Newbie 1917 - Game Over

[Thespio]

Thanks for modding Micc
Flawless modding as always!
please release my PT

Town did great!
the SEs killed it and the newbie townies did great too once everything got rolling

sorry for the tough loss scum-team
you guys were playing against a stacked deck here

So at my old firm I blocked your creepy photo, and When I got to this new one and logged in I was genuinely upset that I had to see it again :p

[TTTT]

i saw the lolhammer but didn't want to give it away and i could've SWORN TTTT and NMSA gave it away and that was the last thing i read before i went to work and i was like MOTHER FUCKERRRRRR YOU DWEEBS but it's okay it worked out i suppose...

NMSA and URAP gave it away
then we pushed to a pagetop and NMSA and I tried to cover it up
still can't believe we pulled that off

[NotMySpamAccount]

i saw the lolhammer but didn't want to give it away and i could've SWORN TTTT and NMSA gave it away and that was the last thing i read before i went to work and i was like MOTHER FUCKERRRRRR YOU DWEEBS but it's okay it worked out i suppose...

NMSA and URAP gave it away
then we pushed to a pagetop and NMSA and I tried to cover it up
still can't believe we pulled that off

Yeah we got lucky there I thought I had screwed it up.

[Thespio]

IDK we passed over Chen early on, so I thought we were safe but they were too eager and ended up in the spotlight again.

[u r a person 2]

FMPOV, the entire SN wagon was a fire drill

We were flailing and needed more for vca

[Micc]

Thanks for modding Micc
Flawless modding as always!
please release my PT

Thanks!

TTTT's personal thread is here.

[chennisden]

gg nerds

[chennisden]

damn i need to lurk more as scum

[GuiltyLion]

he also kinda softed a PR

lol I noticed this too, that was part of why I was backing off him a little bit

[u r a person 2]

damn i need to lurk more as scum

but just a little bit more

Keep that confidence in your scum posting. That's how the best here do it ;P

[chennisden]

ty URAP

dang i dont think i would've lost so bad if i read the gambit correctly. next time i wont claim mafia during twilight (i was actually thinking of pretending to be REALLY FRUSTRATED with your lynch since OMGUS you lynched tracker)

i think the tracker fakeclaim though for Row 1 is a little too powerful - wont be counterclaimed unless a Neapolitan would like to convince the entire town that they are Neap... which at worst case = they get NKed

also Thespio sorry for losing u the entire game

[chennisden]

hello guys

just sayin

greeting thread in first post is scum indicative

what makes you say that?

[u r a person 2]

hello guys

just sayin

greeting thread in first post is scum indicative

what makes you say that?

take a walk through the newbie games in my history if you want to see it for yourself

but i think it has caught or should have caught at least 1 scum in like 5 in a row now or something silly

[chennisden]

hmm given how often it happens id think scum would stop doing it

but ill take ur word for it

[NotMySpamAccount]

hello guys

just sayin

greeting thread in first post is scum indicative

what makes you say that?

take a walk through the newbie games in my history if you want to see it for yourself

but i think it has caught or should have caught at least 1 scum in like 5 in a row now or something silly

This caught me my first game. It's kinda uncanny how good it is.

[CsBlastoise]

Well, I'm back from my retreat (have been for a day and a half); glad the game ended before I even left on it.

…

…Also your night action result is spoilered in the most recent post.

All right, let's take a look:

Welcome CsBlastoise.

Your Night 1 investigation result is:

Spoiler:

Thespio is Mafia

Well, what do you know, I was right… but now I'm right

and

dead.

Here lies

CsBlastoise
Dedicated town cop

Requiescat In Pace

I find it odd a cop just flipped, he was read parrellel with me, now they’re dead when the split was between us... any chance scum popped him to ensure my lynch? Just asking someone to explain why scum me would kill him.

It would be stupid for scum

anyone

to have killed me. I think scum should do whatever possible to avoid narrowing down the pool of mislynches so that hopefully one of the other guys will be lynched instead. In other words:
1. Scum Thespio shouldn't have killed me because with me and him looking like the biggest scumreads, he was sure to be lynched quickly D2 if I was dead.
2. Scum!AnyoneElse should have kept me alive to keep mislynch options open.

CsBlastoise investigates Thespio - Thespio is Mafia
Thespio kills CsBlastoise - CsBlastoise is killed

Still think this was the best nk for our situation though

No, Thespio. Your best move would have been to roleblock me and leave me alive. It would have left me absolutely frustrated at not getting a night result and, frankly, rather disoriented because my D2 plan was to out you as scum even at the risk of my own (in-game) life (provided you

did

come up as scum).

[CsBlastoise]

…my D2 plan was to out you as scum

even at the risk of my own (in-game) life

(provided you

did

come up as scum).[/quote]Actually, had I gotten a scum result on Thespio and lived to tell the tale, I would have kind of

wanted

town to lynch me to prove my role claim, since, no matter what was going to happen, you still would have had the numbers to lynch him D3. Of course, if you guys had decided to believe me anyway and lynch Thespio D2, that would have been fine too. My only concern was the fear that you guys might mistake me for a gamethrowing townie.

Well, anyway, gg town. The win was honestly too easy, but why should we complain?

[CsBlastoise]

RIP I flipped up. Let's fix that quote:

…my D2 plan was to out you as scum

even at the risk of my own (in-game) life

(provided you

did

come up as scum).

Actually, had I gotten a scum result on Thespio and lived to tell the tale, I would have kind of

wanted

town to lynch me to prove my role claim, since, no matter what was going to happen, you still would have had the numbers to lynch him D3. Of course, if you guys had decided to believe me anyway and lynch Thespio D2, that would have been fine too. My only concern was the fear that you guys might mistake me for a gamethrowing townie.

Well, anyway, gg town. The win was honestly too easy, but why should we complain?

[Thespio]

No, Thespio. Your best move would have been to roleblock me and leave me alive. It would have left me absolutely frustrated at not getting a night result and, frankly, rather disoriented because my D2 plan was to out you as scum even at the risk of my own (in-game) life (provided you did come up as scum).

You are wrong, the flop from my scum buddy put you as an easy town read, I thought I could wifom a setup but my stance on my scum buddy made me to susp even for that. You were basicly guaranteed town, you were a PR, and I was at the end of a very thin fraying rope, it was the best lynch by far.

[PenguinPower]