The reason people don't like cults is their alignment changes midgame. Balance like that is needed because otherwise its near impossible to bring down the cult, but its still something players are not happy to have happen to them. You don't (shouldn't) want to have two months of your life invested and then suddenly have none of that apply to a new win condition.In post 24, reinoe wrote:What does everyone else think of the X-SHOT idea for cults? Is it really as bad as Tierce made it out to be?
Cult Balance Thread
- LlamaFluff
-
LlamaFluff Jack of All Trades
- LlamaFluff
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9561
- Joined: May 3, 2008
- Location: California
- Contact:
- Cabd
-
Cabd QT Sniper
- Cabd
- QT Sniper
- QT Sniper
- Posts: 15496
- Joined: February 3, 2013
It's also unfun to be the town left behind.
Let's say the recruitment is two-shot.
Congrats, you're a townie on day four, and all of your prior reads are 100% usless. Hope you like reliving day one four times!ShowHave retired for good; Life is too busy to have time or energy for mafia. It was fun~
And then, a Miracle, a Dance Game and a flight of fancy struck, one more game into the abyss
- Natirasha
-
Natirasha Jack of All Trades
- Natirasha
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9041
- Joined: February 18, 2008
- Location: preening her feathers
I think to flat-out say 'cults are bad noooooo you suck for wanting a cult' is poor and naive.
But cults are tough to both balance and make fun.
So there's that.Current Avatar: Dr. Contessa(OC, art by @pastelpuffin)- Psyche
-
Psyche he/theySurvivor
- Psyche
he/they- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 10573
- Joined: April 28, 2011
- Pronoun: he/they
- Eden
-
Eden Townie
- Eden
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 85
- Joined: February 16, 2014
- Location: Baton Rouge, LA
no it's not, there's no "discipline" in playing scummy or not playing pro-town so you don't get converted and change your wincon, it'sIn post 23, mykonian wrote:
Bingo, that's about discipline.In post 13, Eden wrote:
It's not "my alignment changes so I won't play to win," it's "my alignment changes so IIn post 10, mykonian wrote:There's a couple of issues beyond "my allignment changes I won't play to win because of that" which might depend on your players discipline. I don't think that's the worst.can'tplay to win if I'm playing optimally." If you start off as town, being the most obviously town player makes you a priority target for conversion, just like it would for a nightkill. It's okay to be a priority target for a nightkill because your alignment doesn't change when you're nightkilled; you've still played to your objectives. When you're converted, everything you've done before has actively worked against your win condition, assuming you are playing to it from the start. And the more you try to play to your initial win condition, the more you've worked against your win condition post-conversion. And of course if you just don't do anything you won't get converted at all.
It encourages that refuge of the inexperienced,hedging-- "I'm gonna behave scummy enough to be a viable ML instead of being obvtown so I can live longer!" -- instead of just playing with proper town fundamentals. It teaches placing a premium on survival instead of scumhunting so that you can have a chance to win, which ruins the entire point of the town/mafia dynamic in the first place.suboptimal play that shouldn't be encouraged
EDIT: strikeout area was too vague. it's not a matter of discipline here, because the incentives are such that town plays scummy in order to stay town. it destroys the entire purpose of the town/mafia dynamic in the first place, because if you try to catch the mafia instead of stalling out and waffling around, you get converted, and if you sit around and don't do anything, you don't get converted. this incentivizes town to act like scum and to kill people who try to solve the puzzle because if you try to solve the puzzle, you get converted, and your previous effort actively works against you. and when town act like scum, stalling around and not making themselves a threat, they play right into scum's hands by wasting time when time works against them
+1In post 28, Psyche wrote:look at all of these people you just put down without really any substantiation“Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” - Henry David Thoreau- mykonian
-
mykonian Frisian Shoulder-Demon
- mykonian
- Frisian Shoulder-Demon
- Frisian Shoulder-Demon
- Posts: 11963
- Joined: August 27, 2008
- Eden
-
Eden Townie
- Eden
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 85
- Joined: February 16, 2014
- Location: Baton Rouge, LA
imo as a power role it's a goofy gimmick that distracts the town's ability to scumhunt, and clearly suboptimal to just playing the game straight with proper fundamentals. you don't have to act scummy to avoid getting nightkilled as a PR if you encourage everyone around you to play well enough to merit a nightkill as wellIn post 30, mykonian wrote:it's like playing scummy so you don't get nightkilled. As powerrole that's fine, but hard to do. As VT it's simply not good play. Doesn't mean that some people won't do it.
