My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Mafia (Game Over)

[Elsa Jay]

VOTE: Bins

Even if your a PR I'm saling out whatever the heck you do tonight Bins. So if your going to kill me atleast do it yourself so I can see you do it.

This vote is a protest vote in heart but it deserves more attention later on.

[Papa Zito]

He wants to sort people in 445 legit asks no questions on the matter at hand at any player. When I press him on it he says he sorted reck already. When he didn't even ask reck something. Reck was the one who replied to him and Implo acted like he did it

In 445 he states he wants to sort you, Reck and T-Bone. All three were low presence/low content at that point and thus all are excellent targets for sorting. I have no issue with the post itself. A nice followup I guess you missed was 510 in which he questions Bins on her townreads. It's not hard to presume that was to help him inform his own.

* In 474 he lists Reck as a townread. While it's true implosion himself didn't ask any questions of Reck, Reck posted quite a few times between 445 and 474 (starting at 455). It's not hard to presume that implosion gained a read from those posts.
* implosion engages with you starting in post 551. He later votes you, which points to him having sorted your slot.
* implosion engages with T-Bone starting in 592. He states T-Bone is town in 1554 (and elsewhere), so it's safe to say he's sorted this slot as well.

All in all, he seems to have followed up with what he set out to do so I'm struggling to see the issue here.

I'll have to look more into other points later.

[Papa Zito]

what in the world

[T-Bone]

I wish you had helped me Maria, but ce la vie. I don't know how you could look at the people with you on the implosion wagon and feel like you were in a good spot if you are town.

[Baezu]

Tbone, 20 hours left please hammer

[Elsa Jay]

Stop trying to make people hammer before everyone says shit. I hate it Any time I'm town people do this thing.

[Papa Zito]

Read 551 and 552 to see him just dismissing points

In post 551 he doesn't dismiss anything. This is one of the posts I nodded along with. For example:

Like sure I didn't explain them but it's kind of one-dimensional to jump from "implosion isn't explaining his townreads 24 hours after the game started" to "implosion is making up his reads".

I completely agree with this. I feel like you put a rather unfair expectation on him then declared him unfit to live for not reaching your unfair standards. There's no chapter in the Big Book of Mafia that states you have to explain a townread or face immediate death.

In post 552 he asks you two questions. How in the world is that dismissing something?

---

646 is him putting Elsa back in his poe basically/coming up for a reason to put elsa as scummy

uh

here's 646

like take the elsa wagon; i think he's probably town but that's a VERY weak probably and i don't think the wagon on him was bad as a wagon, per se. you're just stripping any potential nuance and saying "implosion called him town, logically he must then analyze the wagon to find scum on it" which isn't even necessarily a good idea in the first place

He clearly expresses a weak townread on Elsa here. There's no indication that he's putting Elsa in a PoE pool.


Ok I have to get to work so further analysis of that post will have to wait until I get home.

[MariaR]

I doubt we could get a zor wagon in 20 hours but *shrug* I'd try it.
(I'll respond to zito in an hour)

[Bins]

Even if your a PR I'm saling out whatever the heck you do tonight Bins.

waste of a shot

i genuinely believe you think what you do, i just think youre wrong

[Bins]

hey if maria flips scum, uh, maybe reconsider that to the people on the implo wagon

[MariaR]

Hey bins will you stop tring Implo when I flip town?

[Bins]

I'll probably reevaluate most of my reads yeah

[T-Bone]

Shush Gale, it's not even bed time yet.

[T-Bone]

I doubt we could get a zor wagon in 20 hours but *shrug* I'd try it.
(I'll respond to zito in an hour)

I'd rather do this than hammer you, so let's go. No time like the present.

[Baezu]

Ok, get on zor and I’ll join

[T-Bone]

...

[MariaR]

VOTE: Zor
yolo

[MariaR]

He wants to sort people in 445 legit asks no questions on the matter at hand at any player. When I press him on it he says he sorted reck already. When he didn't even ask reck something. Reck was the one who replied to him and Implo acted like he did it

In 445 he states he wants to sort you, Reck and T-Bone. All three were low presence/low content at that point and thus all are excellent targets for sorting. I have no issue with the post itself. A nice followup I guess you missed was 510 in which he questions Bins on her townreads. It's not hard to presume that was to help him inform his own.

* In 474 he lists Reck as a townread. While it's true implosion himself didn't ask any questions of Reck, Reck posted quite a few times between 445 and 474 (starting at 455). It's not hard to presume that implosion gained a read from those posts.
* implosion engages with you starting in post 551. He later votes you, which points to him having sorted your slot.
* implosion engages with T-Bone starting in 592. He states T-Bone is town in 1554 (and elsewhere), so it's safe to say he's sorted this slot as well.

All in all, he seems to have followed up with what he set out to do so I'm struggling to see the issue here.

I'll have to look more into other points later.

This would be fine if Implo acted like that. But the way he went about it was like he sorted them himself if he said he got the read from other people? Sure fine that's all dandy but he's acting like he did it himself with his own posting (at least that's how I took it)

Read 551 and 552 to see him just dismissing points

In post 551 he doesn't dismiss anything. This is one of the posts I nodded along with. For example:

Like sure I didn't explain them but it's kind of one-dimensional to jump from "implosion isn't explaining his townreads 24 hours after the game started" to "implosion is making up his reads".

I completely agree with this. I feel like you put a rather unfair expectation on him then declared him unfit to live for not reaching your unfair standards. There's no chapter in the Big Book of Mafia that states you have to explain a townread or face immediate death.

In post 552 he asks you two questions. How in the world is that dismissing something?

---

646 is him putting Elsa back in his poe basically/coming up for a reason to put elsa as scummy

uh

here's 646

like take the elsa wagon; i think he's probably town but that's a VERY weak probably and i don't think the wagon on him was bad as a wagon, per se. you're just stripping any potential nuance and saying "implosion called him town, logically he must then analyze the wagon to find scum on it" which isn't even necessarily a good idea in the first place

He clearly expresses a weak townread on Elsa here. There's no indication that he's putting Elsa in a PoE pool.


Ok I have to get to work so further analysis of that post will have to wait until I get home.

Read later on in the iso. He takes Elsa right out of town and into his poe. The reason he put weak townread in the first place was to set up for said poe pool. Read the tone of 551 and 552. He's trying to win an argument not sort that's how he's been all game with this fake ass confidence dismissive bs

[xRECKONERx]

Well I have a reason that's freaking obvious and I recognize Maria is a better choice to have then me so we should lynch Implosion instead. If nothing elsa we only lose a VT.

Please for the love of friendship

get off my Backup Tracker.

I'm only 2-Shot anyway but she specified "Any Tracker" so she's legit.

Any hammer after this is scum.

how do you know who the backup tracker is?

(also im tryin to check in but it's the apocalypse in NC right now with like fifty tornadoes and shit so like...no promises)

[xRECKONERx]

Well I have a reason that's freaking obvious and I recognize Maria is a better choice to have then me so we should lynch Implosion instead. If nothing elsa we only lose a VT.

Please for the love of friendship

get off my Backup Tracker.

I'm only 2-Shot anyway but she specified "Any Tracker" so she's legit.

Any hammer after this is scum.

weait i thought you claimed doctor

[Baezu]

Did she? Where?

[Baezu]

He, excuse me

[MariaR]

I'm trying a last-ditch effort zor wagon Reck wanna try it?

[xRECKONERx]

wait no that was baezu that claimed doctor

sorry

how does a primary tracker know their backup? i've never seen that before

[Baezu]

Back up tracker claimed- it’s maria