What would you include in a Normal Græylist?

[Jake The Wolfie]

Please define "Graylist"

[Jake The Wolfie]

For my graylist, I would want roles which are fun to have 1 or 2 of in a game, but not for the majority, or even powered majority to game.

For starters, I would allow some more neutraly roles to exist, such as the following:

Citizen - You wish to see the Mafia dead, but aren't a town member.
Scoundrel - You wish to see the Town dead, but aren't a mafia member.

Mercenary - You provide protection to X players, A, B, ... and C. If more than Y of your targets die, you will exit the game in a loss. You win if at least Y of your targets survive, even if you are dead.

Now for the actual roles, and not just alignments.

Redirector - Redirect your target from player A to player B. Your target will be notified about their new target.
Bus Driver - Bus Driver + Any players targeting players A or B will be notified about their new target.
(Optional: Allow all Power Roles to instead silently De-Activate their ability if Redirected.)

Named roles.

And let's add some modifiers because why not

Limited Deathproof (You cannot be 100% prevented from dying, otherwise your team might as well win outright)
Tree Stump (Initially starts out as alive, can at any time choose to become a tree stump. If they are killed before or during their choice, they will still die)
Auto-[Role] - A role which can only self-target. If the role in question is a protective role (such as a doctor), then it must be limited.

[Jake The Wolfie]

ash, as in Jæk

[Jake The Wolfie]

So a Mafia without their factional kill?