Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[farside22]

[

Iconeum

- Friendly Neighbour - Verified Town]
[

Morning Tweet

- Claims One-shotizer] I know this power exists

Farside22

- Claims Effort Saver turned VT] day proves this I believe
—-
[

TrueSoulEnergy

- Claims Knowledgable BM is town]
[

Looker (Pigman)

- Claims Named VT]
[

Chateau Lobby

- Shielder

só any of the bottom three could be card dealer. BM was widely townread so I can’t rule out that TSE was taking a calculated gamble.
Looker seemed so burned out and sour about town yesterday I don’t see him as either redscum or wolf, though this could be faked as well as the named townie claim.
Chateau’s shielder clam is plausible but as card dealer he would be very well aware of the yellow card effects and that would have a lot of the same effect.

If you need to add to notes, just put in there that MT used there ability on Drew and he confirmed being targetted (I think N2?)

[Porkens]

Next iteration, if needed, I’ll combine the two tables into a master document and...oh shit I’m still at work somehow

[Porkens]

That’s not meant to be snarky just silly

[TemporalLich]

Due to a new site rule, the ruleset (excluding standard wincons) and votecounts have been edited to remove a certain word. Since the intent of the rule change is to disassociate said word from Mafia games, the ruleset has been edited in a way to hide the fact said word existed in the ruleset. Eliminate will be the replacement for this game.

[TemporalLich]

VC 6.1

Looker (1) - farside22 [E-3]
TrueSoulEnergy (1) - Chateau Lobby [E-3]
Porkens (1) - Looker [E-3]
Chateau Lobby (1) - Porkens [E-3]

Not voting: Morning Tweet, TrueSoulEnergy, Iconeum

With 7 alive it takes 4 to eliminate.

Day 6 will end in (expired on 2020-07-10 04:45:00) or when an elimination is reached.

[Porkens]

Oh my god we are a perfect centipede

[Morning Tweet]

[I have almost every living player one-shotized actually, i've been hard at work. Not that it usually does anything]

[Farside's claim of Town Effort Saver shouldn't have been responsible for causing Starbuck to be unlynchable D1. Unless she isn't an effort saver, or if there's something like a showstopper lyncher that was targetting Starbuck (but that seems somewhat unlikely)]

[So we can't really know for sure that farside was what she claimed. She's definitely vanilla now as long as she isn't a werewolf. I'm pretty positive that Pork is a JoAT, Ico is a friendly neighbour, and I am a oneshotizer, though.]

[Porkens]

I didn’t get to my hellbooks analysis yet, is she the one who called showstopper lynched?

[Porkens]

Nope it was MT afaict

[Chateau Lobby]

Quick (9) -

Titus

, farside22,

hellbooks

,

Battle Mage

,

Ircher

,

Doctor Drew

, boring (porkens), Chateau Lobby, TrueSoulEnergy [LYNCH!]

Two Girls One Vote (9) - Iconeum, Chateau Lobby,

Titus

, Pigman (looker),

Battle Mage

,

ManateeDude

,

Doctor Drew

, Chemist1422(MT),

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

Ircher (7) -

Titus

, boring (pork), farside22,

Doctor Drew

,

ManateeDude

, Chateau Lobby,

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

hellbooks (7) - farside22,

Starbuck, Titus,

TrueSoulEnergy, Morning Tweet, Porkens,

ManateeDude

[LYNCH!]

ManateeDude (7) -

Battle Mage

, Porkens, Chateau Lobby, farside22, Morning Tweet,

Starbuck, Titus

[LYNCH!]

So what your showing us here is you were on every lynch with hellbooks except hers.

Or that TSE on both of the scum lynches. TSE and MT are pining me the most when I compare all lynch VCAs. Porkens is still sus to me.

TSE, MT, and Pork in that order for my preferred lynch order.

[Wtf and Looker doesn't even register as sus to you?]

Oh Looker isn't on any wagons... I didn't consider that type of positioning when I threw this list together.

[Chateau Lobby]

[

Iconeum

Chateau’s shielder clam is plausible but as card dealer he would be very well aware of the yellow card effects and that would have a lot of the same effect.

But I got a blue card last night.

[Chateau Lobby]

Due to a new site rule, the ruleset (excluding standard wincons) and votecounts have been edited to remove a certain word. Since the intent of the rule change is to disassociate said word from Mafia games, the ruleset has been edited in a way to hide the fact said word existed in the ruleset. Eliminate will be the replacement for this game.

Good on MS!

[Porkens]

Is that everything you feel like to commenting on?

[Chateau Lobby]

Is that everything you feel like to commenting on?

Please don't be so vague. Just ask me what you want.

[Looker]

Ok so yeah unless Farside is a Neutral role that can choose their own abilities then yeah they are Town.

I guess this game boils down to reading the Grand Idea Mafia thread? Twice the homework for the price of one.

What role/which page?

Oh Looker isn't on any wagons... I didn't consider that type of positioning when I threw this list together.

What does this mean? You didn't take a stance on it, so I don't know if you're expecting a response.

[Chateau Lobby]

Oh Looker isn't on any wagons... I didn't consider that type of positioning when I threw this list together.

