Concerning the answers to my questions :
Nachomamma8 wrote:As to why AntB doesn't believe what he says, refer to #175. The first quote is him saying his scumdar was pinged quite badly, and that brokenscraps's case "failed". And yet, no vote. This shows that his scumdar wasn't pinged that badly, since when people find scum, they put a vote along with their suspicions.
AntB voted brokenscraps right after he answered, what's suspicious about waiting for a target's defense before casting a vote?
Nachomamma8 wrote:The second quote demonstrates AntB dancing around the answer to a question far more than he needed to. Farside said he was voting for a crap reason, and all he needed to do is answer "a scumslip isn't a crap answer". Again, shows he doesn't believe what he says because he's afraid to just come right out and say it.
The wording leaves much room for improvement, but this is exactly what I understood when I read AntB's post : he DOES say a scum slip is a valid reason to vote.
Nachomamma8 wrote:The third quote just bleeds of crap. It's drawing scumteams this early in the game that seem to stem from being voted, although he tries to hide it in creative ways.
I call complete bullshit on this as a reason for your voting, as this was posted by AntB AFTER your vote!
Nachomamma8 wrote:There are a few reasons as to why I'm voting Archer. For one, his entrance into the game was scummy; he did not comment on brokenscraps tell on me, and he still made an RVS vote despite everything happening around him. Reads as scum trying to fit in, but not quite sure how. Then, there's the hatred for lurkers when he himself was lurking, which is of course hypocritical. But, the main reason for my vote is his response to yours. Instead of defending himself and posting why he wasn't making bad votes, or even asking you to clarify, he says you provided "no reasons", says that people who don't provide reasons are typically scum, and then asks him why you decided to vote him in this scummy way. This is deflection, not defense, and I don't like it at all.
And there you do it again! I am asking for your reasons *at the time of your vote*, I don't give a rat's ass about a reread exploited in retrospect! You said, in the same post as your vote :
Nachomamma8 wrote:lord_hur, I figured ALL of his posts give that feeling, especially when he's attacking a suspect in them.
How the hell could "that feeling you get from ALL of his posts" have referred to deflection, when this is the first time he is faced with a real attack in this game, and on top of that it had nothing to do with what I was talking about?
I want to know whether you believed in your attacks, as it is what gives me an opinion about your being scum or not!
Unvote
Vote Nachomamma8
*L-2*
This vote is very unlikely to move until you give me a satisfactory explanation about your voting motivations. Of course, that doesn't mean Archer (and, to a lesser degree, smashbro_of_the_SSS) is off the hook.
All lurkers unite! And jump off the nearest cliff. Now.