When were you amazed by someone else's play?

[GuiltyLion]

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum

couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

[Accountant]

I think I mentioned somewhere that DDDD is the only player that I have continued to townread after he flipped scum

[mastina]

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum
couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

My little JaeReed is all grown up. <3

[Titus]

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum
couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

My little JaeReed is all grown up. <3

Can we coparent?

[Burgerking]

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum

couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

he prolly got lucky.

i played a game with him and he was pretty bad

[VysePresident]

Plotinus as newbie Town in We Didn't Playtest this Mafia. So transparently Town, and one of the most level-headed and intelligent players I've seen.

Lemme see, Postie as scum had a really scary ability to get on people's good side. I know Radiant blamed himself, but she fooled all of us so thoroughly. She managed to be the most effective white knight for me utilizing private QTs to make me think she was absolutely sincere, and went on to an easy win despite her scumbuddy dying day 1. Nobody suspected her, even in the dead thread.

BBMolla is a chill guy who managed to play Town's silliness super effectively in WDPT Mafia. He's still one of my favorite all time scumbuddies, and I would enjoy scumming with him again sometime when I have time to play this silly game again.

That's it off the top of my head.

[Psyche]

nacho as town was troublesome
as scum too

[Aj The Epic]

I've played against Town Nacho before and the majority of my team would freak out about it. I normally didn't, and then would come to regret it 2 days in... The issue is Nacho has such a good read on so many players that it's hard for anyone who plays with him commonly to get away with any mistakes.

[JaeReed]

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum
couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

My little JaeReed is all grown up. <3

Can we coparent?

You're all way too nice to me.

JaeReed is probably the most terrifying town player that I've ever encountered as scum

couldn't pull any of my tricks on him and he just relentlessly called me and my scumbuddy on our bullshit over and over

he prolly got lucky.

i played a game with him and he was pretty bad

Yeah, my focus that game was to not get nightkilled. I tracked 2/3 mafia to the kills though so I figure that's a decent tradeoff. I won't be playing purposely scummy again though, since it looks like I was still considered for the nightkill anyway N1, which means it didn't really have the intended effect.

[Raskolnikov]

Hey jae it's been a while!
Remember when charl faked an inno on the scum and we all panicked for a solid hour till he came back

[JaeReed]

^ well that certainly was a play that amazed me.