make it so it's the optimal strategy foreveryone in the game(as trying any harder puts you at appreciable risk of conversion and setting yourself back worse) and you've got a right clusterfuck on your hands
granted that i haven't played but maybe 4-5 major conversion games (plenty more with like a 1-shot mafia converter but not as main mechanic), but every single one i've played has played out the same way:
* only 3-4 townies bother to scumhunt at all because they see their team isn't doing anything because everyone else is hedging
* those townies get converted and lynched immediately
* town gets steamrolled due to inactivity and/or village-idiot-level poor play to avoid being converted“Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” - Henry David Thoreau-
-
NuclearBurrito Townie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 8
- Joined: February 11, 2018
You could just use the method ToL uses. Have a cultfia with a mafioso (that can be promoted into) and Bulletproof Cult leader with a cooldown(which cannot). Then give them a member limit. From there you can have roles that block conversions and others that block nightkills. You could even make some power rolls immune like the cop. Another way to do it is to let people convert into the cult leader but then make the night kill x-shot or possibly even require killing your own members to use. Again if you have a way to block conversions like with kills and the faction itself has nightkills to counterplay it and a cooldown and member limit to prevent the exponential growth problem it is very possible to have a balanced and fun conversion game. If you don't think that this would work then look up throne of lies.- GuyInFreezer
-
GuyInFreezer Magical Girl
- GuyInFreezer
- Magical Girl
- Magical Girl
- Posts: 18078
- Joined: January 23, 2013
- Location: In your wall
Show"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae- BBmolla
-
BBmolla Open Book
- BBmolla
- Open Book
- Open Book
- Posts: 24301
- Joined: May 29, 2011
this works for 20 minute games, not for 3 month games.In post 32, NuclearBurrito wrote:You could just use the method ToL uses. Have a cultfia with a mafioso (that can be promoted into) and Bulletproof Cult leader with a cooldown(which cannot). Then give them a member limit. From there you can have roles that block conversions and others that block nightkills. You could even make some power rolls immune like the cop. Another way to do it is to let people convert into the cult leader but then make the night kill x-shot or possibly even require killing your own members to use. Again if you have a way to block conversions like with kills and the faction itself has nightkills to counterplay it and a cooldown and member limit to prevent the exponential growth problem it is very possible to have a balanced and fun conversion game. If you don't think that this would work then look up throne of lies.Come see me in the Great American Melodrama in Oceano- callforjudgement
-
callforjudgement Microprocessor
- callforjudgement
- Microprocessor
- Microprocessor
- Posts: 3972
- Joined: September 1, 2011
Something I've been thinking about is a Cult with a factional recruit (i.e. no leader) but when the Cult successfully recruits someone, the recruiter dies.
This is very comparable to a regular Mafia group in terms of nightplay balance (slightly more scumsided, but not much). However, it's considerably more scumsided in terms of dayplay. Those seems like fixable problems, though, as it's the runaway nightplay of a Cult that makes it so hard to balance.scum· scam · seam · team · term · tern · torn ·town- BBmolla
-
BBmolla Open Book
- BBmolla
- Open Book
- Open Book
- Posts: 24301
- Joined: May 29, 2011
- callforjudgement
-
callforjudgement Microprocessor
- callforjudgement
- Microprocessor
- Microprocessor
- Posts: 3972
- Joined: September 1, 2011
- Who
-
Who Yes?
- Who
- Yes?
- Yes?
- Posts: 4745
- Joined: March 22, 2013
- Location: Third Base
- callforjudgement
-
callforjudgement Microprocessor
- callforjudgement
- Microprocessor
- Microprocessor
- Posts: 3972
- Joined: September 1, 2011
White flag is a good idea.
Repeatedly no-lynching so that everyone wins is actually a pretty funny tactic, but I don't think it works (the remaining townies get endgamed once cult controls half the town, as they can stop the no-lynching during the day).scum· scam · seam · team · term · tern · torn ·town- Who
-
Who Yes?
- Who
- Yes?
- Yes?
- Posts: 4745
- Joined: March 22, 2013
- Location: Third Base
If there's only one cultist left, that's everyone but one person, hence the need for white flag.In post 39, callforjudgement wrote:White flag is a good idea.
Repeatedly no-lynching so that everyone wins is actually a pretty funny tactic, but I don't think it works (the remaining townies get endgamed once cult controls half the town, as they can stop the no-lynching during the day).Who said that?
Chamber. It's all a conspiracy.
Or is it?6Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
- Who
- callforjudgement
- Who
- callforjudgement
- BBmolla
- callforjudgement
- BBmolla
- GuyInFreezer
- Eden
- mykonian
- Eden
- Psyche
- Natirasha
- Cabd
- LlamaFluff