Open 857 | Frienemies | Postgame

[fireisredsir]

well, only sometimes!

[Aristeia]

you're too nice to roll mafia, the alignment really doesn't suit you at all. <3

[fireisredsir]

looking at the plist i think my only really strong townread is vulture/std

i sort of like georgebailey's entrance but thats like just pure vibes. in terms of towniness per post he's pretty up there

im less sure on andante being town than i was before but still probably leaning that way? idk we'll see

[fireisredsir]

SS also vaguely towny bc of a couple posts that just feel like going out of his way to put himself out there more than id maybe expect him to do as scum? 918 and 944 especially just seem kinda sticking-neck-out posts

[fireisredsir]

hut, gamma, penguin, implosion has a scum or two in it imo

[Gamma Emerald]

hut, gamma, penguin, implosion has a scum or two in it imo

Why do you say this?

[Gamma Emerald]

That is to say, what do you feel like is the common thread between those players?

[Andante]

im less sure on andante being town than i was before but still probably leaning that way? idk we'll see

So I do some actual game related/towny stuff. and I lose the TR you had on me... cause you TR'd the non game related stuff??
What kind of logic is this?

[Andante]

unofficial Vote Count 1.datisi

PenguinPower (3):

VP Baltar, implosion, Datisi

hutmeil (3):

GeorgeBailey, fireisredsir, PenguinPower

fireisredsir (3):

Gamma Emerald, Aristeia, Save The Dragons

Save The Dragons (1):

hutmeil

Gamma Emerald (1):

Malakittens

not voting (2):

Something_Smart, Andante

okay, so

one of my biggest problems with a penguinpower yeet is that we don't learn much if he flips green. so here's what we're gonna do:

in your next post, if you're not voting for one of penguinpower/hutmeil, give some reasoning on who you'd prefer to vote for between the two of them, and why. if you don't wanna vote either, explain why and

offer alternatives

. if you *are* voting for one of them, say how good you feel about the vote and what you think about the competition.

reposting this so it's not lost on the other page (cough @andante cough)

(cough cough @datisi cough)

[fireisredsir]

That is to say, what do you feel like is the common thread between those players?

there isn't really a common thread i just don't really think at this time that the rest of the pl has 2+ scum in it, and it could be only 1

it's not exactly a super well-thought out thought its just what i was feelin

i do feel like there is some sort of thread between hut and penguin and penguin and implosion but im not really sure what the thread means if anything

[fireisredsir]

im less sure on andante being town than i was before but still probably leaning that way? idk we'll see

So I do some actual game related/towny stuff. and I lose the TR you had on me... cause you TR'd the non game related stuff??
What kind of logic is this?

no? i TRd you for your game-related content early on, and then now im less sure on that

[GeorgeBailey]

What do you mean by unsurprising here? I'm actually shocked and a little weirded out. Usually I get wagoned every D1 for funsies

Cause you seem to be the top town read here from what I was gathering at the time. You seem to be pretty townie this game is what I meant.

what is suspicious to me is that your scumread on vulture seems to be entirely based on that one point. that's like a fine point to rvs scumread someone for, but it feels like you're afraid or unable to produce new and unique content and that's why you're hanging on that one singular point. i don't really see you noticing new things, engaging with the main direction of the game unprompted, or reacting to people's posts that aren't about yourself. i do see that you did these things in your towngame

Mind meld with Fire, i like it

Glad the holiday minister of maple syrup has let you join us!

Trudeau himself rode on a moose to tell me aboot it

[Gamma Emerald]

i sort of like georgebailey's entrance but thats like just pure vibes. in terms of towniness per post he's pretty up there

Explain this

[Datisi]

hutmeil (3): GeorgeBailey, fireisredsir, PenguinPower
PenguinPower (3): VP Baltar, implosion, Datisi
fireisredsir (2): Gamma Emerald, Aristeia, Save The Dragons

@andante, what do you think about these wagons
@george, what do you think about these wagons

[Datisi]

looking at the plist i think my only really strong townread is vulture/std

how is this std different than coalition std

[GeorgeBailey]

@george, what do you think about these wagons

Not a fan of the fire wagon, the Hutmeil wagon dynamic is interesting, since the two other wagons are voting for him.


Penguin is like, why?

Wait, why are you even voting Penguin? I can't find much in your ISO on why you scumread Pengu.

You vote for him, then say we wont learn much from the wagon, then say you stopped townreading him a while ago but nothing to indicate that he's done anything scummy.

[GeorgeBailey]

VP Baltar

Spoiler:

Datisi

Spoiler:

Aristeia

Spoiler:

Gamma Emerald

Spoiler:

Malakittens

Spoiler:

hutmeil

Spoiler:

fireisredsir

Spoiler:

Something_Smart

Spoiler:

implosion

Spoiler:

PenguinPower

Spoiler:

STD

Spoiler:

Andante

Spoiler:

[Datisi]

Wait, why are you even voting Penguin? I can't find much in your ISO on why you scumread Pengu.

You vote for him, then say we wont learn much from the wagon, then say you stopped townreading him a while ago but nothing to indicate that he's done anything scummy.

the only existing scummy thing he's done is blaming his lack of effort on the mod not providing vc, and doing that weird dismissal of the mala wagon.

the non-existing scummy thing he's done is not giving jack shit about this game

i say we won't learn much from his wagon IF he's town, which i'm currently trying to counteract (: do you think he's town?

[fireisredsir]

i sort of like georgebailey's entrance but thats like just pure vibes. in terms of towniness per post he's pretty up there

Explain this

i liked what he said about hut and i liked the vibes of his mostly unreadable meme posting. ive never played with him so idk really what to expect but he feels like he's having fun and my gut says thats towny for him based on close to zero meta

[fireisredsir]

looking at the plist i think my only really strong townread is vulture/std

how is this std different than coalition std

its v different, he feels excited to be posting and is moving things forward and doing things unprompted and trying to solve. i also had a townread on vulture already

[Datisi]

@gamma what do you think about hutmeil and penguinpower

[Malakittens]

I gotta agree with Fire in regards to std

I think we got a town!std over a scum!std

[Datisi]

malakittens, please don't ignore me and the three main wagons and answer the question of how you feel about them and why are you lazily parking on gamma, kthxbye

[Andante]

@datisi

I see/understand the fire/hutmeil wagons, the penguin wagon, ehhh the penguin voters should explain their reads on fire/hut

I’d probably vote fire right now, saying I started towny but became nontowny?? I RECENTLY POSTED A READS LIST WITH SOLID READS… how is that becoming non towny??? half my initial posts were just meh… idk feels sus, fire prob maf, and hut? hut is nervous maf that can’t get into the game and is trying to put that on everything else… thus mentioned meta twice, and tried putting it on pace of the game… ONCE SOMEONE ELSE said something

Penguin actually got townier, but I can’t tell if it’s cause penguin town, or cause penguin read exactly why he was being SRed… idk fire/hut more sus right now

[Andante]

I gotta agree with Fire in regards to std

I think we got a town!std over a scum!std

you only agree with fire? I don’t think a single person here has outed a sr on dragons… like that’s not even like a hot take???