Mini Theme 2077 - Restless Spirits Mafia [ENDED]

[Ankamius]

Vote Count 1.4

[2]

Rx Strange Brew

- mastina, Titus

[2]

Montosh

- Elbirn, Lil Uzi Vert

[2]

ConManMick

- Gamma Emerald, rosterfoster
[1]

rosterfoster

- Montosh
[1]

mastina

- NotMySpamAccount
[1]

Lil Uzi Vert

- Nero Cain
[1]

Creature

- RAS
[1]

Elbirn

- ConManMick
Gamma Emerald -
Nero Cain -
NotMySpamAccount -
RAS -
Titus


Not Voting (2): Creature, RX Strange Brew

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2019-06-01 19:00:00) from now, or June 1st, 7:00 PM CST (GMT-6).

Prodding: N/A
Replacing: N/A

[ConManMick]

ConManMick, the nights I will be drunk will be random. That being said, trying to think exactly like me is hard to do in either state.

I'll spend the game drunk then.

It's gonna be a long month... At least the game is 2077

[Titus]

That doesn't sound healthy.

[Nero Cain]

but how many times has drunk Titus been scum Titus?

[NotMySpamAccount]

Ho boy I'm gonna end up lurking the heck out of this game.

hmmmmmmmmm. VOTE: mastina I don't like that opening at all.

Could you elaborate?

A lot of the arguments here are based on meta, and I haven't played with most of these people, so I'm at a bit of a disadvantage. With that said, opening by claiming a role like that seems really fishy, especially if you've done it in the past as scum. None of mastina's posts since then have sounded at all towny, in fact most have sounded extraordinarily scummy.

[ConManMick]

That's very fair. I'm also not really fond of meta reads in general because in the past I've personally deliberately played to avoid having consistent meta myself, so I don't consider it reliable, and people borderline use it for trust tells.
However in this case: were the role replaced with a miller role, wouldn't you think it fair to claim out the gates?

[RAS]

Just some quick thoughts regarding this whole Nancy thing.

Nancy's frustration level here don't make any sense for someone who was excited to be in this game; 106/107. Tonally, it's not even remotely natural, and the way she handled Roster's vote just feels forced to me. I'm not valuing the fact that she's replacing out into any of this since it's her initial reaction to the vote that bothers me the most.

I still believe that Creature is scum, but I'm more content placing my vote here because of the above.

VOTE: RX.

[ConManMick]

Are you willing to expand on your creature read at this point, or do you still wanna play those cards close to your chest?

[RAS]

I dislike Creature's opening posts and find them forced. It's based on fairly flimsy reasoning considering what he's contributed so far, and something I'd rather not go into.

The above still stands true and is the reason why I haven't gone too much into it. It's not "playing those cards close to my chest", it's just something I don't think I have to go into yet until he contributes more. I can go into it into more detail though.

I think 100 is a poor attempt to throw away what was a legit discussion with the whole Mastina thing. There are a lot of reasons why it was still discussed, and I find it odd why someone would question why it's still being discussed. It basically got the game going, and is still the main topic of discussion.

104 is flat-out false considering how many people brought up in this game that Town!Mastina doesn't do this. It feels like such a lazy read when there were a lot of discussions before this. I don't believe that the only read he got from the previous pages is Town!Mastina.

[Ankamius]

**Flavor Leaf replaces RX Strange Brew effective immediately.**

[Flavor Leaf]

Sorry. I’ve been inactive. I’m replacing in solo, I guess here. Nancy got upset about stuff and couldn’t get ahold of me because I was gone all of yesterday and the day before, but I should be here later today.

[Flavor Leaf]

Just some quick thoughts regarding this whole Nancy thing.

Nancy's frustration level here don't make any sense for someone who was excited to be in this game; 106/107. Tonally, it's not even remotely natural, and the way she handled Roster's vote just feels forced to me. I'm not valuing the fact that she's replacing out into any of this since it's her initial reaction to the vote that bothers me the most.

I still believe that Creature is scum, but I'm more content placing my vote here because of the above.

VOTE: RX.

Why? Things can change. She was upset for multiple reasons after, one including feeling like I wasn’t doing anything.

[Flavor Leaf]

Do you have a better one?

I don’t vote without a reason unless it’s to prevent a no lynch, so you’re asking the wrong person.

VOTE: Rx Strange Brew

A player refusing to be VCA read. Well it's a good policy lynch.

True VCA people can read the lack of votes as votes.

