Mafiascum.net

on you and Isis, I felt the interaction between you didn't seem TvT, hence at least 1 scum. On you specifically, I think you are being very friendly and reasonable here, which although isn't AI, is making me a bit wary. Hard to explain I guess, just my gut saying you could be scum. Of the two of you, I think Isis is objectively scummier.

In post 209, Isis wrote:I'm town, but I don't think Noraa is. That answer from her doesn't bode well.

this, in particular, pinged me as potential scum distancing

VOTE: Isis as the most viable Day 1 play probably

The problem is that if isis ever flips green this game, I will immediately think you were setting up chain lynches here

In post 598, Battle Mage wrote:i don't know what you're saying here? i didn't say anything about playstyle?

I didn't read ur post right. disregard that sorry.

In post 599, Battle Mage wrote:ill come back to you on the other Q Noraa - will consult the ISOs again, as im riffing

kk

In post 603, Noraa wrote:The problem is that if isis ever flips green this game, I will immediately think you were setting up chain lynches here

That's fair enough!

Although having reflected I'm less sure you would be scum if Isis was town, so it wouldn't be automatic.

I think we flip Isis and see how it goes?

In post 606, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 603, Noraa wrote:The problem is that if isis ever flips green this game, I will immediately think you were setting up chain lynches here

That's fair enough!

Although having reflected I'm less sure you would be scum if Isis was town, so it wouldn't be automatic.

I think we flip Isis and see how it goes?

Idk Isis has been p quiet lately. I'd like to hear more from that slot.

I think "setting up chain lynches" is a little too conspiratorial. That's something I've seen feared since the dawn of time, but I've never gone into a scum PT afterwards and found out that scum actually set up an X or Y fully expecting to ruin two days with it.

Gesturing at a pair of players and saying you think there's at least one scum in there somewhere and picking one to try and see hasn't ever been a method I've ever found very strong, though.

wow the pedits

In post 608, Isis wrote:I think "setting up chain lynches" is a little too conspiratorial. That's something I've seen feared since the dawn of time, but I've never gone into a scum PT afterwards and found out that scum actually set up an X or Y fully expecting to ruin two days with it.

Gesturing at a pair of players and saying you think there's at least one scum in there somewhere and picking one to try and see hasn't ever been a method I've ever found very strong, though.

wow the pedits

i can say from personal experience, i have done that as scum.

you're probably right on the latter.

I have some curiousity about how worth that line of scumplay is, my belief that it's rare doesn't mean I believe it's a weak play.
That's kind of an offtopic curiousity though

In post 611, Isis wrote:I have some curiousity about how worth that line of scumplay is, my belief that it's rare doesn't mean I believe it's a weak play.
That's kind of an offtopic curiousity though

it depends doesnt it? in theory it's helpful and sometimes essential, but in practice you're right that people get legitimately antsy about it, and so there's a risk it backfires. I think being subtle about it is probably the best value scumplay.

In post 574, Noraa wrote:

In post 572, Cobra Kai wrote:Joyed and datisi hydra

Not sure on scumreads. Was planning to reread at some point. Nothing is standing out as overtly scummy- I don’t particularly understand why joyed or Noraa are the leading wagons presently. Feels TvT.

Battle mage and Taylor

Not sure at this point in time.

This is actually such a bad answer to murder's question.

I was intrigued by this actually, but I don't think you developed it?
Digame enemiga

In post 613, Isis wrote:

In post 574, Noraa wrote:

In post 572, Cobra Kai wrote:Joyed and datisi hydra

Not sure on scumreads. Was planning to reread at some point. Nothing is standing out as overtly scummy- I don’t particularly understand why joyed or Noraa are the leading wagons presently. Feels TvT.

Battle mage and Taylor

Not sure at this point in time.

This is actually such a bad answer to murder's question.

I was intrigued by this actually, but I don't think you developed it?
Digame enemiga

why it's bad? cuz I could write up something like that in less than a minute.

In post 562, Noraa wrote:Isis explain your progression on me.

Part of it is seeing you post stuff a lot that's ostensibly content but doesn't draw conclusions about other players. It reads to me like faux participation that's not organically leading to you developing reads that would naturally occur for town!Noraa.

Shifting stances a dozen times in a page is a better look.

If you feel like you deserve more airtime, I can try to talk about you more I guess, you upgraded your avatar for it huh. The other slots I've discussed as scummy have mitigating reasons I don't want to vote for them.

pedit: Are you saying you would be capable of write 572 in sixty seconds if you needed to and that's bad, or that you could spend sixty seconds explaining why 572 is bad if I repeated my request?

In post 615, Isis wrote: pedit: Are you saying you would be capable of write 572 in sixty seconds if you needed to and that's bad, or that you could spend sixty seconds explaining why 572 is bad if I repeated my request?

i dont believe this is a serious question

That slot has been pretty lurky and murder tried to engage them and they spent no time or effort on their reply

I scumhunt in a very fencesitty way and rarely draw firm conclusions but I think even my poor townplay has done more than them.

To clarify, I changed my avatar because I requested an avatar in a speakeasy thread. I figured I needed to change it to show the person who chose it for me that he didn't waste his time

Here lemme do some promotion for Panzer:
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=83480&start=250

I’m playing this game how I want to. If you want to eliminate me for it then that’s on you guys and I’m not taking blame for it.

I was asked off the cuff quick fire questions and answered off the cuff and quick fire.

In post 621, Isis wrote:UNVOTE:

Curious where you at Isis

In post 622, Cobra Kai wrote:I’m playing this game how I want to. If you want to eliminate me for it then that’s on you guys and I’m not taking blame for it.

I was asked off the cuff quick fire questions and answered off the cuff and quick fire.

dont AtE me