Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Croag]

who was it that claimed caffeinated from the start

[Croag]

the above post confirms again PP and DOL are not scum together

[gobbledygook]

I will repeat:

Chandra claims to have acted (most likely lying)
Kagami claims to have acted
PP claims to have acted
JJD claims to have acted
Vecna claims to be already caffeinated from the start
Marquis was hinted (by Vecna) to have acted
"unknown Vig" may or may nor have acted

That's SEVEN bloody caffeinated slots. The Mod says only 4.

Well, actually, this confirms JJD or PP as 100% scum.

@Turkey - what do you have to say about that?

Pp, JJD both claimed to have acted N1. The three reflexive players are already caffeinated.

We only have 4 alive players, meaning one of PP or JJD is scum. This is a direct 1v1.

I don’t think that contradicts the 4 people alive. The unknown vig is Marquis so that’s 6. Chandra and Kagami are dead so that’s 4.

Why are your reads so mercurial?

[Day One Wagon]

That was from D2, when Kagami and Chandra were alive. But if we take PP and JJD out of equation, we get 4 caffeinations. PP and Croag replacing Kagami and Chandra makes 4 again. Assuming that Chandra didn't acted is wrong. Even if she knew her sanity, she had to get caffeinated for PoE reasons anyway

[gobbledygook]

Also has it actually been claimed the 3 reflexive people are caffeinated already?

[Day One Wagon]

Also has it actually been claimed the 3 reflexive people are caffeinated already?

Vecna claimed something about being caffeinated from the start, but with how many bs people said in this game already, who knows if that's true or not

[gobbledygook]

Also has it actually been claimed the 3 reflexive people are caffeinated already?

Vecna claimed something about being caffeinated from the start, but with how many bs people said in this game already, who knows if that's true or not

I think that is pretty clearly a lie given how beginning of game announcement.

[gobbledygook]

Bingle, do you know for a fact that there are 3 vigilantes in this game?

[chennisden]

UNVOTE:

Bleh. Lemme think on this bc I think fl might be wrong here

[Vecna]

Like straight up. People just play at a surface level their entire lives and can’t see past :shrug:

seriously, enough of this bullshit.

this playerlist is good enough to catch way better scumplayers than you.

If youre town, show it by playstyle, not "because youd be so omega-awesome youd never get in this position" as scum.

[Vecna]

]VOTE: bingle
lets fucking kick this guys ass

pedit: hmm i think ceph is playing kond of dofferent so far tbh

Oh look, an early comment on ceph’s play. Interesting.

this though

Hmmm

[Vecna]

Maybe he has a bad memory.

I don’t remember where i played with him

Interesting! I think this makes FL town? (my LAW supersedes anyone else's reads)

Hmm. I may have gotten pocketed subconsciously pretty early.

Which checks out because I’m 3 for 3 with catching scumA50.

I also feel JJD set me up tonlook bad even before I got a chance to scumread him.

I also feel gorkington was too town to be town. the slot was fucking flawless. chenn though....made me doubt that read.

Also, too town to be town should be a thing.

[Vecna]

He was actively buttering up and appealing to me because he knew I was a Vig and didn’t want to get shot, but he knew by town reading me directly and too hard, I’d get suspicious, so if you look back at our previous back and forth, he also had an off trajectory

I said OK, dammit! Let someone else speak

(And now you know why FL wasn't playing the game YET, because once he got the mic he assumes its his own property for good)

Why the fuck would we lynch in a 2 vig 1v1? One of them is lying, and the other one shoots them tonight. 90% it's PP lying, but if it isn't does it really matter?

That's not how I see it.

What I see is FL is 100% TOWN here (and NOT lying about his role.. this has to do with how survivalistic FL is as scum).

PP is very likely caught scum, but not 100%. There's a slight chance of mod-fuckery here still.

But I do believe in lynching PP anyway now because I support gun control. (Yes, I do. ONLY JUDGES should have access to any kind of lethal weapon).

