bold.

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

The following players have yet to post and will be prodded if they do not post before the next votecount: Allomancer, Brassherald, RCEnigma, Munchmellow

Prodding Darth Vader.

Day 1 ends on Wednesday, January 23rd at 6:00 PM PST, or 10 days, 21 hours and 36 minutes from this post.

[Darth Vader]

if you're town you should know better than to present the false dichotomy of absolutely no mention of brass' alignment at all and that type of screaming.

Yep, this struck out to me, too.

~A

[Darth Vader]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

Ah, thought I voted there previously.
VOTE: TGP

~A

[Darth Vader]

I'm still here. I'm not really feeling the TGP wagon -- he seems to be making an effort, and his votes are largely in line with my suspicions. Waiting to see what Munch has to say, because I did not have a good feeling about that slot when Tony was in it.

That effort looks more like scum effort though.
Can you elaborate again on your suspicions, in detail? Do you disagree with NSG's meta on Jay?

~A

[RCEnigma]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

Well I want Allo dead and everyone else says town so, meh. I'd Lynch Tony's slot as well now for...reasons.

[brassherald]

Looked at TGP's iso and I don't see anything wrong with it

Let's try another approach, what do you see in it that is Towny?

I still want this.

[Robert2424]

I honestly Feel better about TGP then past times. So its a moot wagon to me.

I would like to explore different options and get more of the quieter folks talking.

Vote Munchmellow

Hiding in Shadows is common scum tactic, especially here on mafia scum.

[Amor]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

So, we're all scum then?

Re: Vader, this kind of stuff is why I still have a scum read on Bambi. I think someone who is lazy town wouldn't get quite so agitated about being voted. And it would be very easy for someone to hide behind a meta like that.

[Allomancer]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

Well I want Allo dead and everyone else says town so, meh. I'd Lynch Tony's slot as well now for...reasons.

Why do you want me dead?

Also, town falling silent could be suspicious, but speaking for myself personally, I was kinda excited when the game first started, but now I'm not really interested at this point. There's also a serious momentum situation: when the game slows down, there's less to post about, so the game slows down even more.

[Munchmellow]

Ok, this is my first time replacing and I find it hard to organize my thoughts on everything that happened.

Here's my readlist:
{Town} NSG, RCE
{Null-town} Bambi, DV
{Null} Robert, Amor
{Null-scum} TGP, Allo
{Scum} Brass

NSG - posts seem very townie, clear opinions, good vibe
Bambi - I can see why people would say she's not playing the game and makes posts without content, but I don't think this is AI in this case. So I trust NSG's judgement for now.
RCE - I don't agree with a lot of things he's saying, but I don't see his posts coming from scum. I liked his 155 and it made me rethink my null read on Allo.
DV- makes some good points, I liked his 107, looks like he really is scumhunting, generally I am getting townvibes
Amor - I don't have much to say here and I don't really know what to think about him
Allo- not much content but enough excuses
Robert - I don't have much to say here. Nothing scummy, but nothing that I wpuld sort him as town either.
TGP - I agree with NSG's 240. A lot of posts that seem meaningfull and pro-town on first sight, but aren't that important for game progress. Very narrow focused posts.
Brass- Did not like that ITH. Asks a lot- why do you scumread that guy, why did you do that, post some analysis - but didn't see him provide any answers or analysis.

[Munchmellow]

VOTE: brassherald

[Allomancer]

Looked at TGP's iso and I don't see anything wrong with it

Let's try another approach, what do you see in it that is Towny?

I still want this.

I think 164 makes a case.
I see nothing inherently scummy about the big L-1. If anything, it's good to let the town know when we get to that point.

[Allomancer]

Brass- Did not like that ITH. Asks a lot- why do you scumread that guy, why did you do that, post some analysis - but didn't see him provide any answers or analysis.

I disagree. Asking questions is actually very beneficial to town. Brass is one of the towniest here IMO.

[Munchmellow]

@Robert
From what you say, I gather you townread NSG, feel good about TGP and null read Bambi.

Am I your only scumread? Can you give reasons for your read or is it just level of activity? Who else do you scumread?

I honestly Feel better about TGP then past times.

What about TGP makes you feel better?

Any thoughts about others?

[Munchmellow]

Brass- Did not like that ITH. Asks a lot- why do you scumread that guy, why did you do that, post some analysis - but didn't see him provide any answers or analysis.

I disagree. Asking questions is actually very beneficial to town. Brass is one of the towniest here IMO.

I agree that asking questions is good, but I think it is a bit hypocritical to only interogate and not state your own opinion. It is also a good way to get towncred without having to post opinions and analysis that could bite you in the ass later.

[Darth Vader]

Munch's list on replacing in seems good on the whole, feeling a lot better about her than Tony. But I don't agree that brass's ITH was that scummy.

Auro feels a bit more strongly on town Allo than I do but I agree with him that TGP is the path for today. -D

[brassherald]

If anyone asks me questions, I'll answer them. No one is asking me questions, so I have nothing to answer.

I like asking questions, I'm fine with answering, I don't want to clog up the thread with my thoughts where maybe no one is interested in my specific thoughts.

And read lists suck ass.

[brassherald]

Also, if people legitimately think I would bother asking questions to people to hide as scum, read my scum games and look how ridiculously bad I actually am. I've shared opinions on shit in this game, probably more than I usually do on a day 1. Because, again, read lists are sucky and I hate them plus, I don't trust any of you mofos... Except NSG, she's town.

By extension Bambi can be town as well.

Was it this game where I did my read list joke?

I don't remember
{Me}
{Everyone else, I'm last town, aren't I?}

[Lady Angel]

Votecount:

Robert2424: 1 (Allomancer)

TheGoldenParadox: 4 (Bambi Jay, Brassherald, Northsidegal, Darth Vader) L-2

Munchmellow: 2 (Robert2424, TheGoldenParadox)
Bambi Jay: 1 (Amor)
Brassherald: 1 (Munchmellow)

Not Voting: RCEnigma

Leading Wagons are in bold.

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

The following players have yet to post and will be prodded if they do not post before the next votecount: Bambi Jay, Northsidegal, TheGoldenParadox,

Day 1 ends on Wednesday, January 23rd at 6:00 PM PST, or 9 days, 22 hours and 43 minutes from this post.

[RCEnigma]

Don't know how I feel about being townspewed, Bambi call me scum q.q

[Bambi Jay]

I'd do that but I'm too lazy.

Honestly I'll put my actual effort into this game tommorow and see why TGP is scummy or if I notice something else.

[RCEnigma]

Sad the town literally had all the energy in the world to try and mob-Lynch me but suddenly when it's TGP's turn your all quiet.

Glad to know where the motivation is here.

Well I want Allo dead and everyone else says town so, meh. I'd Lynch Tony's slot as well now for...reasons.

Why do you want me dead?

Also, town falling silent could be suspicious, but speaking for myself personally, I was kinda excited when the game first started, but now I'm not really interested at this point. There's also a serious momentum situation: when the game slows down, there's less to post about, so the game slows down even more.

Well you still haven't posted about anything....like at all. Brass may not like readslists but at the very least humor me with one.

Because at the moment no one knows where you fall one way or the other. I wouldn't call it fencesitting, more like benchsitting. Which is why I don't get all of the townreads on your slot.