Open 726 - Revenge of the Vengeful (Endgame)

[Marshmallow Marshall]

By the way, should I self vote?

[IcemanCh]

OH that's too funny. The one guy leading town around and trying to control the way town is running decides to vote me when I push back a bit. HA.

That's ok. I'm convinced that MM is the scum. Lynch me and I'll get the scum menace.

[IcemanCh]

By the way, should I self vote?

This seems like scum trying to look town..... or in the off chance no one see's it that way a scum trying to get control of the NK.

[Almost50]

@ALmost50 you said you thought she was town but followed N_M anyway because you trusted him, how do you feel about that now

I still trust N_M if that's what you're asking. Nobody said he'd be 100% all the time, but he has a very good eye for scum. Also let's not forget N_M does not bus, so I have hard evidence he is Town.

[Almost50]

I am still skeptical, but I do think lynching in MM/Ice is the way to go because I do believe at least one is scum. HOWEVER, what if both are? The living one of the two will use that flip to clear himself.
What id one is Scum and the other is Town and we lynch the scumster? They won't venge the other and it will send us straight to WIFOM land.

But my choices are indeed limited, so it's up to Rei/N_M to finish this.

VOTE: Iceman

L-1

[Rei]

I am still skeptical, but I do think lynching in MM/Ice is the way to go because I do believe at least one is scum. HOWEVER, what if both are? The living one of the two will use that flip to clear himself.
What id one is Scum and the other is Town and we lynch the scumster? They won't venge the other and it will send us straight to WIFOM land.

But my choices are indeed limited, so it's up to Rei/N_M to finish this.

VOTE: Iceman

L-1

if the one we lynch is the scum then what we do is lynch the other one of the two tomorrow
and if he's town he venges the last scum

I kinda wanna see who nm wants to vote

[IcemanCh]

VOTE: Iceman

[Ankamius]

Vote Count 3.2

[3]

IcemanCh

- Marshmallow Marshall, Almost50, IcemanCh

[LYNCH]

Almost50 -
Marshmallow Marshall -
Not_Mafia -
Rei -


Not Voting (2): Not_Mafia, Rei

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2018-08-10 04:30:00) from now, or July 24th, 10:30 AM CST (GMT-6).

Prodding: N/A
Replacing: N/A

[Ankamius]

**IcemanCh has been lynched.**

IcemanCh was

Mafia Vengeful

.

**IcemanCh has (expired on 2018-07-30 23:30:00) to submit a vengekill. Day will begin at this time or when I receive a submission.**

[Ankamius]

**Not_Mafia has been vengekilled.**

Not_Mafia was

Town Vengeful

.

Day four begins.

[Ankamius]

Vote Count 4.1

Almost50 -
Marshmallow Marshall -
Rei -


Not Voting (3): Almost50, Marshmallow Marshall, Rei

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2018-08-12 07:40:00) from now, or August 12th, 7:40 AM CST (GMT-6).

Prodding: N/A
Replacing: N/A

[Almost50]

So, which one of you is the last culprit? I have argument for each and arguments against each, so I'm not going to do anything stupid.
I am willing to wait for both of you to talk and willing to engage either of you if so you wish.

[Rei]

I think I’ll do a case against him but I think it’s pretty obvious that on d2 i was the first to suggest iceman as scum before he was like “haha I’m kidding I don’t sus rei i sus everyone she suses basically “
He’s literally been doing the wolfiest stuff with the excuse of “fishing”

Also there’s still a paranoid part of me that thinks you knew nm was town because you’re mafia
Although I’m definitely leaning on mm more and have been since d1

[Rei]

Yeah I’ll case both of you after all

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Okay.... I am willing to be lynched myself. I will vengekill my scum read. I'm quite confident now. If I'm scum and I get lynched, scums lose, so you can all live happily ever after. If I'm town, then I vengekill and I believe I will be right ^^

[Rei]

huh interesting
how can you be so sure in your read tho
like personally, i'd rather lynch my scum lean and have them kill tha last person with me bec i am 100% sure I'm town, are you so willing to risk losing just for being confident in your scum read?