Yeah and I'm challenging the read. It's a read that doesn't take into account that FL is good at scum and just generally projects confidence

This is ofrhz knowing PP (the fake one ) is flipping town and is lining up FL for a mislynch.

i think i want this
VOTE: bingle

I can get behind that for now

VOTE: Bingle

Ugggh.

Yeah, It’s JJD-Chennis.

this is bad though.

scum talking to scum, to get behind it?

works against the theory imo

[Vecna]

Spoiler:

VOTE: bingle

For some reason I’m getting scum vibes here

He seems to be speaking less than town!bingle

I know that’s meta but like eh

Also, I genuinely don’t get the thing with perry

I think it’s semantics
Like I can’t remember word for word my role pm and I wouldn’t want someone to hold it against me

so can someone explain to me definitively, why, perry is scum

the way it looks to me is he is a miller (which by defn appears as scum) and said this

and apparently... that makes him scum? does this mean the miller neighbourhood DONT appear as scum? otherwise whats the issue

wait lmao im even more confused

not that i dont want it but why is what im saying clearing me

it seems ive found the secret formula

Lmaoooooo someone please explain the scum read on me right now

U bantering

i want to trust in my hood

i dont think any of them are maf

can someone double confirm to me who has claimed what hood and who they are with please

sorry to be a pain

im looking at popsofctown today

Don’t.

Do it tomorrow.

Pops is confirmable.

why tomorrow? why not today?

You know what?

Why not just lynch Croag? I feel like it’s going to be that big of an issue, why the hell not just lynch Croag today? Does anybody town read the slot? Like, I am not scum reading them by any means, but if croag’s town, they’re gonna be mislynched eventually anyways. Let’s just vote them.

VOTE: Croag

scummiest post ive ever read

>not scum reading them
>lets just lynch them anyway

lmao

Oh and im 50% sure chenn is scum

I'm not sure how many scum there are though?

popping in here, quickly browing the last 3-4 pages, throwing out some unreadable responses......not exactly allowing us to sort you either.

Youre not playing the game. You dont have any reads. You dont make any statements that allow us to read you.

Either its a strategy, or you should just not be playing (because youre not).

How do you propose we deal with your slot croag?

i have read the entire thread & just now read all pages from when i last was here.

I have already given my reads.

The entirety of my hood is town. That is my read and that is something I have already posted in here. Just because everyone else was saying the same thing, apparently, does not make it any less valid that it is coming from me.

I have voted for pops. That is one of my reads for a scum slot.

If you want other reads from me, I think DOL and JJD are scum.

Theres some reads, enjoy.

considering no one is helping me out

ive just read every post where hood was mentioned

can someone confirm to me if i have this right


{
Vecna
Marquis
Bingle
}

{
Croag
Penguin
Chandra
Kagami
}

{
Pops
FL
Perry - vig? town and dead
}

{
JJD
OFRHZ
DOL
Chenn
}

I haven't been able to sort Pine, Fish or Kuribo. I'm not sure what
Teenage Troublemaker
Self-Proclaimed Anarchist
Laboratory Technician
means and what hood that implies they are in

why is there 17 players? was there one hood with 5 in?

Kuribo, Fish and Pine were apparently together in a hood.

For all we know, Kuribo was actually a suicide bomber and just exploded on Fish.

Heck, I actually like that idea, it fits somewhat with self-proclaimed anarchist flavour, and at least that would somehow explain why he suddenly went and claimed the way he did (after making up his mind he was 100% gonna explode on Fish).

I probably couldnt be further from the truth, but I wouldve liked that to actually have been what happened.

makes sense

fsr i just thought it was 4, 4, 4, 4, (1) because mine is a 4

You know, a lot of these just scream NAI or slightly townie, but when putting them all together, I’m lock towning this slot. No more ISO necessary for Croag.

I also really liked the 50% Chen scum read they had, which actually makes me feel more comfortable about my ChennScum solve.

welcome to like, two weeks ago.

[Vecna]

Really, were going to vca scum into arbitrary piles now? Can we not waste our time on such pointless exercises?

