Scummies Nominations 2019

[Alisae]

LOL WE TOLD ZOR LIKE 20 TIMES TO ADD IT AND HE STILL DIDN’T ADD IT.

Feel free to submit Moment of brilliance nominations in thread

[Alisae]

I’ll try to get the issue fixed but it might not happen for atleast 2 weeks cuz I’m busy

Speaking of which
I doubt I’ll be able to process any nominations from the 2nd to the 12th, my gf is visiting during that time and I know that my attention is going on her 24/7 so...

[Lycanfire]

anti nom scummies most improved

[Liger_Zero]

Id like to submit

Iconeum for moment of brilliance

for StarCraft II Legacy of the Void Mafia.

He played extraordinarily well, had perfect reads and was able to help a disorganized, apathetic town, in order to get them together to avoid mislynches and push 2 scum lynches in order for town to win the game.

[Alisae]

I plan on updating this with all of the current nominations tomorrow or tonight!

[Almost50]

Id like to submit

Iconeum for moment of brilliance

for StarCraft II Legacy of the Void Mafia.

He played extraordinarily well, had perfect reads and was able to help a disorganized, apathetic town, in order to get them together to avoid mislynches and push 2 scum lynches in order for town to win the game.

^^ Icon gets my vote here too

[Ankamius]

Thirding the Iconeum nom

[Boonskiies]

Is Moment of Brilliance award not able to be picked on the Nomination Form?

That reminds me. I never got around to doing this. I also nominated a couple things for Goodfellas and 3rd Party.

Nominating

Ras

for

Moment of Brilliance

for his work in BooneyToonz X: Boonin' It In The Slums.

Ras, after accidentally sending some links on the quote numbers to his own personal Private Thread, which obviously was unauthorized to anyone who clicked them, it looked like a hard Mafia slip, and was immediately called out, but was saved by Awestfie who faked a Mason claim. This at least got him through the first day and night phase. Ras was an Odd-Night Cop, and he targeted Night 1 the same player that the Mafia chose to kill that night. He decided to trust his reads, which he had done a lot of analysis on, to fake a guilty on scum RC Car, the hydra of RCEnigma and Mcqueen, and they didn't really know how to defend themselves from it. Ras then retracted that fake guilty immediately after they were hammered and said his real guilty was on The Last Knight, who was scum, and was defending the RC slot. On top of that, Ras then called out who the other 2 scum members were based simply on their play and gave a plan of action for Daveas, a Night 2/3 Town Vigilante to shoot those other 2 scum slots. Ras single handedly proved an entire scum team of 4 and caught them by the end of Day 2. This game ended Night 3 because of 2 perfect Vigilante shots, and 2 fake guilties. Normally, I wouldn't like this kind of risk, but this isn't the usual from Ras, and he trusted his reads. Had he even gone wrong just a little bit, he could have thrown the game for town, but that is the definition of "Moment of Brilliance". It was a perfect game. He also theorized about the potential of their being a role that could split the Lovers, because one of the Lovers was Mafia, and they knew it, and lo and behold, there was!

[Gamma Emerald]

That should also count for Master Strategist

[Jingle]

Having not read the game in question it seems like all of his good play there was specifically non mechanical, other than the scum lover spec, so I'm not sure Master Strategist fits at all.

I'm also reluctant to reward fakeclaiming guilties as town, although perhaps that's less awful in context.

[Flavor Leaf]

Having not read the game in question it seems like all of his good play there was specifically non mechanical, other than the scum lover spec, so I'm not sure Master Strategist fits at all.

I'm also reluctant to reward fakeclaiming guilties as town, although perhaps that's less awful in context.

While I agree that I wouldn't nominate Ras for Master Strategist here, I think there's an area for that specifically.

I was actually pondering the idea of when The Last Knight claimed Sticky Fruit instead of Fruit, and ScumProfii immediately thought "hmm, I wonder if he meant regular Fruit", and then adapted his play to make sure that the Sticky Fruit confusion was still there, which I think was actually pretty strong mechanical play from Profii. The confusion on the Sticky Fruit ended up being a BIG part of LAST NIGHT TOMORROW.

[Jingle]

I would support changing Master Strategist to be both alignments or making a similar scum award. I'm not sure profii's would fit because it ended up backfiring and getting him lynched, compared to say xtox from the same game convincing town to give him a vigshot, successfully hiding it, and then negotiating his way out of a damning fakeclaim in order to prevent a town autowin by shooting, vigging, and roleblocking all at the same time to slip an incredibly tight noose setting Nero up for the win.

[Flavor Leaf]

Oh yeah, that’s a town only award

[Lycanfire]

I think the point of master strategist is meant to break games in favor as town, whereas if you're scum it's just good scumplay. See: Reasonably Rational in Steven Universe 2 rigging just about every event in favor of scum. I think it's a very one dimensional award and if you give a shit about the person you're nominating, nom them Don Corleone instead.

[Alisae]

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah
will update soon, defs before end of the week

[Alisae]

Id like to submit

Iconeum for moment of brilliance

for StarCraft II Legacy of the Void Mafia.

He played extraordinarily well, had perfect reads and was able to help a disorganized, apathetic town, in order to get them together to avoid mislynches and push 2 scum lynches in order for town to win the game.

^^ Icon gets my vote here too

Thirding the Iconeum nom

If any of you two also want to add to the write up for that nomination I'll add ya to the charts


all of the nominations I recieved SHOULD be up there if you think I missed one you remember me making let me know I added
2 moment of brilliance noms
1 white knight nom
1 goodfellas nom
and a bunch of best third party noms

[Pink Ball]

Ali I'm new to this and I want to nominate RC's Undertale for Paperback Writter, what do I have to do?

[Alisae]

You have to fill out the form in the op, but if you want to write up your nomination here I'll fill in the form for you.

[Pink Ball]

I'll check the op, thanks!

[Alisae]

np glad to help ;D

[Flavor Leaf]

Xtoxm’s nomination is from BooneyToonz X: Boonin’ It In The Slums. viewtopic.php?f=3&t=79391

It’s labeled as the Sorcerer game. Maybe I messed that up.

[Alisae]

Could have been me to tbh I was really stoned when I went through that sheet I tired to fuck up as least as I possibly could but BooneyToonz games all sound the same to me by name ;D

[Alisae]

either way, its definitely fixed now

[Alisae]

Guys I have an announcement for ywall and you're gonna love it.

We're introducing a new award:
Best Marathon

we're still going to work out some stuff like for example, what is the name for the award, a banner (which might not actually be done until later or if we redo some of the other banners, like for example the banners for some of the new awards are due for changes), and what the actual description for it is.

But I HIGHLY suggest looking through marathons to see what you think should get an award.

[the worst]

That is a fantastic award. I'll do some digging later!