In post 631, davesaz wrote:Saying yes to the 1-shot or not 1-shot question tells scum who that PR is

Really? So you saying you're not a 1-shot PR tells scum who the PR is?? It could still be YOU. just not 1-shot!!!

Here are the remaining possible combinations of the remaining 2 letters:

CC (1-shot Vig): a Cop in the remaining 4 Townies

CD (1-shot Vig + 1-shot Cop): a Doctor in the remaining 3 Townies

CV (1-shot Cop): a Vig in the remaining 4 Townies

CB (1-shot Vig + 1-shot Cop): a RB in the remaining 3 Townies

DD (1-shot Vig + 1-shot Doc): a Doc in the remaining 3 Townies

DV (no claims): a Doc & a Vig in the remaining 5 Townies

DB (1-shot Vig): a Doc & a RB in the remaining 4 Townies

VV (1-shot Vig): a Vig in the remaining 4 Townies

VB (no claims): a Vig & a RB in the remaining 5 Townies

BB (1-shot RB): a RB in the remaining 4 Townies

Alternatively we have TT for the final 2 letters and we have no more PRs and SCUM ALREADY KNOW IT. (This should result in a 1-shot Vig claim as well)

Tell me what more info do scum gain in each case (assuming 1T, because OBVIOUSLY they gain no more info if it's TTT).

Let me re-format the table above (assuming we are in 1T) and what scum would get from them:

1- No claims: Doc/Vig or Vig/RB in a pool of 5 Townies. So? They are shooting someone anyway!

2- 1-shot Vig: a Cop OR a Vig OR Doc+RB in the remaining 4 Townies!! Which one? Whom to shoot???

3- 1-shot Cop: a Vig in the remaining 4 Townies. So?

4- 1-shot RB: a RB in the remaining 4 Townies...

5- 1-shot Vig + 1-shot Cop: a Doctor OR a RB in the remaining 3 Townies

6- 1-shot Vig + 1-shot Doc: a Doc in the remaining 3 Townies

The worst part is IF Cheeky was a 1-shot Cop/Vig there's NO WAY she would know if there's another 1-shot PR in the setup, and thus won't know if there would be 1 or 2 "VTs outed". If she was a full Doc/Vig/RB there's no way she would know if there will be claims to begin with, and if she's a full Cop the 1-shot Vig claiming doesn't give her away.

Now tell me gain, what does "any given claim" confirm to scum???