Fire Emblem: Heroes of Mafia [Game Over]

[GuyInFreezer]

Tbh if i had a killing ability i would stab dunnstral regardless of my alignment and never look back.

No you wouldn't have, I didn't pay you much attention day 1

I meant that as regardless of what happened in the game.
From what ive seen from the games that i modded, you looked like a player who is fun to nightkill randomly just to see the reaction in the dead thread.

[Dunnstral]

you looked like a player who is fun to nightkill randomly just to see the reaction in the dead thread.

? ? ?

[Fro99er]

I'll post real things tomorrow

Daytona 500 today

[Fro99er]

Frogger why were you townreading Brian

I was scumreading him by mid-day/end of day

[Vifam]

VOTE: NotChara

[Vifam]

tbh I was scumreading but by the time the day ended I was starting to think he was town

[Fro99er]

Then I decided he fake dumbslipped and was scum with NC

[Gammagooey]

I have something similar to a gut town read on Not Chara but really I think it's mostly that everything I think people are scumreading them for is null and I like the overall tone of their posts. Like the only thing I'd say is straight bad is them not really existing at the end of the day right after having a wagon on them.

[Vifam]

Why are you voting PV

[Gammagooey]

I think his demeanor change to suddenly trying to imply how obvious it is that zito is scum and how bad i am for being on MS for a billion years and not immediately seeing that the things zito did were scummy for *reasons* (and imo he still didn't really say why they're MORE likely to be coming from scum than town, just why they make sense for scum to do, but that's not really relevant to his alignment) is really unnatural.

[Gammagooey]

like PV going back after zito said he was scumreading him and forming a scumread on him right afterwards is a little gross but I could see coming from either alignment. The added on pushing of how clear it was when he was voting with zito just a bit before feels manipulative and like he's trying to push what he's saying onto the game instead of actually try to convince people.

[Gammagooey]

wait wait holy shit is this actually exactly the thing that I got him lynched for in harry potter mafia

i was scum there with him to be fair so you can argue that I was negatively reading into his play for whatever he was doing even if it was a null-tell but seriously this feels astoundingly gross, one sec

[Gammagooey]

it's locked so the quotes are a bit funky but here, starting with a piece of viewtopic.php?p=5893370#p5893370:

-what was your read on sns when you voted him
-what is your current read on LML
-and why for both

2 reasons for sns vote. One was the lurking. Sure, more often then not it catches town. But, combine with the posting elsewhere, it's a big scum indicator.
Lee showed up and commenced to play. He claimed and was posting coherently, so he's obviously not lurking, so no reason to keep voting him.

My current read on Lee is town.

Don't like Pere's answer to why he unvoted LML when I would really think he's smart enough to a)realize that I want him to answer to get a read on his alignment and wanted what his read was at the time I actually asked it and I don't like the stupid last sentence that technically answers the question while trying to imply that it was dumb to ask it in the first place
and b)that if a player not posting while posting in other games is actually a scum indicator then it doesn't make sense to unvote someone because their replacement stopped doing it, ESPECIALLY when he didn't vote anyone else while unvoting LML.

I really think Pere is the best lynch today.

[Gammagooey]

i might dig up some more when i get back, gotta leave to go play board games

also sorry for consecu-posting a bit but seriously pere's posts feel real real gross and I think this is the most solid thing to go on in the whole game atm

[Vifam]

I like your argument

[Vifam]

Mostly cuz you provided another game

[Boonskiies]

prodge. I'll catch up tonight.

[Papa Zito]

I'm not gonna be able to read up until tomorrow, sorry guys. Weekends are always tough for me.

[Gammagooey]

Two more minor things about Harry Potter mafia mentioned above about Pere

-The kind of manipulative pushing/implication thing quoted was actually pretty minor in terms of what got him lynched compared to him just not putting any effort into scumhunting
-Desp apparently had a lot of games played with Pere before that (I think I've had a decent amount too at this point but I think all but maybe 1 were seeing him as scum) and had him as a scumread but wound up tunneling on town that day until Pere got run up and self-hammered.

Desp do you have an opinion on Pere here?

[Desperado]

id vote him no problem

[Vaxkiller]

It was either he was shot by other scum or it was a vig shot

Can't be a vig shot, unless we have a multi-shot vig that is staying quiet (seems unlikely, would most likely have to be another 5 star)

[Cabd]

Votecount 2-2

GuyInFreezer (1): Dunnstral
PeregrineV (1): Gammagooey
Not Chara (3): Desperado, Fro99er, Vifam




With 12 players alive, it will take 7 votes to lynch/no lynch.
Not Voting (7): Not Chara, Papa Zito, PeregrineV, Aj The Epic, Boonskiies, GuyInFreezer, Vaxkiller

Deadline for Day Two is: (expired on 2017-03-04 16:48:05)

[PeregrineV]

Monday post. Here but back later.

[Aj The Epic]

Then I decided he fake dumbslipped and was scum with NC

Can you walk me through your suspicions of Superhans early on D1? Like, how suspicious were you and what justified your vote elsewhere when you clearly showed suspicion of him? Also, what post changed your mind?

[PeregrineV]

I think his demeanor change to suddenly trying to imply how obvious it is that zito is scum and how bad i am for being on MS for a billion years and not immediately seeing that the things zito did were scummy for *reasons* (and imo he still didn't really say why they're MORE likely to be coming from scum than town, just why they make sense for scum to do, but that's not really relevant to his alignment) is really unnatural.

Yeah, it's weird.