Open 796: Haunted Village Game Over

[Noraa]

UNVOTE:

y

[Isis]

I don't think Noraa's analysis of Kai actually says that much about Kai's alignment, but it looks solvey to me

I kind of don't want to vote everything, which is every game nowadays

[Isis]

Noraa, why is + scummier than me?

[Noraa]

do you think you are scummier than plus?
I have made my case on plus and you very clear(and why I prefer plus lim for that matter). I don't think there's any reason why you should not know.

[Cobra Kai]

Your case on plus is he won’t (and literally can’t) explain his read on you.

[Isis]

Yeah I guess I kind of share the don't-get-it about finding plus scummy at all. I don't feel like you've outlined how there's more of a scum story than a townstory for what you're complaining about versus just not being happy with it.

[egotisi]

[edit from the future] alright, so i sat down to read this game. it took me an hour to go through 4 pages. it's past 1am and my brain is not working. mr bailey promised to get to this game after work, i'll get to it when i'm not deceased first thing in the morning. ok cool. thanks. [/edit]

Immediately paranoid of Noraa.

- Norwee

norwee do you have reads

re 334: the reason i asked is because the "there could be scum on this wagon i guess lol bc wagon fast" in very early stages of the game with nothing else pointing at is like. weaksauce and p easy to post as scum, especially if you don't say who and like, do nothing about your "read" there

though at this point i'm thinking i was mentally overreacting about my read about that situation

@egotisi, it’s been a while since you voted, and after expressing suspicion on Murdercat, you didn’t vote him. Is he your strongest scumread? Where are you at the moment?

george wanted to talk to me first, but then we never ended up talking about it
i'm in a vc with him atm, he says the unvote seemed lamist, but the response was fine

right now i'm at trying to read the thread but my eyes are glazing over as it's already past midnight

[consider this a

prodge

preview of an actual post? idk. i was awake until 5:30am yesterday. i'm feeling dead.]

-tisi

[Noraa]

I don't think Noraa's analysis of Kai actually says that much about Kai's alignment, but it looks solvey to me

I kind of don't want to vote everything, which is every game nowadays

my analysis of kai is actually prolly the least solvey thing I've done. You changing around based off of terrible reasons is quite questionable.

Your case on plus is he won’t (and literally can’t) explain his read on you.

is that not a valid reason? He has a "strong SR" yet he can't explain any of it. You can't even explain to murder why a few people are townie. Like his reads are all nothing if he can't back them up and it just feels like scum wanting to seem like he put in effort when he actually isnt.

[Dunnstral]

Don't use ongoing games as the basis for your read then hint vaguely at it in the game thread while never explaining anything, it NEVER goes well for you

[Cobra Kai]

He’s put effort into every other read. I think you’re nitpicking.

Ninja
^
Basically. Can we drop this now?

[MURDERCAT]

Don't use ongoing games as the basis for your read then hint vaguely at it in the game thread while never explaining anything, it NEVER goes well for you

Agree

[Isis]

I don't think Noraa's analysis of Kai actually says that much about Kai's alignment, but it looks solvey to me

I kind of don't want to vote everything, which is every game nowadays

my analysis of kai is actually prolly the least solvey thing I've done. You changing around based off of terrible reasons is quite questionable.

Your case on plus is he won’t (and literally can’t) explain his read on you.

is that not a valid reason? He has a "strong SR" yet he can't explain any of it. You can't even explain to murder why a few people are townie. Like his reads are all nothing if he can't back them up and it just feels like scum wanting to seem like he put in effort when he actually isnt.

what would you say is the most solvey thing you've done, Noraa

[Isis]

it's fine to post "I scumread X player and am not going to say why due to the ongoing games rule" btw. Just not more

[Cobra Kai]

I know you want to vote everyone, but are there any standouts in particular isis?

[Noraa]

Don't use ongoing games as the basis for your read then hint vaguely at it in the game thread while never explaining anything, it NEVER goes well for you

ah he can't explain because its ongoing?
that's bullshit. ongoing = no reason at all.
ongoing also = easy way to make it seem like ur solving when ur fucking not.

[Noraa]

I am his strongest SR yet the only evidence he has is an ongoing game?
No. If I was the strongest SR that deserves the vote(which is on me in case anyone missed that), he will have more reason that just "ohh ongoing game whoopsie can't say why"

[Noraa]

I can understand using ongoing games to judge someone and not being able to elaborate but if ur vote is on someone, u cannot fucking brush it off and be like "nope got no reasons that I can tell u cuz the games ongoing"

[Noraa]

No. fucking no. if your only reason is one singular game in general(tiny tiny sample size), that reason is already absolute garbage.

[Noraa]

not to mention hiding behind a site rule to not elaborate on a read.

[Noraa]

If I am a top SR, u literally cannot not provide a single reason. There is no way a reason based 100% on meta and one singular game can be good. You will provide a reason for SRing me otherwise I will literally death tunnel you

[Noraa]

what would you say is the most solvey thing you've done, Noraa

I've tried to solve multiple slots. I've tried to solve plus and you for the most part. Cobra isnt even someone I'm really trying too much to solve. I just dislike some things about them is all.

[Noraa]

Spoiler:

Don't use ongoing games as the basis for your read then hint vaguely at it in the game thread while never explaining anything, it NEVER goes well for you

ah he can't explain because its ongoing?
that's bullshit. ongoing = no reason at all.
ongoing also = easy way to make it seem like ur solving when ur fucking not.

I am his strongest SR yet the only evidence he has is an ongoing game?
No. If I was the strongest SR that deserves the vote(which is on me in case anyone missed that), he will have more reason that just "ohh ongoing game whoopsie can't say why"

I can understand using ongoing games to judge someone and not being able to elaborate but if ur vote is on someone, u cannot fucking brush it off and be like "nope got no reasons that I can tell u cuz the games ongoing"

No. fucking no. if your only reason is one singular game in general(tiny tiny sample size), that reason is already absolute garbage.

not to mention hiding behind a site rule to not elaborate on a read.

If I am a top SR, u literally cannot not provide a single reason. There is no way a reason based 100% on meta and one singular game can be good. You will provide a reason for SRing me otherwise I will literally death tunnel you

plus you better give me a damn reason otherwise I am pushing you to hell and back for not being able to defend a single read and for throwing shade at me for no literal reason.

[Noraa]

upsetti spaghetti Noraa is currently present in the chat

Spoiler:

[Cobra Kai]

I’m really tempted to vote Noraa here but I’m not sure if it’s scum being intentionally obstinate or town.

[MURDERCAT]

I feel like I've totally lost the thread of this game, I need to do some iso dives. Where is xofelf?