Open 835: D6 | Songs About Ronald Reagan | Day 5

[Galron]

If it's Egix, we have a double bus Day 3, when Taly and Egix could have limmed RH9.

And if it's A50, who wasn't voting, He and Taly could have hammered a town!RH9 pretty easily.

[Galron]

So that leaves Q, RH9 and me. I know it's not me, and I'm fairly certain it's not RH9, so I think Q needs re-evaluated.

And you know it's not me bc I wouldn't put myself in the POE like this.

[Galron]

The kill is actually kinda brilliant bc of the A50/Egix rivalry.

[Galron]

It doesn't make sense for A50 to hammer Taly there when there were still 3 or 4 days left in the phase.

[Galron]

I don't want to vote either of them yet. I think it may be neither and that nightkill was for max WIFOM because I think the obvious choices were Egix or A50.

Egix or A50 as the final scum, not as the Night Kill. I think maybe the kyouko/bloodhail Night Kill was made so that we'd argue about Egix vs A50 all day.

[Almost50]

So that leaves Q, RH9 and me. I know it's not me, and I'm fairly certain it's not RH9, so I think Q needs re-evaluated.

And you know it's not me bc I wouldn't put myself in the POE like this.

So, it's not Egix because of the double bussing, but it's NQ and it's STILL DOUBLE BUSSING?????

[Galron]

Oh shit. You're right. That doesn't work.

[Galron]

Is RH9 skilled enough to do this?

[Galron]

Or maybe it's just Egix.

[Galron]

If we lim Egix today, and he's town, we're in elo. I'm okay with that.

[Galron]

I don't know why egix would kill bloodhail though

[numberQ]

bloodhail came in strong and immediately put Egix at the bottom of his reads list. You could argue that just paints a target on Egix, but then again, blood was one of three next to myself and A50 who ALSO had Egix very low or at the bottom. So maybe it was just a matter of taking out someone he thought was dangerous.

[numberQ]

I'm nervous though. I don't know what I'd do or re-evaluate if we lim Egix and still end up going into Day 6. (Day 6 in D6 )

[numberQ]

Regardless I think this clears Galron in my book. I don't think scum puts this much effort into diverting attention away from the A50/Egix rivalry when it'd be easy to get two mislims in a row off it. Town Egix miiiiiiight lower my rating of A50 somewhat. Though ultimately I would probably call RH9 my second choice in a hypothetical ELo.

[numberQ]

I hate quad posting, but I forgot to say I'm holding off on an actual vote until we hear from Egix at least one more time.

[RH9]

Is RH9 skilled enough to do this?

I will give you the benefit of doubt.

[RH9]

I hate quad posting, but I forgot to say I'm holding off on an actual vote until we hear from Egix at least one more time.

Wisest decision ever. Let's hear the defence and then the jury can make their decision.
See how much I learnt.

[Egix96]

Please dither. I've strongly TRed A50 for a large portion of the game. Why is he the last scum?

The simple answer is that the way he acted towards the end of D4 makes no sense coming from town. I thought he was practically openwolfing. Plus I don't really see anyone else as scum here.

Why does scum!A50 NK bloodhail?

To frame me...

If it's Egix, we have a double bus Day 3, when Taly and Egix could have limmed RH9.

RH9 makes no sense as a scum counterwagon, and by play he's been town. New town to be sure, but town nonetheless.

I agree with this entirely.

Does scum bus both their partners to death like this? Assuming Taly does get limmed, and Egix is scum. I'm starting to feel a scumteam out of {Egix, Galron}, though I haven't looked back at the thread to point at concrete evidence. It's just pinging me.

Here we have what looks like a possible perspective slip.

What does everyone else think?

How so? You don't seem to have thought so at the time.

I hate quad posting, but I forgot to say I'm holding off on an actual vote until we hear from Egix at least one more time.

Wisest decision ever. Let's hear the defence and then the jury can make their decision.
See how much I learnt.

Fwiw I don't think there's much chance I will suddenly start posting up a storm and brainwashing everyone into not voting me, if that's what you're dreading.

[numberQ]

Please dither. I've strongly TRed A50 for a large portion of the game. Why is he the last scum?

The simple answer is that the way he acted towards the end of D4 makes no sense coming from town. I thought he was practically openwolfing. Plus I don't really see anyone else as scum here.

Are you talking about what I said at day start, where A50 put a narrative in your mouth? Saying that makes

no sense

as town is a bit of a stretch. I could see it coming from either side, it's more indicative of confidence than alignment imo. Confident scum, or confident town. If I'm off base and there's something else to his end of D4 play that pinged you let me know.

But overall this really just strikes me as scum faced with 4 players who are TRed to various extents and trying to build a flimsy case on one of them. Maybe RH9 is the more obvious mislim target since there was a decent amount of contention around his slot for a bit, but I don't think it's ridiculous that scum!Egix chooses A50 to attack over RH9.

VOTE: Egix

E-1 I believe?

[T3]

mod on vla until the 13th

Lazy mobile VC: Egix (2): Almost50, numberQ
Almost50 (1): Egix96

[Egix96]

Are you talking about what I said at day start, where A50 put a narrative in your mouth? Saying that makes no sense as town is a bit of a stretch

I meant him posting the "I lied" clip and all that.

[numberQ]

Huh, I did kind of gloss over that in the moment. A50, why did you lie there?

[T3]

Replacing Almost50.

[numberQ]

Well that's unfortunate. I don't even know if it's worth waiting for the replacement to chime in. I'll keep my vote here.

[RH9]

I'll hammer.
VOTE: Egix96