911: What's Your Emergency? (Postgame)

[insomnia]

Next pers to claim is Inviz, cuz maria doesn’t care about the game, consider I’m Maria

[Elbirn]

Next pers to claim is Inviz, cuz maria doesn’t care about the game, consider I’m Maria

.....Hi Maria I'm Dad?

[Enigma]

so ive been scum in this scenario before (see ofrhz's open) where there is a JK and a protective, and one scum left

so ive thought this out before - scum can choose to either:
1. try to pick off the claimed prs
2. choose to no kill and throw shade on the claimed prs
thus we need to remember the above when thinking about strats

----
(worst case mislynch) scenario where scum kills, assuming tprs are true (in which case scum nk them)

today:
8 town vs 1 scum
8 in poe pool, 1 conf town

(mis)lynch 1:
7 town vs 1 scum
7 in poe pool, 1 conf town

scum night kill (doc):
6 town vs 1 scum
5 in poe pool, 2 conf town

(mis)lynch 2:
5 town vs 1 scum
4 in poe pool, 2 conf town

scum night kill (jk):
4 town vs 1 scum
2 in poe pool, 3 conf town

(mis)lynch 3:
3 town vs 1 scum
1 in poe pool, 3 conf town

scum night kill:
2 town vs 1 scum
1 in poe pool, 2 conf town

LYLO - town win

mechanically, we win this game

---

next post - thoughts when scum doesnt kill
another post - if tprs are lying

[Invisibility]

im a vt
someone else decide who goes next

[rosterfoster]

Elbirn.

[rosterfoster]

Or Vedith or Enigma

[Invisibility]

also yeah it was april 23rd 2:03:28 am when night ended and volxen posted the claim on april 23rd 2:07:50 am

[Invisibility]

ok vedith i guess

[Enigma]

I’ll go
VT

Elbrin next , then Vedith ?
Actually which ever is online first idc

[Vedith]

I already claimed.
Shows that no one cares about me :<

[Enigma]

I already claimed.
Shows that no one cares about me :<

[Enigma]

claims

enigma: vt
vizzy: vt
vedith: vt
maria: doc (ofrhz n1, tris n2)
insomnia: jk (maria n1, rooster n2)

remaining: elbrin, tris, ym, rooster

elbrin next

[Enigma]

It's 1 scum left (prob a strongman if the jk/doctor are real)

btw this might be a thing, but probably n-shot if thats the case
or something that is a rb, or something else like that for balance

so consider rooster a soft-clear

[Enigma]

im a vt
someone else decide who goes next

arent u a neighbour?

[insomnia]

VOTE: Invisibility

[insomnia]

really hope that was a hammer. unlikely tho

[Elbirn]

Doubt.

I'm a VT, I want YM to go next

[tris]

(mis)lynch 2:
5 town vs 1 scum
4 in poe pool, 2 conf town

scum night kill (jk):
4 town vs 1 scum
2 in poe pool, 3 conf town

Why do we gain a conf town here? By my calculations, this ends with lylo with 1 conf town who will have a 50-50 chance. That's of course assuming the mafia makes it there.

[Vedith]

Well call me confirmed town and it's a win.

[tris]

Well call me confirmed town and it's a win.

Yeah, if we can accurately townread someone other than the prs and roster, it's gg. And, I do think you're town.

[insomnia]

I feel like everyone else is claiming VT. Shall we vote?

[rosterfoster]

Highly likely.

I also feel Vizzy is just the last scum.

[Yes Mafia]

(prob a strongman if the jk/doctor are real)

Uh.

insom jailed you while you docced ofhrz on n1. It's somewhat bizarre that you put out this possibility without mentioning at all that what if there is no strongman. This just makes me more paranoid because it reminds me of the Children of Hurin theme game where you fake claimed town parity cop, but were actually the mafia godfather....so we ended up losing that game.

----
if there were no strongman, then insom jail maria, maria doc ofhrz - means the protection on ofrhz failed due to insom jailkeeping maria. So it could mean there is no strongman. however if both protectives are truly town, then existence of a strongman is possible because it makes a ton of sense for mafia strongman against doc+jk. but with a redirector, who knows, maybe there was no need for a strongman anyway...

Mechanically, setups consisting of town jk+doc are incredibly bizarre....I don't recall ever seeing both exist in a setup from top of my head.

@mod curious question - was this setup reviewed, and if so by who?

[Yes Mafia]

UNVOTE:

I'm also vt.

In the case of a mislynch - with roster cleared by night actions, a doc, and jk, I agree that the doc should protect jk while the jk jailkeeps at night.

[insomnia]

If Vizzy isn’t the scum here, I’m down with lynching Maria tomorrow.