Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Kaito Momota]

Kaito's still scum, by the way. i just think Lady Angel is also scum. Maki's another candidate for me, but i really want to see her reply to Wisdom (namely to him not buying her Nikk vote) before anything.

Deadline’s in 4 days. I could vote Lady if the Kaito wagon doesn’t happen.

At least one scum in this bloc

[Alchemist21]

VOTE: Lady Angel

[Kaito Momota]

I'm not ok with a Lady Angel wagon

We can do better than a lurker

They're more likely town than not because I don't think they would fake claim miller as scum

[Kaito Momota]

Can we move off of Maki onto one of these two? Wisdom? Pink Ball? Nikk?

[Kaito Momota]

we played after my ban together yet you mention "before my ban" and you don't say anything about my meta - you're just applying a generally standard meta on my playstyle here cause that fits your shading narrative better.

VOTE: Creature

We played a lot of games together on mu all after my ban. I refuse to believe you're posting here is based on a natural thought process cause it doesn't fit.

pedit: what is missing and why you just changed your story after I voted you and talked about you?

what about me begging for townread as town is new for you?

The reason I'm scumreading you has nothing to do with your mental state.

You're previous posts were like how you can see scum me begging for being townread now that I revealed your shading you're changing that to a full scumread ay?

You claimed you're scum reading me for something that is clearly a part of my personality and everyone who knows me knows that and you should have known that which means its related to my personal state.

I dunno whether you would beg to be townread as town too or not, but I find it worth pushing because it's generally scummy.

This is absolutely

horrendous bullshit

and why you're scum. Plus you post it like it was actually what you were considering all along after me mentioning why it makes you scum.

Why would creature scum be pushing you instead of anyone else?

[Wisdom]

Deadline’s in 4 days. I could vote Lady if the Kaito wagon doesn’t happen.

or you could vote maki

[Kaito Momota]

Lady Angel wagon is lazy at best and scum driven at worst, and anti-town fits in somewhere in between

[Nikk]

Lady Angel wagon is lazy at best and scum driven at worst, and anti-town fits in somewhere in between

I would agree with this. Chara and Sheeps votes in particular set of alarm bells.

[Creature]

I need a game to play.

[Pink Ball]

Can we move off of Maki onto one of these two? Wisdom? Pink Ball? Nikk?

I don't get this post, are you talking to me or are you telling people to vote me? If it is the first one, which "these two" are you talking, Chara and Alch? 'Cause that's a no for me dawg.

[Frozen Angel]

I know I promised to post yeasterday but I was occupied here doing stuff since its last day I'm here

I'm flying to paris rn. I'll post tomorrow first thing in the morning

can someone tell me what is the deadline for the game?

[Elsa Jay]

We got less then 4 days left, Frozen.

[Chara]

Lady Angel wagon is lazy at best and scum driven at worst, and anti-town fits in somewhere in between

I would agree with this. Chara and Sheeps votes in particular set of alarm bells.

this "scum never lurk" or "lurkers are always null" meta sucks, and leaves towns with multiple unreadable/useless slots in the endgame.
why's she town?
i'm scumreading her posting. the only good argument i've seen for her town is the miller claim, and she could have been told to do that.

i can compromise on Maki, but it's more of a lack of townread there than a scumread.

[Chara]

Can we move off of Maki onto one of these two? Wisdom? Pink Ball? Nikk?

what happened to your Wisdom scumread?

[Chara]

i'd actually forgotten that Kaito was the one who said he was townreading the miller claim. that's on me, sorry.

[Chara]

this game needs more frequent vote counts.

let's pretend i'm wrong on Kaito. why are scum sleeping on that mislynch? are they playing a backseat game where they wait for town to mislynch town? it's too early to really say. and it's always possible in a game like this that we just have lurker scum who simply aren't affecting the game much at all, so i'm not going to rely on that. that's for later when the game comes closer to the wire.

i've considered scum Alch, but if he's scum he's really committed to hiding in my pocket, and he also somehow predicted all of the miller claims. (his was second.)
i'm not willing to pursue scum Alch right now.

i have some reasoning for Kaito town i've been holding back to avoid weakening my own case/push.

the only reason to think of LA town is her miller claim, as Kaito pointed out. it was 4th, at that point i don't think it's outside the realm of being told to claim that/thinking it safe.

[Chara]

I need a game to play.

there's a game right here. who's scum?

[Chara]

on Maki scum: Kaito, why are you townreading her? please, no bullshit, i'm really sick of it. if you don't want her lynched you need to actually say why she isn't scum and why she's a bad lynch. this isn't a leading question, and it wasn't one when i asked it a damned week ago. defend your townread.

[Maki Harukawa]

Can we have a VC thanks mod

[davesaz]

Pretend I'm a complete newb who thinks Maki is the towniest of the town.
Convince me I'm wrong, with actual explanations.
What I remember being mentioned is the "maybe Mafia know there are a lot of millers" thing, without much of an explanation of why only scum might think that.

[Chara]

my read has nothing to do with that. i have a few things that have me sideeyeing Maki, but i'm waiting for her catchup first.

if you truly think she is incredibly towny (i don't think you are, though) that's cause for at least one raised eyebrow from me.
if Maki isn't caught up soon i'll just talk about the read.

[Alchemist21]

Someone said that, and Nikk just wanted a flip for info. Wisdom and Kaito both naked voted.

So that wagon appeared for a weak reason and I think scum hopped onto it. It’s what prompted me to loom at Kaito’s ISO and see the thing with Chara.

P-edit: This was a response to Dave’s post.

[davesaz]

if you truly think she is incredibly towny (i don't think you are, though) that's cause for at least one raised eyebrow from me.

The post is borrowing from a technique I saw recently in a science fair judging guide, on how to get the entrant to explain their project.
A couple variants are "explain it to me like I'm 5" or "like I'm your grandfather".
So yeah, the "incredibly towny" thing is a rhetorical device that doesn't necessarily match my actual read.

Spoiler: btw

That grandfather example isn't far off for

some

scummers, the age difference is big enough lol

[Wisdom]

my explanation is that it looks like scum maki

[Nikk]

Lady Angel wagon is lazy at best and scum driven at worst, and anti-town fits in somewhere in between

I would agree with this. Chara and Sheeps votes in particular set of alarm bells.

this "scum never lurk" or "lurkers are always null" meta sucks, and leaves towns with multiple unreadable/useless slots in the endgame.
why's she town?
i'm scumreading her posting. the only good argument i've seen for her town is the miller claim, and she could have been told to do that.

i can compromise on Maki, but it's more of a lack of townread there than a scumread.

What are you talking about? All I stated was your vote set off alarm bells. What is this meta you are attributing to me here?