AWESOME!!!

This means my VCA is likely pretty decent.

I dno, this is again starting to feel desperate

[gobbledygook]

So did JJD confirm he used an action the first night?

[Day One Wagon]

So did JJD confirm he used an action the first night?

he claimed target, but there's no way to confirm

[gobbledygook]

Who was his target?

[Flavor Leaf]

PP claims to act N2, not N1, I don't see problem there. He never claimed to act N1, he simply didn't denied assumption that he acted N1 and it's smart, scum wouldn't consider him as a target, if they think he already used his ability

Have you played with town A50? I'm really curious why you so hung up on fact that he isn't lying about acting N1. I've seen him flipping his claim as town in the past, so I take that as a NAI

Also I see you finally noticed that there was 0 people caffeinated at the start

This has already been discussed. It doesn’t matter.

Day 3 has 4 caffeinated.

Bingle
Vecna
Marquis
PP
JJD

Like drop Night 1 from your mind. It’s still accurate.

[Flavor Leaf]

I will repeat:

Chandra claims to have acted (most likely lying)
Kagami claims to have acted
PP claims to have acted
JJD claims to have acted
Vecna claims to be already caffeinated from the start
Marquis was hinted (by Vecna) to have acted
"unknown Vig" may or may nor have acted

That's SEVEN bloody caffeinated slots. The Mod says only 4.

Well, actually, this confirms JJD or PP as 100% scum.

@Turkey - what do you have to say about that?

Pp, JJD both claimed to have acted N1. The three reflexive players are already caffeinated.

We only have 4 alive players, meaning one of PP or JJD is scum. This is a direct 1v1.

I don’t think that contradicts the 4 people alive. The unknown vig is Marquis so that’s 6. Chandra and Kagami are dead so that’s 4.

Why are your reads so mercurial?

This is wrong.

He claimed the Vig from N2, not N1.

[Flavor Leaf]

Like straight up. People just play at a surface level their entire lives and can’t see past :shrug:

seriously, enough of this bullshit.

this playerlist is good enough to catch way better scumplayers than you.

If youre town, show it by playstyle, not "because youd be so omega-awesome youd never get in this position" as scum.

Lol, disagree.

I honestly can’t even name a current better scum player than me, so this is just surface level from you right now.

[Day One Wagon]

PP claims to act N2, not N1, I don't see problem there. He never claimed to act N1, he simply didn't denied assumption that he acted N1 and it's smart, scum wouldn't consider him as a target, if they think he already used his ability

Have you played with town A50? I'm really curious why you so hung up on fact that he isn't lying about acting N1. I've seen him flipping his claim as town in the past, so I take that as a NAI

Also I see you finally noticed that there was 0 people caffeinated at the start

This has already been discussed. It doesn’t matter.

Day 3 has 4 caffeinated.

Bingle
Vecna
Marquis
PP
JJD

Like drop Night 1 from your mind. It’s still accurate.

Where Croag? And why you so sure Bingle and Vecna are caffeinated?

[Day One Wagon]

Also, you didn't answered, why you so sure about JJD acting N1?

[Flavor Leaf]

Really, were going to vca scum into arbitrary piles now? Can we not waste our time on such pointless exercises?

AWESOME!!!

This means my VCA is likely pretty decent.

I dno, this is again starting to feel desperate

Which proves you are surface level with no accurate measurement of my scum play meaning all your comments on anything related to skill level is irrelevant because you talk whilst uneducated.

And i have a super chill demeanor with these past few pages. You’re just throwing desperate in to throw the word in, which is again, surface level of you.

[Flavor Leaf]

Also, you didn't answered, why you so sure about JJD acting N1?

Until he confirms, I’m going to go through like he has. That’s on him to discern it, not me.

Croag was said to not have acted. They’d have acted N2, I guess if they got into the.

Also I’d like to point out the immense amount of communication and analysis I’m bringing to the game.

Even if I am incorrect, it is healthy for the town. Which is another reason why Vecna is surface level.