Read 10716 again. I never said that I suspected Nahdia as scum. I said that Almost50 and JaeReed suspected that Nahdia is scum, so I targeted Nahdia in order to avoid another day of pointless speculation, in addition to them being the only target that could provide a definite result.In post 10721, PeregrineV wrote:
Actually, your death along with the crumb that has never been is what we are looking for way more than who you followed and where they went.
What made you think Nahdia might be scum performing the kill and not the Jailkeeper she claimed?
Except you claimed weak, which means you could target mafia and give a result of your death, which would in turn allow us to catch an actual mafia player.In post 10726, Giovanni il Pellegrino wrote:Read 10716 again. I never said that I suspected Nahdia as scum. I said that Almost50 and JaeReed suspected that Nahdia is scum, so I targeted Nahdia in order to avoid another day of pointless speculation, in addition to them being the only target that could provide a definite result.In post 10721, PeregrineV wrote:
Actually, your death along with the crumb that has never been is what we are looking for way more than who you followed and where they went.
What made you think Nahdia might be scum performing the kill and not the Jailkeeper she claimed?
The Mathblade lynch was bad. There was no reason to lynch him BEFORE Giovanni.In post 10728, Ankamius wrote:PeregrineV, what are your thoughts on the rest of the game?
This is actually a very interesting point. I don't think anybody is scumreading me right now. Do you have any guesses why?In post 10729, PeregrineV wrote:Your claim of hated seems to me to be a shortcut for scum to secure an easy win if they keep you as a scumread until this point in the game. Is anyone scumreading you?
Not at all. If I was I assure you I would have been lynched long ago. I've been offered a chance on a golden plate earlier and all I had to do is go along with Math's plan.In post 10733, JaeReed wrote:Almost, are you a jester of sorts?
Read above. We're in a situation where we must be taking chances anyway. If I'm not lynched it would be PV, Ank, Gio or you. I can't see any of those 4 being scum either. Maybe I'm carrying on my initial reads from before the Maxous lynch and that's what is blinding me?In post 10734, BigYoshiFan wrote:I find it hard to believe that if you're town you'd be pushing for your lynch like this, because no one is suggesting it.
But for that same reason, I find it hard to believe that you're scum.
BUT it ALL makes sense if you're a jester.
The thing is they can still nightkill me into a 3man lylo because they won't need their abilities anymore.In post 10735, Almost50 wrote:But if we are 5 vs 1 then it does have he benefit of protecting you for tonight and -depending on whether we have a NK or not- maybe take you into a 3-man LyLo where YOU will decide the game outcome.
Well, you didn't hammer anyone of lae, so I'm assuming you're still a vig.In post 10739, Ankamius wrote:Almost50: What state do you think I am at right now?
Again, assuming you didn't shoot, but only because you were not sure whom to shoot.In post 10740, Ankamius wrote:Alternatively and potentially more relevant, what do you think the relevance of only a single kill last night is?
Are you assuming I'm town here? It wouldn't make any sense to not shoot as scum.In post 10742, Almost50 wrote:Again, assuming you didn't shoot, but only because you were not sure whom to shoot.In post 10740, Ankamius wrote:Alternatively and potentially more relevant, what do you think the relevance of only a single kill last night is?
Like, how am I supposed to know if it's any different when I don't even know what states your role goes through and in what order?
My problem with your logic here is that, in your scenario, Maxous picks based on PR strength alone. SirCakez's Inventor was far from a powerful PR compared to others, yet he got chosen. It seems simplistic to pick your cult based onIn post 10738, Almost50 wrote:OK, let me try to put myself in Maxous' shoes and see what I can come up with:
So far, you have said over and over again how bad I have misplayed the role.Except you claimed weak, which means you could target mafia and give a result of your death, which would in turn allow us to catch an actual mafia player.
Except that had you died, we would have had no result ONCE again, because you left no information on your supposed target.
It's almost as if you don't get your role, like it's not real.....
So, when you explain your actions and results as if you are not a weak follower, it makes it harder to believe you're a weak follower.
Follow me?
Vote: Giovanni
Can you link me to a game you played that had a Jester in it?In post 10733, JaeReed wrote:Almost, are you a jester of sorts?
You misplayed the role 3 times in a row. Both aspects of your claimed role. So 6 times. Even after being called out on it by me the first time.In post 10745, Giovanni il Pellegrino wrote:My problem with your logic here is that, in your scenario, Maxous picks based on PR strength alone. SirCakez's Inventor was far from a powerful PR compared to others, yet he got chosen. It seems simplistic to pick your cult based onIn post 10738, Almost50 wrote:OK, let me try to put myself in Maxous' shoes and see what I can come up with:claimedPRs alone.
However, even if we go by PRs alone, survivability of a claimed role is another factor to take into account. A vanilla townie would normally be a bad target to cult, but because of that, they have a lower chance to be lynched and nightkilled; A powerful PR not getting nighkilled eventually raises alarms and can be easily lynched, a vanilla townie not so much.
And no, I am not stating that JaeReed might be scum. It was an example.
So far, you have said over and over again how bad I have misplayed the role.Except you claimed weak, which means you could target mafia and give a result of your death, which would in turn allow us to catch an actual mafia player.
Except that had you died, we would have had no result ONCE again, because you left no information on your supposed target.
It's almost as if you don't get your role, like it's not real.....
So, when you explain your actions and results as if you are not a weak follower, it makes it harder to believe you're a weak follower.
Follow me?
Vote: Giovanni
What exactly is scummy in my play other than that?
Also, was I scum from the beginning of the game or did I got culted when Maxous got lynched?
Why?In post 10746, PeregrineV wrote:Can you link me to a game you played that had a Jester in it?In post 10733, JaeReed wrote:Almost, are you a jester of sorts?