Theme Test Market

[Maruchan]

would there be any interest in a new grand idea upick?
Exampels:
viewtopic.php?f=84&t=76258
viewtopic.php?f=84&t=67652

haven't hosted in a few years and these were always the most fun to me

Probably. Especially since your games seem to allow the especially bastard roles (unlimited dayvig Jester, lol!)

Oh yes, I hate veto-ing a horrible role in mafia. Read the one with the plethora of night-based post-graveyard shit where the entire game was a clusterfuck of "how would these interact?" as a mod.

[Cook]

Fallout: New Vegas Large Theme.

I need people to bounce this idea off of.

[Ythan]

I would be tempted to play that.

[Cook]

Anyone interested in a semi-open of this?

3d20

– you roll three dice and you get a role.

[T3]

Anyone interested in a semi-open of this?

3d20

– you roll three dice and you get a role.

Weird crazy setup? Definitely interested.

[Gamma Emerald]

I’m considering running a Survivor Legends UPick in the somewhat near future and I kinda wanna hear what people would want from it, would a more traditional mafia experience but with roles based on the player picks be preferred or should I strive for a Mafia-Survivor hybrid? Would a Redemption Island/other return method be wanted? How to integrate “challenges”?

[Cook]

I’m considering running a Survivor Legends UPick in the somewhat near future and I kinda wanna hear what people would want from it, would a more traditional mafia experience but with roles based on the player picks be preferred or should I strive for a Mafia-Survivor hybrid? Would a Redemption Island/other return method be wanted? How to integrate “challenges”?

similar questions to answer to City Games's Old Mamanuca.

[Save The Dragons]

I’m considering running a Survivor Legends UPick in the somewhat near future and I kinda wanna hear what people would want from it, would a more traditional mafia experience but with roles based on the player picks be preferred or should I strive for a Mafia-Survivor hybrid? Would a Redemption Island/other return method be wanted? How to integrate “challenges”?

reach out to Cephrir, he ran something like this a few years ago

[Gamma Emerald]

I knew he'd be someone to keep in mind but wasn't aware he actually ran a thing like that

[Cook]

Paperclip Maximizer Mafia.

Based slightly off of Universal Paperclips and also Paperclip Maximizer. Would feature a mechanic surrounding needing to hit quotas of paperclips.

[Cook]

Jackbox Mafia.

PM me if interested in helping design.

[Jake The Wolfie]

Salted 2 Mafia, a Parody of Splatoon 2, featuring Splat Tim!

PM me if you'd be interesting in something similar to this.

[Mizzytastic]

Any interest in 'UPick a Normal'?

players pick a normal legal town and scum power role, and can submit a preference for town, scum and/or vanilla - I create a setup based on those submissions, with some randomising elements to minimise any biases I have and hopefully getting it reviewed by a member of the normal comittee

[Ythan]

Sounds fun but I'd check up front with the normal reviewers before you start doing the other work.

Oh obviously you mean as a theme. Sounds fun.

[redtea]

Pagetop mafia?
Where every pagetop gives an advantage?
No spamming allowrd?

geriatric pagetop mafia...?

[Korina]

Jackbox Mafia.

PM me if interested in helping design.

Jackbox Mafia has been done in marathon queues before. IIRC, how it worked was:
Winner chooses to eliminate someone, and if there was I think seven or eight people, mafia get a NK on top of the winner choosing who to eliminate.
Game just progresses until one side is gone.

Not sure if this was what you wanted, but it would be a good schematic to build off of.

[Cook]

Jackbox Mafia.

PM me if interested in helping design.

Jackbox Mafia has been done in marathon queues before. IIRC, how it worked was:
Winner chooses to eliminate someone, and if there was I think seven or eight people, mafia get a NK on top of the winner choosing who to eliminate.
Game just progresses until one side is gone.

Not sure if this was what you wanted, but it would be a good schematic to build off of.

I think I'd do this as a series of games based on each party pack.

Eventually, we'll catch up...

[Azelf Ann]

.

[Cook]

speedrunning/agdq mafia?

roles flavored around either runners or commonly spedran games, with abilities flavored around the tricks you do to gain time? mafia flavored around cheaters.

[Cabd]

speedrunning/agdq mafia?

roles flavored around either runners or commonly spedran games, with abilities flavored around the tricks you do to gain time? mafia flavored around cheaters.

If you kept it as a micro or a mini theme you could probably do one game per each of the major franchise entries for example I'm pretty sure that the summoning salt history of Mario 64 any percent could fill an entire mini theme by itself.

[MegAzumarill]

Would anybody be interested in a "Fusion" Upick?

Each player submits a single pick. Each player has their role become a fusion of some elements of their pick and of another players pick.

For some examples of fused roles

Spoiler:

Take a fusion of a Doctor and a Vengeful. They could prevent a random night kill the night after their elimination. If they are mafia-aligned it could instead make their teammates ninjas/godfathers the night after elimination (thus ""protecting"" them from investigation)

A fusion of a bus driver and a paranoid gun owner could be an ability to redirect players that visit them into visiting themselves (Like a mirror). This could work for either alignment.

A fusion of a Traffic Analyst and a Viglilante could kill the target only if they are in a PT.

I'd be hosting this in January most likely if there is interest

[Nancy Drew 39]

Would anybody be interested in a "Fusion" Upick?

Each player submits a single pick. Each player has their role become a fusion of some elements of their pick and of another players pick.

For some examples of fused roles

Spoiler:

Take a fusion of a Doctor and a Vengeful. They could prevent a random night kill the night after their elimination. If they are mafia-aligned it could instead make their teammates ninjas/godfathers the night after elimination (thus ""protecting"" them from investigation)

A fusion of a bus driver and a paranoid gun owner could be an ability to redirect players that visit them into visiting themselves (Like a mirror). This could work for either alignment.

A fusion of a Traffic Analyst and a Viglilante could kill the target only if they are in a PT.

I'd be hosting this in January most likely if there is interest

Sounds really cool Meg, I’d definitely be interested.

[TemporalLich]

Would anyone be interested in playing Broken Bubble Grand Idea Mafia?

It is a Grand Idea Mafia mutation where players may discuss the game while it is still ongoing. (but still may not discuss other ongoing games of course!)

[Greeting]

I have a loose idea. A kind of April Fool's Game Mafia game. Which has power roles, but all of them are useless or not very useful.

Examples of roles:

Town Power Roles: Town Crier (every Night Phase they get to submit a message which will contain up to 100 words but cannot mention any player or role in the game, the message will be posted at the start of the following Day), Drunk Cop (every Night Phase they get a random read, which has a 50% accuracy), Voiceless (their votes do not count in the tally), Drunk Texter (they get to send a message to the host every Night Phase, the meaning of it will be reversed, it will be rephrased and then sent to a random player)

Mafia Power Roles: Mafia Cop (a Cop, but aligned with the Mafia), Self-Vigilante (They can only target themselves)

I might put in one town and one mafia role in the game, which will have one shot-only, and, with a bit of luck might actually help them. Thoughts?

[lilith2013]

I’d recommend making a new thread and asking for opinions there. This thread is for gauging interest on themes, not reviewing/advising on setups.