Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Almost50]

and Almost i'll continue to be paranoid about despite this looking like town Almost.

I'd say if you didn't you are either an investigative or Scum!

[Nero Cain]

guys guys guys. A 3rd scum team is stupid. An SK is FAR FAR FAR FAR more likely.

[Nero Cain]

Shaz, why is Koki scum?

(pls no one answer this besides Shaz)

[Gamma Emerald]

Why are we bringing up SKs as the only option when we haven't disproven the possibility of a vig?

[Venmar]

Votecount 2.11

[0] Nero Cain:

[2]

Kiana Kaslana:

ActionDan, Klazam

[0] brassherald:

[0] Bujaber:

[1]

Kokichi Oma:

Shaziro

[0] Chara:

[5]

Gamma Emerald:

Titus, Kokichi Oma, pidgey, Ranmaru, Kiana Kaslana

[3]

Klazam:

Joey_, Gamma Emerald, Almost50

[0] Titus:

[0] Shaziro:

[3]

ActionDan:

marshy, Brassherald, Chara

[0] Joey_:

[0] pidgey:

[0] jodaxq:

[0] almost50:

[0] marshy:

[3]

ranmaru:

Jodaxq, BuJaber, Nero Cain

Not Voting

• N/A

Deadline

• In (expired on 2018-03-27 09:00:00)
  
• Tuesday, March 27th @9:00am PST

Mod Notes:

• With 17 alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch.
  
• Chara is V/LA

[Shaziro]

Good. Now you have a full day to think of a believable claim and reason as to why you used a watcher shot on the clear yesterday and not tonight.

You're poisoning the well against him now. Gross.

Here's a direct quote which I can be bothered to get because it's recent. Beyond that, it's a mix of the seemingly purposeful spearing of attempts to get information, the constant insistence that they be World Congress leader, the attempts to powerlynch Gamma despite Gamma (at least to me) being obviously town, and their smug attitude towards votes on them which smacks of scum trying to convince town that voting them won't do anything so don't bother.

TL;DR they've been scummy as shit all game both in action and in my gutread on them, I'd be happy to see them flip.

[Kokichi Oma]

Is gamma's last red he cannot just claim to have a doc shot and lie/not use it on the IC, it would makes him 100% lynched tomorrow thus against a last-red wincon. At the same time, if gamma's orange there's a lot of gains to get another night

You believe his commute shot claim?

You don't? Might wanna put some justification on that.

I'd unvote if I did.

[Kokichi Oma]

Good. Now you have a full day to think of a believable claim and reason as to why you used a watcher shot on the clear yesterday and not tonight.

You're poisoning the well against him now. Gross.

Here's a direct quote which I can be bothered to get because it's recent. Beyond that, it's a mix of the seemingly purposeful spearing of attempts to get information, the constant insistence that they be World Congress leader, the attempts to powerlynch Gamma despite Gamma (at least to me) being obviously town, and their smug attitude towards votes on them which smacks of scum trying to convince town that voting them won't do anything so don't bother.

TL;DR they've been scummy as shit all game both in action and in my gutread on them, I'd be happy to see them flip.

Wow pushing on scum makes me scum. Who knew

[Gamma Emerald]

Is gamma's last red he cannot just claim to have a doc shot and lie/not use it on the IC, it would makes him 100% lynched tomorrow thus against a last-red wincon. At the same time, if gamma's orange there's a lot of gains to get another night

You believe his commute shot claim?

You don't? Might wanna put some justification on that.

I'd unvote if I did.

I don't care if you TR me, you're probably scum anyway. I just want to hear what makes you doubt my commuter shot being real.

[Kokichi Oma]

Seems unlikely to be with the other shots.

[Joey_]

Is gamma's last red he cannot just claim to have a doc shot and lie/not use it on the IC, it would makes him 100% lynched tomorrow thus against a last-red wincon. At the same time, if gamma's orange there's a lot of gains to get another night

You believe his commute shot claim?

i dont know man, i read him individually as town and im not sure it would be impossible to have a joat with a 1 shot commute, im bad at setup spec so i prefer not to read player for it

[Joey_]

Klazoum saying that gamma is town but he isnt even trying to build a CW to his hard townread conftown gamma

I was trying, and im completely ignored because you idiots want to make conftown gamma fullclaim. Me going fuck you go ahead lynch him was because you voted him "is that a challenge." im just done with this game.

lmao

[Joey_]

My spider sense tell me to lynch gamma for the sake of it, soft guilty + info etc, but my other spider sense tell me if hes town then he goes with the IC and its a terrible error to not wait when 3 scum flipd

[Joey_]

I think lynching gamma is the correct conservative play that is probably resulting in a scum flip 8 out of 10 times here, the loss if wrong tho is pretty high

[Kokichi Oma]

Yeah gamma best lynch.

