Two Vigclaims

[GreyICE]

Since it came up in a game (now over).
You have a player claim 2-shot vig, this gets cc by a player claiming x-shotvig (could be one).
You are in a game that was revieved for beeing normal and balanced by mini-normalreviewers.
Do you lynch in the vigs or outside?

Vig doesn't counterclaim during the day phase, question is irrelevant.

[GreyICE]

Grey: You get that that realy happened in a game, right?

Then I'm super sad.

The real vig should shoot the fake one at night.

the scenario was that a scum Odd-Night BP claimed 2-shot Vig at L-1

there was a JOAT with a 1-shot Vig, who counterclaimed on the basis that

-

roles were NAI by game design.

scum could easily have gotten docs, JKs, BPs, etc

- because of this, he assumed scum would only claim vig if they had some means of protection

setup spec heavily indicated the roles were incompatible in the same setup

an argument then ensued over whether the players should lynch elsewhere and allow a cross-shoot to happen, or to just lynch the original vig claim

A mod handing vigs to scum wants the town to lose.

That being said, always lynch the main claim over the counterclaim. You'll be right like 95% of the time.

[GreyICE]

In that case the town vig should shoot the vig fakeclaim. If they fail, counterclaim.

Also the original person claiming was scum, the counterclaimer was town. This is how it goes 95% of the time, and most of the remaining 5% is townies counterclaiming other townies.

[GreyICE]

Grey: So at the moment you would have lynched the first claimer?

Hell no, I'd tell them to crosskill and then if they were both still alive lynch the first claimer the next day.