The Scumvey 1.0

[Aeronaut]

Hey everyone!

So, in an effort to improve my own personal modding, (because there's always room for improvement), I've been making a short survey that I plan on possibly implementing to the postgame of my games. The idea stems from a conversation in one of the Scummys threads about ways to improve that system.

While this isn't quite that, I'm curious what things you guys think of something like this. It would be entirely private (e.g. over PM), and right now I'm trying to find a way to do this so people are honest about the game instead of trying to be nice and giving good scores. I also get that not everyone is going to take the time to do it, but I did take measures to make it pretty short and painless, and if even a few players at the end of the game gave their thoughts it would certainly help out. Just curious about what you guys think of this idea, + if you have categories / elements to add. It's sort of in the first stages right now. Thanks!

Scumvey 1.3

Player Performances	Score	M.V.P.(s)	Comments
Town Performance	/10	-	-
Scum Performance	/10	-	-
Third Party/Werewolf Team Performance (If Applicable) [/color]	/10	-	-

Modding	Score	Comments
Votecounts (Were they frequent enough, easy to read, etc.)	/5	-
Mod Presence (Was it too little or too much?)	/5	-
Problem Solving/Fairness (Was the mod too strict or too loose?)	/5	-
Setup	Score	Comments
Originality (Did the setup incorporate new or cool ideas?)	/5	-
Enjoyability (Was the setup fun to play?)	/5	-
Balance (Did you feel it was fair to both sides?)	/5	-
Flavor (If applicable)	/5	-

Overall Enjoyment	Score
(Regardless of other scores, how much did you personally enjoy playing this game?)	/100

Additional Comments

If you have any additional comments, write them here! Thanks so much for taking the survey, it's quite helpful!

EDIT 1: Added "Personal enjoyment" score that reflects the players individual enjoyment of the game, regardless of the other scoring.
EDIT 2: Changed "Right it here" to "Write it here"
EDIT 3: Multiple other grammar/spelling errors

[Vampirate]

Seems good to me.

[Vampirate]

Only thing I would add are a Note section for all 3 for players to put their own thoughts in.

[Vampirate]

You can also include a section for each player individually as well.

[Aeronaut]

Well that's what the "comments" part is.

The notes is just general things if they wanted.


Yea, toying with the idea of specific players but honestly I feel like A) sometimes it's hard to judge the impact of just one player unless they were insanely good, or horrendously bad, and B) people will certainly be biased and give people who DIDNT screw them over good scores, etc. so idk there

[Vampirate]

Feedback is feedback and regardless the results are going to be skewed either way.

Plus it's just fun to see how people think you did at the end of the game.

[Vi]

zoraster had a system for these while he was the Large Theme List Mod. Contact him, etc.

[Aeronaut]

Oh yea! Thanks vi

[Aeronaut]

Oh god I wrote "right them here"

*gross*

[Untrod Tripod]

don't forget "dick size"

[Aeronaut]

Oh yea

[YurikoJasmine]

this sumvey looks fantastic. i'd say most of the time the players' interaction is what influences my mafia experience most.

nonetheless better modding = more enjoyment!

[Aeronaut]

+1

[SilverWolf]

Great idea, I would totally answer these surveys.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I really love this. Would you be opposed to other mods using it?

[Aeronaut]

Nah go ahead! No patent pending, anyone can use this if so choose. It's for the community!

[Bellaphant]

This is really good, btw <3

[BBmolla]

I'll probably steal this.