[Gamma Emerald]

Perusing two recently completed games I don't think marshy is scum anymore because in those games he fell victim to RWSTFO, but here he has been consistently active pretty much.

[Jodaxq]

What's wrong with the Ranmaru lynch?

[Jodaxq]

I do not want to lynch Gamma today

[Jodaxq]

I could go ActionDan if someone provides a reason other than his activity level

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Ranmaru
Deadline's rather close and I'd like to not end up the only viable wagon at deadline

[Nero Cain]

Why are we bringing up SKs

as the only option

when we haven't disproven the possibility of a vig?

this is pretty manipulative and misreppy. There's this whole idea of there being a 3rd scum faction and until a 3rd team flips there's no need to speculate there is one. I'm saying that an SK id far more plausible than a 3rd team.

[Nero Cain]

Good. Now you have a full day to think of a believable claim and reason as to why you used a watcher shot on the clear yesterday and not tonight.

You're poisoning the well against him now. Gross.

Here's a direct quote which I can be bothered to get because it's recent. Beyond that, it's a mix of the seemingly purposeful spearing of attempts to get information, the constant insistence that they be World Congress leader, the attempts to powerlynch Gamma despite Gamma (at least to me) being obviously town, and their smug attitude towards votes on them which smacks of scum trying to convince town that voting them won't do anything so don't bother.

TL;DR they've been scummy as shit all game both in action and in my gutread on them, I'd be happy to see them flip.

There are lots of ppl trying to powerlynch Gamma. Fuck Joey rolefished him and has been kinda fence sitting on him for awhile. Isn't this the same thing you were calling me scum for? Project much? Town tunnel town all the time and Koki tunneling town is NAI. I'd prob be more suprised if Koki was tunneling scum for a change. There are town that are smug while getting votes. This case is crap and I feel like 3168 makes YOU look scummy. Its also kinda a vote sideline b/c the chances Koki gets flipped over Gamma, Ran, Kiana, AD, Klazam seem slim to none.

[BuJaber]

I think lynching gamma is the correct conservative play that is probably resulting in a scum flip 8 out of 10 times here, the loss if wrong tho is pretty high

Even if this is true (the 80% scum flip) it doesn't justify a lynch now. The expected value of 20% lynching a JOAT is worse than the value gained of 80% lynching scum when we have this many players still alive.
Y'all are acting as if not lynching gamma now = locktowning him. Keep him alive and test his claim. He is either killed by scum or he proves his role or he gets lynched later.

Patience shaz. If koki is scum he will be lynched this game. Just wait until nobody can refute it.

Ran/Dan/Klazam they even sort of rhyme. Lynch here come on.

[Gamma Emerald]

Why are we bringing up SKs

as the only option

when we haven't disproven the possibility of a vig?

this is pretty manipulative and misreppy. There's this whole idea of there being a 3rd scum faction and until a 3rd team flips there's no need to speculate there is one. I'm saying that an SK id far more plausible than a 3rd team.

Well guess what? No one was really arguing 3 teams either at that point.

[BuJaber]

I think lynching gamma is the correct conservative play that is probably resulting in a scum flip 8 out of 10 times here, the loss if wrong tho is pretty high

Even if this is true (the 80% scum flip) it doesn't justify a lynch now. The expected value of 20% lynching a JOAT is worse than the value gained of 80% lynching scum when we have this many players still alive.
Y'all are acting as if not lynching gamma now = locktowning him. Keep him alive and test his claim. He is either killed by scum or he proves his role or he gets lynched later.

Patience shaz. If koki is scum he will be lynched this game. Just wait until nobody can refute it.

Ran/Dan/Klazam they even sort of rhyme. Lynch here come on.

I explained it poorly. The negative EV of lynching JOAT is far greater than the positive EV of lynching scum here.