Open 765: Haunted Village (Over)

[NorwegianboyEE]

We can’t just focus on one guy, need alternatives to spur discussion.
VOTE: Tris

[NorwegianboyEE]

Voting because Tris’s logic on post 1343 is bad.

[tris]

what's bad about it?

[tris]

We can’t just focus on one guy, need alternatives to spur discussion.
VOTE: Tris

Why do you need to say this? Don't you townread fake-PP. insn't that enough for you not to vote him?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Makes no sense to me. Why would Phoenix "expect the wagon to dissolve"? What makes you think that?

[tris]

when there's no counterwagons, people decide he can't be scum because otherwise there's be a counterwagon. and in the meantime he's doing things that appear towny, but in my opinion are not actually town indicative. i think he's just keeping up appearances

[Something_Smart]

Makes no sense to me.

Not a scumtell.

[Something_Smart]

he's doing things that appear towny, but in my opinion are not actually town indicative.

Uhhhhh this sounds like a contradiction.

Appear towny to whom?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Regarding the Phoenix wagon, it is just as likely that scum sees a wagon forming on a townie Phoenix and they are just kicking back and relaxing because they don't feel the need to do anything. And that's why there are no counter-wagons.

[tris]

he's doing things that appear towny, but in my opinion are not actually town indicative.

Uhhhhh this sounds like a contradiction.

Appear towny to whom?

idk. not anyone specifically. things that some people might find town, but that scum could do easily. Why is that a contradiction? people read things incorrectly

[Something_Smart]

It would have been a contradiction if you said they appeared towny to you, which is what your vagueness implied.

[Beta Sapphire]

VOTE: Vorkuta

There I was starting to seriously SR you in one pages time, I look back through the content before and see this

What do you think my read on your slot is now SS?

[Beta Sapphire]

-M

[Beta Sapphire]

Also, both heads of this hydra were SRing RCE last time we talked. We’d both be okay with fake-PP but I think I want it more there. Mostly because I’m being lazy tho, and haven’t totally made up my mind/ISO dived there yet.

We disagree about norwegian. I think he’s scum, ofhrz thinks he’s town but we haven’t had a chance to talk it out yet due to ITL activity reduction reasons.

-M

[Something_Smart]

What do you think my read on your slot is now SS?

Confused.

[Beta Sapphire]

You’re confused or you think my read is confused?

-M

[Something_Smart]

The latter.

[NaCl]

I wasn't even around for the majority of it. How should I know?

I mean, statistically it's likely that scum was on it at some point, but that's not the same thing.

I was mostly asking you since (IIRC) you weren't on the wagon or against it, so I wanted to know what you think.



I'm still happy with a Norwegian lynch, my second preference is Benhalkum. Moving my vote there since it seems slightly more likely VOTE: Benhalkum. Although now I'm kind of not liking Something_Smart either after his random and pointless vote on Vorkuta at this point.

Tris and RCE are both meh wagons for me, I could go along because time's running out, but I'm not the most excited about either of them.

I'm still against the Fake-PP wagon.

[Something_Smart]

Although now I'm kind of not liking Something_Smart either after his random and pointless vote on Vorkuta at this point.

Where's the scum motivation in that?

[NaCl]

Well, there are all the other wagons to choose from, 1.5 days before the deadline, and rather than putting out your thoughts on them, you're randomly voting someone unrelated for no reason at all.

[Beta Sapphire]

The latter.

Could you tell me more about why this is/just expand on the point?

I’ll tell you where I’m at on you afterwards, I promise. I just wanna do this first in case you throw me in the other direction with your answer

-M

[NaCl]

It could be trying to stall, or possibly not knowing what to think of things. Although it is a bit weak, I agree.

Why do you think your vote is useful where it is?

[Something_Smart]

Well, there are all the other wagons to choose from, 1.5 days before the deadline, and rather than putting out your thoughts on them, you're randomly voting someone unrelated for no reason at all.

I have given my thoughts on the only wagon that's achieved any significance. I have no further thoughts to share about any wagon.

Should my vote be necessary to achieve a lynch, I will be more than happy to provide it.

(Also, I do have reasons for voting Vorkuta, as should be obvious no matter my alignment, but I chose not to share them.)

[Something_Smart]

Could you tell me more about why this is/just expand on the point?

I'm at a very different place with respect to this game as I was in PFUP (my recent replace-in being the main reason), and it's manifesting itself in weird behavior.

Given your experience with me, I wouldn't have expected you to know what to do with this weird behavior.

[Something_Smart]

Why do you think your vote is useful where it is?

It's not. I don't have any scumreads worthy of the name, so I don't think it would be useful anywhere.