In post 52, UberNinja wrote:No really. By all means; let's.
It's a terrible idea and you should be ashamed for thinking otherwise.
In post 52, UberNinja wrote:No really. By all means; let's.
In post 54, chamber wrote:I think scummies as they are are deeply flawed, if no one else is with me on that then I see why you'd be so adverse to my suggestion.
ITT, elitism over people most people don't care about?In post 61, Kublai Khan wrote:Also, I really think we should have aHall of Fame. Now that mafiascum.net is 10 years old, those whose join dates are more than 10 years should be eligible for induction (n number of inductees per year or whatever).
...which never gets nominated?Nuwen 57 wrote:Right now site meta already features too much anti-town claiming and gambiting for the hell of it.
I'd be on board with this as a compromise.In post 63, zoraster wrote:Best Moment In a Mafia game isn't a bad idea.
In post 61, Kublai Khan wrote:But I understand IceGuy's argument and think that maybe we could have a Best Moment in a Mafia Game award to highlight particularly good plays or particularly funny or memorable moments.
In post 74, quadz08 wrote:...
Very rarely have I seen a truly hilarious moment also be a moment of truly good play.
In post 75, SleepyKrew wrote:Khan, how is someone supposed to judge whether the strategic genius of a move is better or worse than the comedic genius of an exchange?
In post 74, quadz08 wrote:For example, in Fate's Destiny Mafia, Spyrex posted an image in-thread that I think literally every player in the game fell of their chairs laughing at. Would I have nominated it for funniest moment? Absolutely. Good play? Hell no. While the categories are not mutually exclusive, the overlap is so small that it makes no sense to group them together.