[ConManMick]

I dislike Creature's opening posts and find them forced. It's based on fairly flimsy reasoning considering what he's contributed so far, and something I'd rather not go into.

The above still stands true and is the reason why I haven't gone too much into it. It's not "playing those cards close to my chest", it's just something I don't think I have to go into yet until he contributes more. I can go into it into more detail though.

I think 100 is a poor attempt to throw away what was a legit discussion with the whole Mastina thing. There are a lot of reasons why it was still discussed, and I find it odd why someone would question why it's still being discussed. It basically got the game going, and is still the main topic of discussion.

104 is flat-out false considering how many people brought up in this game that Town!Mastina doesn't do this. It feels like such a lazy read when there were a lot of discussions before this. I don't believe that the only read he got from the previous pages is Town!Mastina.

I think 100 could be read as a lack of comprehension of the discussion to that point, imo. I can see where you're coming from though. I need to re-read re: your comment on 104 though

[Flavor Leaf]

So there’s 100% scum on The Strange Brew wagon. Really terrible reasoning, even if it wasn’t on my former hydra slot. It’s Nancy, and people have those reasonings to get a wagon on her this early? Lol

[Flavor Leaf]

I mean, that’s fine to get some pressure on her, but anyone thinking they had an actual read is either lying or fooling themselves.

[Flavor Leaf]

I wanna just sheep mastina this game.

VOTE: RX

Sheep me. Mastina has a tendency to tunnel town me.

[Flavor Leaf]

Just some quick thoughts regarding this whole Nancy thing.

Nancy's frustration level here don't make any sense for someone who was excited to be in this game; 106/107. Tonally, it's not even remotely natural, and the way she handled Roster's vote just feels forced to me. I'm not valuing the fact that she's replacing out into any of this since it's her initial reaction to the vote that bothers me the most.

I still believe that Creature is scum, but I'm more content placing my vote here because of the above.

VOTE: RX.

Piggybacking on this, Nancy’s reaction ONLY makes sense for someone excited for this game.

She got upset because one, Rosterfoster, two, I hadn’t responded to her in a bit because I was out of town and sorta forgot the pass to Strange Bree, three, she was excited for this game and she got hard wagoner.

That is classic Nancy. How does that not make sense? This seems projecty.

[RAS]

Piggybacking on this, Nancy’s reaction ONLY makes sense for someone excited for this game.

She got upset because one, Rosterfoster, two, I hadn’t responded to her in a bit because I was out of town and sorta forgot the pass to Strange Bree, three, she was excited for this game and she got hard wagoner.

That is classic Nancy. How does that not make sense? This seems projecty.

No. If I'm excited about something, I'm not going to throw it away because one unfortunate event happened. A simple vote made her completely snap out of this game, and I don't think that's a natural thought process at all. The wagon wasn't "hard" at all, that's a bit of a stretch.

It doesn't make sense to me that someone would flip out this much over something so small.

[Flavor Leaf]

Piggybacking on this, Nancy’s reaction ONLY makes sense for someone excited for this game.

She got upset because one, Rosterfoster, two, I hadn’t responded to her in a bit because I was out of town and sorta forgot the pass to Strange Bree, three, she was excited for this game and she got hard wagoner.

That is classic Nancy. How does that not make sense? This seems projecty.

No. If I'm excited about something, I'm not going to throw it away because one unfortunate event happened. A simple vote made her completely snap out of this game, and I don't think that's a natural thought process at all. The wagon wasn't "hard" at all, that's a bit of a stretch.

It doesn't make sense to me that someone would flip out this much over something so small.

YOU are not going to, sure.

Nancy WOULD and HAS. This is you projecting a seemingly easy target.

[Flavor Leaf]

She’s very impulsive.

[Titus]

but how many times has drunk Titus been scum Titus?

Random tbh. I am equally drunk as town or scum. Alignment does not impact BAC. I frequently play both alignments simultaneously too.

[rosterfoster]

VOTE: RAS

Yeah there is no way Flavour slot is scum.

[rosterfoster]

Btw Nancy I can always give you some chicken ice cream to make you feel better <3

[Titus]

That's very fair. I'm also not really fond of meta reads in general because in the past I've personally deliberately played to avoid having consistent meta myself, so I don't consider it reliable, and people borderline use it for trust tells.
However in this case: were the role replaced with a miller role, wouldn't you think it fair to claim out the gates?

Millers claim post 1. If you change another's role, you must at least hint at it, no matter how obscurely.