What does this mean? You didn't take a stance on it, so I don't know if you're expecting a response.

As to what it means, I don't have a strong feeling one way or the other atm. But it is for sure notable and for sure it pings me.

[Looker]

Oh Looker isn't on any wagons... I didn't consider that type of positioning when I threw this list together.

What does this mean? You didn't take a stance on it, so I don't know if you're expecting a response.

As to what it means, I don't have a strong feeling one way or the other atm. But it is for sure notable and for sure it pings me.

How does it "ping" you if you "don't have a strong feeling one way or the other" about it?

[Morning Tweet]

[So we can lynch one player and roleblock one player. I'm going to remove myself, Ico, and Pork from contention. Ico is town. Obviously if we're going to try to roleblock we need Pork alive. If you want to dispute me being in the sus pile then i'm open to hearing it, but my role cannot be the card dealer]

[Exile pool - Looker, Chateau, Farside, TSE] (want to aim for card dealer)
[Roleblock pool - Looker, Chateau, Farside, TSE] (can be anyone)

[...]

[Farside's role could easily have been up to no good. Effort Saver is by no means confirmed. HOWEVER. She is most likely vanillaized now. That means she can't be the card dealer -- we're still getting cards, are we not?]

[I want to believe Chateau is somehow behind some of the nightkills being blocked. There should be two deaths per night. And yet there weren't. Not even fucking close. But he's just a modded doctor. Hm.]

[TSE correctly called that BM is town on D2, claiming that his role is knowledgable townie. However. If TSE is mafia, he could have noticed the post restriction and used hellbook's list of roles. That would have made BM confirmed town right off the bat. HOWEVER AGAIN: TSE voted for BM in RVS and made a weird comment. Am i correct in assuming this was a soft?]

[Looker is simply a "Orange Townie", correct? He never voted against hellbooks and went with her a lot. Hm.]

[...]

[Based off this analysis, we should probably remove farside from the exilepool. She can't be the card dealer I believe. Also based off of this analysis, I don't think TSE can be the card dealer. He seems to have always been aiming for BM in some way. He consistently seemed to want to say he knows something abt BM]

[Exile pool - Looker, Chateau] (want to aim for card dealer)
[Roleblock pool - Looker, Chateau, Farside, TSE] (can be anyone)

[...]

[Chateau and TSE should not have ability charges left if they're scum. I oneshotized them a while ago. Looker has one shot remaining if he has an ability.]

[TSE has been consistently against all scum, including hellbooks. He also has consistently been with BM whether it be sheeping him or defending him. I'd like to take TSE off the table today.]

[Farside was vanillaized night 3. Still no deaths night 4. I don't think her role is behind it. It's probably Chateau's (regardless of whether he's being truthful or not). And Chateau has no charges left.]

[It feels like Looker is the only eligible player left to be the card dealer to me. What about you guys?]

[...]

[Exile pool - Looker] (want to aim for card dealer)
[Roleblock pool - Chateau, Farside] (can be anyone)

[Chateau has no shots and Farside is vanillaized. All they have left is to kill. They could be a part of any faction. I don't know which is a better roleblock. I'd say Chateau probably]

VOTE: Looker

Vote Roleblock: Chateau

[Morning Tweet]

VOTE: chetau

I’ll roleblock tse tonight

I'm good with this. I think the card dealer happens at the end of the day, because that is when I receive a card.

I'm going to be damn curious why some many players died night 5. Can't wait to see the mod notes on this game when it's over.

[y are we roleblocking TSE over Chateau]

[TSE i oneshotized N1. Chateau i oneshotized 2 nights back. Both shouldnt have abilities. we should pick between them which is more likely to be scum, since all we're trying to stop is the kill. and i think that's Chateau as long as im not wrong on TSE]

[Porkens]

You 1 shorted chetau 2 nights back? He repost using his ability every night:

I guess I can claim now since it will be asked of me sooner than later. And besides last night was the last night that I could have used my ability since I got the ability restriction yesterday.

I am Town Shielder

Targets:
N1: Drew
N2: Titus
N3: Titus
N4: BM
N5: Bingle

Not sure what happened last night but I should have protected Bingle.

I thought of the TSE/HB connection, hence the roleblock there, but...
I think with that revelation yeah we kindly escort looker Out the door and RB chetau.

VOTE: looker

[Iconeum]

VOTE: Looker

fine with RB'ing CL

[Porkens]

That’s a hammer

[Porkens]

Ok here it goes. I asked the mod what would happen if we got down to two unaligned scum, what would happen. He confirmed that both scum factions would tie. I’m werewolf and I’ll kill iconeum. If the other scum is still alive, kill someone else. I’m putting all my money on this, but if we just lynched card dealerbom fucked anyway too many clears. And I claimed wolf already and it’s only a matter of time till you figure that out lol.

Oh and please god don’t let looker have a blue card

[Porkens]

To be clear I kill iconeum, you (chetau please be dealer) don’t kill me, you won’t survive too many clears. Kill someone else, then there are 4, we nolynch tomorrow and kill the last two.

Also sorry Ifigênia fucking up here.

[Porkens]

Chetau are you the dealer?