A Mid-Scummer Night's Dream - D.S. al Fine

[TheWayItEnds]

like lynch her if you want but fuck if the conversation about what our claimed hider should have done last night wasnt possibly the stupidest thing ive ever read.

[TheWayItEnds]

ceph whos scum other than maria?

[Cephrir]

as i said my best guess is LLD. if that's wrong i'm looking at dreal/serra

[TheWayItEnds]

are you scumreading maria more or are you just more interested in the extra night action if lld turns out to be town?

[MariaR]

I don't know why ceph sr's me. Like I know he does but I have no idea for reasons why.

[mhsmith0]

The Smith hide makes no sense. The fact no one's question it also makes no sense.

i agree with this and consider him a prime candidate for her partner.

This reads like you think that the hide claim itself makes me likelier her scum buddy which seems... strange? Like, is there something that you feel connects us as buddies in terms of actual day play, or do you really think that the antispew claim of a wolf going down (if LLD is scum, she'd have to think that her lynch today is reasonably likely) is something that should be read into at all?

I'll try to have actual stuff to say tonight (who knows, maybe we can make the pie not lose 20 pieces this time ) but that struck me as odd on quick skim, and I'd really like some level of thought on that.

[Cephrir]

are you scumreading maria more or are you just more interested in the extra night action if lld turns out to be town?

the second one

[Cephrir]

The Smith hide makes no sense. The fact no one's question it also makes no sense.

i agree with this and consider him a prime candidate for her partner.

This reads like you think that the hide claim itself makes me likelier her scum buddy which seems... strange? Like, is there something that you feel connects us as buddies in terms of actual day play, or do you really think that the antispew claim of a wolf going down (if LLD is scum, she'd have to think that her lynch today is reasonably likely) is something that should be read into at all?

I'll try to have actual stuff to say tonight (who knows, maybe we can make the pie not lose 20 pieces this time ) but that struck me as odd on quick skim, and I'd really like some level of thought on that.

i merely don't have the powerful townread on you that everyone else has, so if you stopped being clear i'd have to take a good hard look at that

[Cephrir]

though i do also find it a bit suspicious how little sense that target makes.

[Cephrir]

I don't know why ceph sr's me. Like I know he does but I have no idea for reasons why.

literally go to the first page of my iso and ctrl-f yourself

[TheWayItEnds]

are you scumreading maria more or are you just more interested in the extra night action if lld turns out to be town?

the second one

mmk

[mhsmith0]

btw, for shits and giggles...

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=72889&user_select%5B%5D=30284

was maria/dunn hydra in the large theme that just ended where they were scum. While idk who made which posts, that was kind of blatantly not how maria's been posting here, and I guess I just tend to just not really bleieve that it's super likely that she'd in that game be in trouble in a scum team going down (3 man team, her hydra was 2nd scum death, and that happened with a LOT of bodies left in the game) and just generally be kind of blah about it, but that at the same time she'd be scum here and just be completely fucking miserable. Like, I just really don't see it. At all. If it's lolsmith then so be it, but that just feels so completely and utterly different from her scum game (and drealz noted that she was similar to this game in some other recently completed town game, and she as town has an annoying tendency to just give up [open 646, new year's masquerade; 2/2 times I played with her and she was town she white flagged it at some point] )... that it just feels like she's tonw here. Also her early d3 post was her just blatantly being OFFENDED at what I was saying at her, which seems like a somewhat difficult place to get to naturally as scum, and somewhat difficult to want to fake, while as town who thinks I'm just being an asshole or something, it basically makes sense.

And that's more of a reason for her being town than I think anyone has offered all game long for her being scum, so I'll just go ahead and stick to that read.

[Cephrir]

i think i've played enough mafia that i can no longer ever believe in anything except inevitable town losses.

[hebichan]

btw, for shits and giggles...

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=72889&user_select%5B%5D=30284

was maria/dunn hydra in the large theme that just ended where they were scum. While idk who made which posts, that was kind of blatantly not how maria's been posting here, and I guess I just tend to just not really bleieve that it's super likely that she'd in that game be in trouble in a scum team going down (3 man team, her hydra was 2nd scum death, and that happened with a LOT of bodies left in the game) and just generally be kind of blah about it, but that at the same time she'd be scum here and just be completely fucking miserable. Like, I just really don't see it. At all. If it's lolsmith then so be it, but that just feels so completely and utterly different from her scum game (and drealz noted that she was similar to this game in some other recently completed town game, and she as town has an annoying tendency to just give up [open 646, new year's masquerade; 2/2 times I played with her and she was town she white flagged it at some point] )... that it just feels like she's tonw here. Also her early d3 post was her just blatantly being OFFENDED at what I was saying at her, which seems like a somewhat difficult place to get to naturally as scum, and somewhat difficult to want to fake, while as town who thinks I'm just being an asshole or something, it basically makes sense.

And that's more of a reason for her being town than I think anyone has offered all game long for her being scum, so I'll just go ahead and stick to that read.

That's actually been my position, actually having been in the game. I couldn't say so early on while the game was ongoing obviously.

Haven't played with Ceph in awhile but he's been more aggressive than I remember him as town.

[Cephrir]

i get more aggressive than this.

i have a fluctuating game-persona.

[hebichan]

Fair enough, I suppose.

Can you address the maria thing though?

[Cephrir]

3887 is my response to it; in essence, "fuck, maybe you're right"

[hebichan]

In light of that, and the fact that LLD will resolve itself tonight, where do you think we should lynch, since those have been your biggest scum reads.

[Cephrir]

my answer to that is to default to dreal but that's not a very satisfying answer and last time I did that it didn't turn out so great.

I don't have a lot of conviction right now. Someone needs to show me the light.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Am I not voting Dreal right now?

I can't remember.

Vote: Dreal

[serrapaladin]

VOTE: twie

Would also be pretty happy to no-lynch.

I do think setup stuff is gonna sort LLD one way or another.

[Cephrir]

no lynch is bad. we need that number for LLD potentially dying, and we also supposedly have two clears.

[Cephrir]

are we really, really sure imperium wasn't scum?

[Cephrir]

this isn't related to 3895 i was already thinking it

tammy had one great wall but she's not completely incapable of faketowning, and she didn't post the rest of the time

[Cephrir]

Here is a recent Syryana town game.

Here's a recent game where he replaces into a scum slot.

Maybe it's because the latter is a newbie game, but his attitude is night and day

I feel that any twie votes at this stage really should be addressing this.

VOTE: Dreal