[Almost50]

Okay.... I am willing to be lynched myself. I will vengekill my scum read. I'm quite confident now. If I'm scum and I get lynched, scums lose, so you can all live happily ever after. If I'm town, then I vengekill and I believe I will be right ^^

On face value, this happens to be your towniest post all game!

P-edit:

@Rei: You're overlooking something: If he's scum town wins either way. If he is town though town still has a 50-50 chance. This offer does not come from scum.

You -on the other hand- sound like you want "someone else" lynched, and then hope they venge the other townie.

So, if I'm to be lynched myself I am 90% sure I'd be venging you over MM.

[Rei]

Actually A50, I hugely disagree
MM rn sounds like the "idealistic townie"
"You can lynch me guys! I'll just kill my scum lean and we'll win and everything will be fluff and rainbows!"

Thats not realistic. Yes I suspect MM but am I 100% sure of him? No I'm not. Just because I'm not sure of my read doesn't make me scum, it makes me a realistic townie.
And don't act like you wouldn't want the same because if your scum lean flips town you'd want them to kill the other person not you if you know you're town.

Let's stop acting like some angels because that is the truth, and if I was scum I definitely wouldn't mention that knowing how it would ake me look.

[Rei]

"@Rei: You're overlooking something: If he's scum town wins either way. If he is town though town still has a 50-50 chance. This offer does not come from scum."

well it obviously can if you're town and are buying into it

[Rei]

Lets just not act like I'm the only one who wants that because if you're 100% sure of your read then something's wrong with that

[Marshmallow Marshall]

huh interesting
how can you be so sure in your read tho
like personally, i'd rather lynch my scum lean and have them kill tha last person with me bec i am 100% sure I'm town, are you so willing to risk losing just for being confident in your scum read?

Because A50 has done many town things that could not come from a scum not you

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Actually A50, I hugely disagree
MM rn sounds like the "idealistic townie"
"You can lynch me guys! I'll just kill my scum lean and we'll win and everything will be fluff and rainbows!"

Thats not realistic. Yes I suspect MM but am I 100% sure of him? No I'm not. Just because I'm not sure of my read doesn't make me scum, it makes me a realistic townie.
And don't act like you wouldn't want the same because if your scum lean flips town you'd want them to kill the other person not you if you know you're town.

Let's stop acting like some angels because that is the truth, and if I was scum I definitely wouldn't mention that knowing how it would ake me look.

That's not realistic?? LOL! Vote me and I'll show you it's realistic

[Rei]

Wasnt i your top townie???? why am i suddenly the sum lean??????
Especially when i was the one who sused iceman first wth

you know what
you got it
VOTE: Marshmallow marshal

I refuse to believe this type of play is a townie
there's just no way in my mind
And if you're both gonna kill me if you flip town, then honestly to hell with it

if you both wanna lynch me too then go ahead, but dont blame me if i venge wrong because you guys wont consider all possiblities

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Actually A50, I hugely disagree
MM rn sounds like the "idealistic townie"
"You can lynch me guys! I'll just kill my scum lean and we'll win and everything will be fluff and rainbows!"

Thats not realistic. Yes I suspect MM but am I 100% sure of him? No I'm not. Just because I'm not sure of my read doesn't make me scum, it makes me a realistic townie.
And don't act like you wouldn't want the same because if your scum lean flips town you'd want them to kill the other person not you if you know you're town.

Let's stop acting like some angels because that is the truth, and if I was scum I definitely wouldn't mention that knowing how it would ake me look.

Also I'll give you a tip, coming from a shit scum but a good town player. When you're talking about what you do as town, limit your "if"s and when you're talking about scum, put your "if"s when you can. This, whatever your alignment is. You tend to say "if" when you're talking about town more than about scum. This is, obviously, not the only reason I scum read you, but it makes me more confident.

Also, it's not because my play was unusual that you get a free pass to insult me and talk as if I was a noob or w/e.

[Rei]

mm why dont you lynch me if you're so confident in who the scum is like you said